일화기억 회상 시 질문의 순서 바꾸기가 정보인출에 미치는 영향 = The Effect of Different Orders of Question on the Recalling Episodic Memory

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study aims to investigate the effect of forward and mixed-ordered question in the true and deceptive group on the recalling of episodic event. 80 college students were sorted into two(true vs. deceptive) groups. And again, they were randomly classified into forward question group and mixed-ordered question group. They were shown the video clip of theft, and interviewed according to 2 types of question-order. In first interview, they were free-recalling of the full contents of event, and in second interview, they were recalling of additional information about specific parts of video. All the interviews were recorded and written and analyzed written files. Major results are as follows: First, in second interview, new information in true group were more in mixed-ordered question than forward question. But deceptive group had no difference of acquired information between in mixed-ordered and forward question. Second, both true and deceptive group had more true information in mixed-ordered question than forward question. And deceptive group had more new untrue information in forward question than mixed-ordered question. This study found that mixed-ordered question would get more new true information than forward question in truth teller and liar in investigative interview.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구에서는 기억을 촉진시키는 면담 기법인 인지면담에서 제안하고 있는 질문의 순서 바꾸기 기법이 일화기억의 회상에 미치는 영향을 알아보았다. 화자의 거짓말 의도 여부에 따라 진실하게 진술하였을 때와 거짓으로 진술하였을 때, 회상 방향을 달리 한 질문의 순서 바꾸기 기법이 어떠한 효과를 나타내는지 살펴보았다. 이를 위해 심리학을 수강하는 대학생 총 80명을 대상으로 실험을 실시하였다. 참가자들은 절도 범죄에 대한 영상을 시청한 후 영상의 내용을 진실하게 진술할 것인지 거짓으로 진술할 것인지에 따라 두 집단으로 분류되었으며, 각 집단의 참가자들은 특정 부분에 대한 회상 시 순차순 질문순서에 따라 진술할 것인지 순차순과 역순이 혼합된 혼합순 질문순서에 따라 진술할 것인지에 따라 또 다시 무작위 분류되어 면담이 진행되었다. 그 결과, 진실 집단은 혼합순 질문순서를 따랐을 때가 순차순 질문순서를 따랐을 때에 비해 더 많은 정보를 보고하였으며, 거짓 집단은 질문순서에 따른 차이가 나타나지 않았다. 또한, 보고된 정보를 진실 정보와 거짓 정보로 나누어 살펴본 결과, 두 집단 모두 혼합순 질문순서를 따랐을 때가 순차순 질문순서를 따랐을 때에 비해 진실 정보는 더 많이, 거짓 정보는 더 적게 보고하였다. 이러한 결과를 토대로 수사면담 시 정보가(價)를 갖는 정보의 획득 방안에 대하여 논의하였다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김시업, "효율적인 수사면담을 위한단축형 인지면담 개발" 한국사회및성격심리학회 20 (20): 21-38, 2006

2 문옥영, "한국어 진술서에서 책임회피 시 나타나는 거짓의 언어·심리적 특징" 한국사회및성격심리학회 25 (25): 91-111, 2011

3 김미영, "인지면담의 네 가지 기법간 효과 비교 연구" 2 : 19-30, 2004

4 왕경수, "인지 부하와 교수 설계" 한국초등교육학회 22 (22): 491-522, 2009

5 김시업, "수사면담 시 라포가 진술의 양에 미치는 영향" 한국사회및성격심리학회 24 (24): 149-166, 2010

6 강 선, "사건에 대한 장기기억에서 역순회상의 인출 연구 : 복합탐색과 인지적 부담을 중심으로" 경기대학교 대학원 2014

7 조은경, "거짓말의 특징과 탐지" 한국심리학회 21 (21): 33-65, 2002

8 Ekman, P., "Why kids lie: how parents can encourage truthfulness" Scribner 1989

9 Kent C. H. L., "Trips Down Memory Lane : Recall Direction Affects the Subjective Distance of Past Events" 35 : 230-243, 2009

10 Longford, G., "The use of the cognitive interview by police officers trained on the National Investigative Interviewing Course" Institute of Police and Criminological Studies, University of Portsmouth 1996

11 McAdams, D. P., "The problem of narrative coherence" 19 : 109-125, 2006

12 DePaulo, B. M., "The motivational impairment effect in the communication of deception : Replications and extensions" 12 : 177-202, 1988

13 Singer, J. A., "The integrative function of narrative processing: Autobiographical memory, self-defining memory, and the life story of identity" Psycology Press 2004

14 Davis, M. R., "The efficacy of mnemonic components of the cognitive interview : towards a shortened Variant for time-critical investigative" 19 : 75-93, 2005

15 Holliday, R. E., "The effect of prior cognitive interview on children's acceptance of misinformation" 17 : 443-457, 2003

16 Murdock Jr, B. B., "The Serial Position Effect of Free Recall" 64 (64): 482-488, 1962

17 Page, M. P. A., "The Primacy Model : A New Model of Immediate Serial Recall" 105 (105): 761-778, 1998

18 Ekman, P., "Telling lies: Clues to deceit in the marketplace, politics and marriage" W. W. Norton 2001

19 Conrad, R., "Short-Term memory in the deaf : A test for speech coding" 63 : 173-180, 1972

20 Bower, G. H., "Scripts in Memory for Text" 11 : 177-218, 1979

21 Geiselman, R. E., "Reverse and forward recall of script-based texts" 4 : 141-144, 1990

22 Loftus, E. F., "Retrieving Multiple Autobiographical Memories" 3 (3): 280-294, 1985

23 Sentis, K. P., "Remembering schema-consistent information : Effects of a balance schema on recognition memory" 37 (37): 2200-2211, 1979

24 Geiselman, R. E., "Psychological Methods in Criminal Investigation and Evidence" Springer Publishing Company 191-215, 1989

25 Fisher, Ronald P., "Memory-enhancing techniques for investigative interviewing: the cognitive interview" Charles C Tomas 1992

26 Anna E., "Limited capacity to lie : Cognitive load interferes with being dishonest" 9 (9): 199-206, 2014

27 Conrad, R., "Information, acoustic confusion and memory span" 55 : 429-432, 1964

28 Jensen, A. G., "Individual differences in learning: Interference factors. Final Report, 1964" Office of Education 1897-, 1964

29 Vrij, A., "Increasing cognitive load to facilitate lie detection : The benefit of recalling an event in reverse order" 32 : 253-265, 2008

30 Vrij, A., "Imposing cognitive load to elicit cues to deceit: Inducing the reverse order technique naturally" 18 (18): 579-594, 2012

31 Skowronski, J. J., "How describing autobiographical events can affect autobiographical memories" 22 : 555-590, 2004

32 Virginia, M. R., "Forward and backward serial recall" 25 (25): 37-47, 1997

33 Li, S., "Forward and backward recall : Different retrieval process" 21 (21): 837-847, 1995

34 Thomas, J. G., "Forward and backward recall : Different response time patterns, Same retrieval order" 14 (14): 169-174, 2003

35 Geiselman, R. E., "Enhancement of eyewitness memory : An empirical evaluation of the cognitive interview" 12 : 74-80, 1984

36 Johnston, W. A., "Divided Attntion : A Vehicle for Monitoring Memory Processes" 83 (83): 164-170, 1970

37 Whitten Ⅱ, W. B., "Directed Search Through Auto-biographical Memory" 9 (9): 566-578, 1981

38 Vrij. A., "Detecting deceit via analysis of verbal and nonverbal behavior" 24 (24): 239-263, 2000

39 Depaulo, B. M., "Cues to deception" 129 : 74-118, 2003

40 Healy, A. F., "Coding of temporal-spatial patterns in short-term memory" 14 : 481-495, 1975

41 Boon, J. C. W., "Changing perspectives in cognitive interviewing" 1 : 59-69, 1994

42 Bireta, T. J., "Backward recall and benchmark effects of working memory" 38 (38): 279-291, 2010

43 O'Connor, N., "Backward and forward recall by deaf and hearing children" 28 : 83-92, 1976

44 Milne, R., "Back to Basics : A Componential Analysis of the Original Cognitive Interview Mnemonics with Three Age Groups" 16 : 743-752, 2002

45 Kahana, M. J., "Associative Retrieval Process in Free Recall" 24 (24): 103-108, 1996

46 Richard, R., "Applying cognitive models of deception to national security investigations : Considerations of psychological research, law, and ethical practice" 39 (39): 339-364, 2011

47 Eaves, R., "An evaluation of the efficacy of the mnemonic components of the cognitive interview" University of Middlesex 1992

48 Memon, A., "An empirical test of the mnemonic components of the cognitive interview" De Gruyter 1996

49 Clifford, B. R., "A field investigation of training in three methods of witness/victim investigative interviewing" 2 : 231-248, 1996

50 George, R., "A field evaluation of the cognitive interview"