The purpose of this study was to implement peer tutoring strategies to teach student s with reading comprehension learning disabilities (RCLD) who ex perience learning and emotional problems due to their learning disabilit ies . T his study examined t...
The purpose of this study was to implement peer tutoring strategies to teach student s with reading comprehension learning disabilities (RCLD) who ex perience learning and emotional problems due to their learning disabilit ies . T his study examined the effects of the peer tutoring strategies on reading comprehension and self - concept of tutees andtutors , and analyzed and compared differences in the four peer tutoring strategies. The four peer tut orin g strategies implemented in this study were (1) regular same- age peer tut oring (RS ), (2) regular cross - age peer tutoring (RC), (3) reading compreh ension learning disabilities same- age peer tutoring (LS ), (4) reading comprehension learning disabilities cross - age peer tutoring (LC). By comparing and analyzing the effects in implementing the peertutoring strategies, this study at tempted to examine the effective st rategies that cont ributed to improving tutee's reading comprehension and self - concept . This study also examined the effects on the reading comprehension and self-concept for those student s with RCLD who participated as tutors .
The subject s of the study were recruited from ten elementary schools in the Pusan metropolitan city in Korea. The tutees were 40 students with RCLD recruited from the fourth grade, and the tutors were 10 fouth graders from regular classes, 10 fouth graders with RCLD, 10 six th graders from regular classes , and 10 sixth graders with RCLD.
After having five pre- training sessions run by special education teachers (special education teachers whose students participated in the study ), the tutorsran their peer tutoringsessions with the tutees . Peer tut oring session s were conducted for 30 minutes for each session four t imes a week , totaling to twenty sessions for five comprehension was adapted from Korea language textbooks for fourth graders with elaborat ion strategies .
The results of intervention are as follow : First , the different peer tutoring str ategies showed differences in improvement in the tutees' reading comprehen sion . The cross - age peer tutoring was more effective than the same- age peer tutoring in reading comprehension. Also the regular peer tutoring howed more improvement in reading comprehension than the peer tutoring by the students with RCLD. Therefore it is desirable to place academically advanced and older students for peer tutoring to promote cognitive improvement of tut ees .
Secondly , there were no differences among the peer tutoring strategies in terms of improvement of self- concept of the tutees . This suggests that ability and age of tutors may not be that important in tutee ' definitional improvement . However , compared to the performance on pre- test , each group showed improvement in self - concept in the post - test . Therefore the peer tutoring h ad a positive impact on definitional improvement of the tutees .
Thirdly , the application of peer tutoring contributed significantly to improv ement of reading comprehension of the students who participated as tutors . T his implies that the students with RCLD who participated as tutors showed significant cognitive improvement through the experiences as the tutors in implementing the peer tutoring strategies .
Fourthly , the implementation of the peer tutoring strategies showed significant effect sin improvement in self - concept for those with RCLD who part icipated as tutors . This implies that the students with RCLD who participated as tutor s in implementation of the peer tutoring strategies made emotional improvement through the experiences as tutors .
In summary , the peer tutoring for students with RCLD was an effective strat egy for both tutors and tutees in terms of making cognitive and emotional improvement . In particular , to make the peer tutoring effective for tutees' cognitive improvement , age and ability of tutors need to be considered.