단토의 헤겔주의와 헤겔 미학의 현대성 = Danto's Hegelianism and the Contemporary Significance of Hegel's Aesthetics

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In this paper, I attempt to explain the characteristic features of Danto' Hegelianism and to show the contemporary significance of Hegel's aesthetics. There is no doubt that Danto is an important living figure in art theory and art criticism and Hegel is famous for his contributions to the philosophy of art and the history of art. It is well-known that, developing his theory of art,Danto presents his thesis of 'the End of Art' which Hegel also claimed nearly two centuries ago. It is also well-known that Danto's theory of art is partly founded on Hegel' s theory of art. In section II and III, I delineate Hegel's concept of art and Danto's idea of art,and compare Hegel' version of the thesis of 'the End of Art' with Danto's. And then I show in what respect Danto's theory of art depends on Hegel's thoughts. In section IV, I explain the consequences of Danto's theory of art which include 'pluralism' in contemporary art,and clarify to what extent they correspond to Hegel‘s theory of art. In conclusion, I maintain that Hegel's aesthetics has an actual significance as long as Danto's theory of art provides us with an important insight into the contemporary art world.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 장민한, "아서 단토의 미술종말론과 그 근거로서 팝 아트의 두 가지 함의" 현대미술사학회 (19) : 1-16, 2006

2 장민한, "미술비평에서 '예술계'의 역할 - 어서 단토의 이론을 중심으로" 한국미학회 (55) : 119-147, 2008

3 Gombrich, E. H., "‘The Father of art History'. A Reading of the Lectures on Aesthetics of G. W. Hegel(1770-1831). in : Tributes: Interpretations of our Cultural Tradition" 1984

4 Hegel, G. W. F., "Werke in 20 B änden" T heorie-Werkausgabe(=TWA) 1969

5 Hegel, G. W. F., "Vorlesungen über die Ästhetik III Bd. 15" TWA

6 Hegel, G. W. F., "Vorlesungen über die Ästhetik II Bd. 14" TWA

7 Hegel, G. W. F., "Vorlesungen über die Ästhetik I Bd. 13" TWA

8 Hegel, G. W. F., "Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Geschichte Bd. 12" TWA

9 Haapala, A., "The end of art and beyond : essays after Danto" 1999

10 Danto, A. C., "The Transfiguration of the Commonplace" 1981

11 Lyotard, J.-F., "The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge" 1984

12 Danto, A. C., "The Philosophical Disenfranchisement of Art" 1986

13 Danto, A. C., "The End of Art: A Philosophical Defense" 37 : 132-133, 1998

14 Henrich, D., "The Contemporary Relavance of Hegel's Aesthetics. in : G. W. F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, vol. 4" 419-426, 1993

15 Danto, A. C., "The Artworld" 61 : 571-584, 1964

16 Pinkard, T., "Symbolic, Classical, and Romantic Art. in : Hegel and the Arts, Evanston, Ill" 3-28, 2007

17 Danto, A. C., "Responses and Replies. in : Danto and His Critics" 1993

18 Solomon, R. C., "Hegel's Concept of "Geist". in : Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays" 125-149, 1972

19 Maker, W, "Hegel and Aesthetics" 2000

20 Kelly, M., "Essentialism and Historicism in Danto's Philosophy of Art" 37 (37): 30-43, 1998

21 Carroll, N., "Essence, Expression, and History: Arthur Danto's Philosophy of Art. in : Danto and His Critics" 79-106, 1993

22 Danto, A. C., "Encounters & Reflections : Art in the Historical Present" 1990

23 Danto, A. C., "Embodied meanings : critical essays & aesthetic meditations" 1994

24 Danto, A. C., "Beyond the Brillo Box: The Visual Arts in Post-historical Perspective" 1992

25 Hilmer, B., "Being Hegelian after Danto" 37 (37): 71-86, 1998

26 Solomon, R. C., "Atomism, Art and Arthur Danto's Hegelian Turn. in : Danto and His Critics" 107-126, 1993

27 Donough, M., "Art and History: Hegel on the End, the Beginning, and the Future of Art. in : Hegel and the Arts, Evanston, Ill" 179-215, 2007

28 Danto, A. C., "After the End of Art: Contemporary Art and Pale of History" 1997

29 Croce, B., "Aesthetic" 1967

30 Kudielka, R., "According to What: Art and the Philosophy of the 'End of Art'" 37 (37): 87-101, 1998

31 이성훈, "<브릴로 박스>는 예술의 종말을 신호하는가?" 한국미학예술학회 16 : 157-184, 2002