음악적 표현성에 대한 확장된 형식의 시뮬레이션 이론 = A Simulation Theory of Musical Expressivity - An Expanded Version

국문 초록 (Abstract)

이 글에서 필자는 코크레인의 `음악적 표현성의 시뮬레이션 이론`을 비판적으로 고찰한 후 이것을 더욱 정교화하고 확장하여 좀 더 포괄적이고 설득력 있는 이론으로서 `음악적 표현성에 대한 확장된 형식의 시뮬레이션 이론`을 제안한다. 청자에게 즉각적으로 환기되는 원초적 느낌을 대상으로 하는 `낮은 수준`의 시뮬레이션에 전념하는 코크레인의 이론은 음악의 즉각적이고 국부적인 정서표현성이 인식되는 기제는 어느 정도 성공적으로 해명하는 반면 인지적으로 고차원적인 정서에 대한 음악의 표현성이 인식되는 기제는 전혀 해명하지 못한다. 또한 코크레인의 이론은 청취 시 발생하는 음악과 청자 간의 역동적인 상호작용을 고려하지 않은 채 청자를 음악에 즉각적으로 반응하는 수동적인 존재자로서만 간주한다. 필자는 `높은 수준`의 시뮬레이션을 도입할 때 이러한 문제들이 해결된다고 주장하며 코크레인의 이론에 높은 수준의 시뮬레이션을 도입함으로써 코크레인의 이론을 확장할 것을 제안한다. 궁극적으로 필자는 필자가 제안하는 `음악적 표현성에 대한 확장된 형식의 시뮬레이션 이론`이 코크레인의 이론이 갖는 문제들뿐만 아니라 음악의 정서표현성에 대한 기존의 담론들이 가지는 문제들 역시 성공적으로 극복하며 그것들이 정당하게 주목하거나 명료한 설명을 제시하는 데 실패한 기제들에 대해 더 나은 해명을 제시한다고 주장한다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In this essay, I critically examine Cochrane`s `simulation theory of musical expressivity` (2009) and then propose its expanded version as an enhanced and more comprehensive theory. While Cochrane`s theory, which commits to the `low-level` simulation that concerns the primitive feelings immediately aroused in listeners, elucidates quite successfully the mechanism underlying our recognition of the musical expressivity at the local and cognitively low level, it fails to give an account of the mechanism underlying our recognition of the musical expressivity for cognitively higher emotions which usually needs a considerable span of musical unfolding. In addition, Cochrane`s theory generally overlooks the dynamic interaction between music and listeners and sees listeners as passive beings only to respond to music immediately. I argue that these problems would be solved when we introduce the `high-level` simulation and that we should therefore expand Cochrane`s theory embracing the `high-level` simulation. Ultimately, I argue that `the expanded version of a simulation theory of musical expressivity` as I suggest overcomes successfully not only the problems in Cochrane`s theory but also those in other theories on musical expressivity providing a better account of the mechanism to which those theories fail to give due attention or to offer clarification.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Gallese, Vittorio, "What Is So Special about Embodied Simulation?" 15 (15): 512-519, 2011

2 Cochrane, Tom, "Using the Persona to Express Complex Emotion in Music" 29 (29): 264-275, 2010

3 Pellegrino, Giuseppe di, "Understanding Motor Events: A Neurophysiological Study" 91 (91): 176-180, 1992

4 Davies, Stephen, "Themes in the Philosophy of Music" Oxford University Press 152-168, 2003

5 Levinson, Jerrold, "The Pleasures of Aesthetics: Philosophical Essays" Cornell University Press 90-125, 1996

6 Nussbaum, Charles, "The Musical Representation: Meaning, Ontology, and Emotion" The MIT Press 2007

7 Cone, Edward T., "The Composer’s Voice" California University Press 1974

8 Kivy, Peter, "Sound and Sentiment: An Essay on the Musical Emotions, Including the Complete Text of the Corded Shell, The Arts and Their Philosophies" Temple University Press 1989

9 Goldman, Alvin I., "Simulating Minds: The Philosophy, Psychology, and Neuroscience of Mindreading" Oxford University Press 2006

10 Karl, Gregory, "Shostakovich's Tenth Symphony and the Musical Expression of Cognitively Complex Emotions" 53 (53): 401-415, 1995

11 Stueber, Karsten, "Rediscovering Empathy: Agency, Folk Psychology, and the Human Sciences" The MIT Press 2006

12 Ridley, Aaron, "Philosophers on Music: Experience, Meaning, and Work" Oxford University Press 130-146, 2007

13 Matravers, Derek, "Philosophers on Music: Experience, Meaning and Work" Oxford University Press 95-116, 2007

14 Davies, Stephen, "Musical Meaning and Expression" Cornell University Press 1994

15 Peters, Deniz, "Musical Empathy, Emotional Co-Constitution, and the “Musical Other”" 10 (10): 2-15, 2015

16 Ridley, Aaron, "Music, Value, and the Passions" Cornell University Press 1995

17 Cochrane, Tom, "Music, Emotions, and the Influence of Cognitive Sciences" 5 (5): 978-988, 2010

18 Levinson, Jerrold, "Music, Art, and Metaphysics: Essays in Philosophical Aesthetics" Cornell University Press 336-375, 1990

19 Maus, Fred Everett, "Music as Drama" 10 : 56-73, 1988

20 Goldman, Alvin I., "Mirroring, Simulating, and Mindreading" 24 (24): 235-252, 2009

21 Goldman, Alvin I., "Mirror Neuron Systems: The Role of Mirroring Processes in Social Cognition" Springer 311-330, 2008

22 Heal, Jane, "Mind, Reason and Imagination: Selected Essays in Philosophy of Mind and Language" Cambridge University Press 2003

23 Kohler, Evelyne, "Hearing Sounds, Understanding Actions: Action Representation in Mirror Neurons" 29 : 846-848, 2002

24 Juslin, Patrik N., "From Everyday Emotions to Aesthetic Emotions: Towards a Unified Theory of Musical Emotions" 10 (10): 235-266, 2013

25 Bastiaansen, Jojanneke A. C. J., "Evidence for Mirror Systems in Emotions" 364 : 2391-2404, 2009

26 Curry, Gregory, "Empathy: Philosophical and Psychological Perspectives" Oxford University Press 82-95, 2011

27 Goldman, Alvin I., "Empathy: Philosophical and Psychological Perspectives" Oxford University Press 31-44, 2011

28 Robinson, Jenefer, "Deeper than Reason: Emotion and its Role in Literature, Music, and Art" Oxford University Press 2005

29 Levinson, Jerrold, "Contemplating Art: Essays in Aesthetics" Oxford University Press 91-108, 2006

30 Zahavi, Dan, "Basic Empathy and Complex Empathy" 4 (4): 81-82, 2012

31 Gallese, Vittorio, "Action Recognition in the Premotor Cortex" 119 : 593-609, 1996

32 Cochrane, Tom, "A Simulation Theory of Musical Expressivity" 88 (88): 191-207, 2009