계획가 특성에 따른 계획이론의 실무적합성 분석

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Planning theories have been criticized for a lack of relevance to practice. Previous studies argued that for the relevance, planners adopt a group of theories instead of attempting to identify one best theory. Planners were not considered in the studies, however, although they actually use the theories and assess the relevance in practice. Thus, this study explores how the practical relevance differs according to characteristics planners have. For empirical analysis, individual theories of planning are categorized into groups, each of which proposes a certain planner role. Then, this study investigates which role is adopted in practice, that is, which theory is practically relevant. Logit models find that planners’ sociodemographics, work settings, and specialties are associated with the relevance of the theories. Chi-squared test of association and tetrachoric correlation confirm that for the relevance, planners choose either the group of rational-refined rational-transactive/communicative planning or that of radical-advocacy planning.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 봉인식, "도시정비사업 의사결정과정에서 계획가의 역할에 관한 연구" 경기개발연구원 2010

2 권원용, "계획환경의 변화에 대처하는 도시계획가의 역할 모색에 관한 연구" 한국도시행정학회 21 (21): 3-24, 2008

3 전상인, "계획이론의 탈근대적 전환에 대한 비판적 성찰" 대한국토·도시계획학회 42 (42): 7-24, 2007

4 Friedmann, J, "Why do planning theory?" 2 (2): 7-10, 2003

5 Aitken, S. C, "Who contrives the “ real” in GIS?" 22 (22): 17-29, 1995

6 Verma, N, "What is planning practice? The search for suitable categories" 14 (14): 178-182, 1995

7 Alexander, E. R, "What do planners need to know? Identifying needed competencies, methods, and skills" 22 (22): 91-106, 2005

8 Frank, N, "Values, Information, and Power, Baltimore: Association of Collegiate Schools of Planning 2002"

9 Guzzetta, J. D, "Urban planners’skills and competencies" 23 (23): 96-106, 2003

10 Myers, D, "Toward greater heights for planning" 71 (71): 121-129, 2005

11 Lim, G.-C, "Toward a synthesis of contemporary planning theories" 5 (5): 75-85, 1986

12 Friedmann, J, "The uses of planning theory" 28 (28): 247-257, 2008

13 Mazziotti, D. F, "The underlying assumptions of advocacy planning: Pluralism and reform" 40 (40): 38-47, 1974

14 Beauregard, R. A, "The occupation of planning: A view from the Census" 42 (42): 187-192, 1976

15 Helling, A, "The central sixth theme" 16 (16): 228-, 1997

16 Weber, M, "The Theory of Social and Economic Organization" Free Press 1997

17 Schon, D. A, "The Reflective Practitioner" Basic Books 1983

18 Rodwin, L, "The Profession of City Planning" Center for Urban Policy Research 2000

19 Friedmann, J, "Teaching planning theory" 14 (14): 156-162, 1995

20 Ozawa, C. P, "Taking our bearings" 18 (18): 257-266, 1999

21 Lindblom, C. E, "Still muddling, not yet through" 39 (39): 517-526, 1979

22 Baum, H. S, "Social science, social work, and surgery" 63 (63): 179-188, 1997

23 Alexander, E. R, "Response to ‘Why do planning theory?" 2 (2): 179-182, 2003

24 Faludi, A, "Rationality, critical rationalism, and planning doctrine" 1996

25 Kaufman, S, "Quantitative and research methods in planning" 15 (15): 17-33, 1995

26 Dalton, L. C, "Preparing planners for the breadth of practice" 73 (73): 35-48, 2007

27 March, A, "Practising theory" 9 (9): 108-125, 2010

28 Harris, N, "Practice through a lens: A metaphor for planning theory" 19 (19): 309-315, 2000

29 Meyerson, M, "Politics, Planning and the Public Interest: The Case of Public Housing in Chicago" Free Press 1955

30 Edwards, M. M, "Planning’s core curriculum" 31 (31): 172-183, 2011

31 Healey, P, "Planning through debate: The communicative turn in planning theory" 63 (63): 143-162, 1992

32 Innes, J, "Planning theory’s emerging paradigm: Communicative action and interactive practice" 14 (14): 183-189, 1995

33 Yiftachel, O, "Planning theory at the crossroad: The Third Oxford Conference" 18 (18): 267-270, 1999

34 Friedmann, J, "Planning in the Public Domain" Princeton University Press 1987

35 Forester, J, "Planning in the Face of Power" University of California Press 1989

36 Schonwandt, W. L, "Planning in Crisis?" Ashgate Publishing 2008

37 Brooks,M.P, "Planning Theory for Practitioners" Planners Press 2002

38 Baum, H. S, "Planners and Public Expectations" Schenkman 1983

39 Kraushaar, R, "Outside the whale: Progressive planning and the dilemmas of radical reform" 54 (54): 91-100, 1988

40 Beauregard, R. A, "Occupational transformations in urban and regional planning, 1960 to 1980" 5 (5): 10-16, 1985

41 Wekerle, G. R, "New Space for Women" Westview 1980

42 Etzioni, A, "Mixed scanning revisited" 46 (46): 8-14, 1986

43 Mandelbaum, S. J, "Introduction" 11 (11): 1996

44 Friedmann, J, "Insurgencies: Essays in Planning Theory" Routledge 2011

45 Sanyal, B, "Globalization, ethical compromise and planning theory" 1 (1): 116-123, 2002

46 Grabow, S, "Foundations for a radical concept of planning" 39 (39): 106-114, 1973

47 Mandelbaum, S. J, "Explorations in Planning Theory" Center for Urban Policy Research 1996

48 Liggett, H, "Examining the planning practice conscious(ness)" 299-306, 1996

49 Dalton, L. C, "Emerging knowledge about planning practice" 9 (9): 29-44, 1989

50 Watson, V, "Do we learn from planning practice?" 22 (22): 178-187, 2002

51 미국 노동부 노동통계국, "Current Population Survey"

52 Forester, J, "Critical Theory, Public Policy, and Planning Practice: Toward a Critical Pragmatism" State University of New York Press 1993

53 Beard, V. A, "Covert planning for social transformation in Indonesia" 22 (22): 15-25, 2002

54 Hoch, C, "Conflict at large: A national survey of planners and political conflict" 8 (8): 25-34, 1988

55 Seltzer, E, "Clear signals: Moving on to planning’s promise" 22 (22): 77-86, 2002

56 Meyerson, M, "Building the middle-range bridge for comprehensive planning" 22 (22): 58-64, 1956

57 Knox, P. L, "Attitudes to Third World urban planning" 13 (13): 67-79, 1989

58 Alexander, E. R, "After rationality, In Explorations in Planning Theory" Explorations in Planning Theory 45-64, 1996

59 Davidoff, P, "Advocacy and pluralism in planning" 31 (31): 331-338, 1965

60 미국도시계획협회, "APA/AICP 2006 Planners Salary Survey"

61 Krumholz, N, "A retrospective view of equity planning: Cleveland, 1969- 1979" 48 (48): 163-174, 1982

62 Murray, D, "A critical analysis of communicative rationality as a theoretical underpinning for collaborative approaches to integrated resource and environmental management" 33 (33): 17-34, 2005

63 Davidoff, P, "A choice theory of planning" 28 (28): 103-115, 1962