Why do Territorial Disputes Escalate? A Domestic Political Explanation for the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands Dispute

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Why has the Senkaku/Diaoyu territorial dispute escalated recurrently? This study examines the sources of the 2010 and 2012 escalations in territorial disputes over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands. We review existing explanations and their limitations and introduce new hypotheses based on the effect of political leaders’ interests in the escalation of territorial disputes. We argue that when competition among leaders intensifies or leaders’ political vulnerability increases, it is more likely that leaders who are seeking to retain or take office will behave more assertively in claiming rights over territories; therefore, a territorial dispute is more likely to escalate. We find that when Japanese leaders have needed to strengthen their political position during elections, they have adopted aggressive strategies in the dispute to avoid criticism from both the public and political oppositions about their weak postures against China. In China, the succession process has intensified political struggles and has led leaders to pursue a hardline policy with respect to the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands dispute. The Chinese government and the media have also fueled anti-Japanese protests to increase internal cohesion for successful leadership transition. This study not only provides a domestic political explanation for the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands dispute, but also serves as supporting evidence or process tracing for the theoretical proposition that leadership change is associated with the escalation of territorial disputes.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이명찬, "센카쿠제도를 둘러싼 중·일간 갈등과 동북아" 한국국제정치학회 53 (53): 255-293, 2013

2 Hagström, Linus, "‘Power Shift’ in East Asia? A Critical Reappraisal of Narratives on the Diaoyu/Senkaku Islands Incident in 2010" 5 : 267-297, 2012

3 Xinhua, "‘Absolutely no concession’ on Diaoyu Islands, says Chinese premier"

4 China Daily, "Wisdom needed in the expression of patriotism"

5 유현주, "When Domestic Factors Matter: The Relocation of US Bases in Okinawa" 한국국제정치학회 12 (12): 403-423, 2014

6 Bueno de Mesquita, "War in a Changing World" University of Michigan Press 183-206, 2001

7 Bueno de Mesquita, Bruce, "War and the Survival of Political Leaders: A Comparative Study of Regime Types and Political Accountability" 89 (89): 841-855, 1995

8 Watts, Jonathan, "Violence flares as the Chinese rage at Japan"

9 Nakamoto, Michiyo, "Tokyo governor attacks plans for Islands"

10 South China Morning Post, "Timeline: the Diaoyu-Senkaku Islands dispute"

11 Blanchard, Jean-Marc F., "The U. S. Role in the Sino-Japanese Dispute over the Diaoyu (Senkaku) Islands, 1945-1971" 161 : 95-123, 2000

12 Tretiak, Daniel, "The Sino-Japanese Treaty of 1978: The Senkaku Incident Prelude" 18 (18): 1235-1249, 1978

13 Koo, Min Gyo, "The Senkaku/Diaoyu dispute and Sino-Japanese political-economic relations:cold politics and hot economics?" 22 (22): 205-232, 2009

14 Choong, William, "The Senkaku/Diaoyu dispute" 54 (54): 59-92, 2014

15 Smith, Sheila A., "The Senkaku Islands and Japan’s Evolving Diplomacy" 19 (19): 41-43, 2014

16 Thayer, Carlyle A., "The Senkaku Islands Dispute: Risk to U.S. Rebalancing in the Asia-Pacific?"

17 Drifte, Reinhard, "The Japan-China Confrontation over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands–Between ‘shelving’ and ‘dispute escalation,’" 12 (12): 2014

18 Coser, Lewis A., "The Functions of Social Conflict" The Free Press 1956

19 Suzuki, Takeshi, "The Dispute Over the Diaoyu/Senkaku Islands: How Media Narratives Shape Public Opinion and Challenge the Global Leader" Palgrave Macmillan 2014

20 Midford, Paul, "The China-Japan Border Dispute:Islands of Contention in Multidisiplinary Perspective" Ashgate Publishing Company 2015

21 Ha, Do Hyung, "Territorial Issues in East Asia and Dokdo" Northeast Asian History Foundation 2013

22 Reilly, James, "Strong Society, Smart State: The Rise of Public Opinion in China’s Japan Policy" Columbia University Press 2012

23 Fackler, Martin, "Sleepy Islands and a Smoldering Dispute"

24 Takeuchi, Hiroki, "Sino-Japanese relations: power, interdependence, and domestic politics" 14 : 7-32, 2014

25 Yomiuri Shimbun, "Shasetsu: Senkakuoki Shoutotsu Jiken Chuugokujin Senchou no Taiho wa Touzen Da [Editorial: The Senkaku Collision Incident, Chinese Fishing Boat Captain’s Arrest is Reasonable]"

26 Asahi Shimbun, "Shasetsu: Senkaku Arasoi No Umi Ni Senu Chie[Editorial: Wisdom in the Sea of the Senkaku Dispute]"

27 Henochowicz, Anne, "Sensitive Words: Anti-Japan Protests (2)"

28 Feng, Zhaokui, "Seeds of Diaoyu dispute sowed by U.S"

29 Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, "SIPRI Military Expenditure Database"

30 Wada, Haruki, "Resolving the China-Japan Conflict Over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands" 43 (43): 2010

31 Fearon, James, "Rationalist Explanations for War" 49 (49): 379-414, 1995

32 Japan Times, "Raising the Senkaku Stakes?"

33 Horiuchi, Toru, "Public Opinion in Japan and the Nationalization of the Senkaku Islands" 31 : 23-47, 2014

34 Weiss, Jessica C., "Powerful Patriots: Nationalist Protest in China’s Foreign Relations" Oxford University Press 2014

35 Beukel, Erik, "Popular Nationalism in China and the Sino-Japanese Relationship: The Conflict in the East China Sea, an Introductory Study" Danish Institute for International Studies 1-32, 2011

36 Baruah, Pranamita, "Political Rift Deepens in Japan over Senkakus’ Nationalization" Institute for Defense Studies and Analyses

37 Chiozza, Giacomo, "Peace through Insecurity: Tenure and International Conflict" 47 (47): 443-467, 2003

38 Yang, Ai, "Ozawa questions sovereignty of Chinese islands"

39 Asahi Shimbun, "Noda team moves swiftly to curtail Senkaku controversy"

40 Asahi Shimbun, "Noda Government to Buy Senkaku Islands for 2 Billion Yen"

41 Asahi Shimbun, "Noda Cabinet Approval Rating Sinks to New Low"

42 Downs, Erica S., "Legitimacy and the Limits of Nationalism: China and the Diaoyu Islands" 23 (23): 114-146, 1998

43 Japan Times, "Kan, Obama agree on Futenma"

44 Japan Ministry of Defense, "Japan’s Security and Defense Policy"

45 Wan, Ming, "Japan’s Party Politics and China Policy: The Chinese Fishing Boat Collision Incident" University of Tokyo 2011

46 China Daily, "Japanese lawmakers' aerial inspection of Diaoyu Islands slammed"

47 Economist, "Japanese Politics: Aberration"

48 Global Times, "Japanese Ambassador Summoned for 5th time"

49 Economist, "Japan's Military Spending: Tooling up"

50 BBC News, "Japan and China trade barbs over Islands at UN"

51 Henderson, Barney, "Japan and China agree to reduce tensions over Senkaku islands"

52 Levy, Jack S., "Handbook of War Studies" Unwin Hyman 259-288, 1989

53 Chiozza, Giacomo, "Guess Who Did What: Political Leaders and the Management of Territorial Disputes, 1950-1990" 47 (47): 251-278, 2003

54 Fravel, Taylor M., "Getting the Triangle Straight:Managing China-Japan-US Relations" The Brookings Institution Press 2010

55 World Bank, "GDP growth (annual %)"

56 World Bank, "GDP at market prices (current US$) (in trillions)"

57 Xinhua, "Full text of Statement of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People's Republic of China"

58 Norris, William, "Explaining Recent Senkaku/Diaoyu Tensions: The Domestic Dimension" 19 (19): 43-44, 2014

59 Hayashi, Nozomu, "Expect tough attitude from China while Xi carves out his niche"

60 Wiegand, Krista E., "Enduring Territorial Disputes: Strategies of Bargaining, Coercive Diplomacy, and Settlement" The University of Georgia Press 2011

61 Wong, Edward, "Ending Congress, China Presents New Leadership Headed by Xi Jinping"

62 Gaubatz, Kurt T., "Election Cycles and War" 35 (35): 212-244, 1991

63 Makinen, Julie, "Economic stakes high in China-Japan islands dispute"

64 Economist, "East Asian rivalry: Protesting too much"

65 Leeds, Brett A., "Domestic Political Vulnerability and International Disputes" 41 (41): 814-834, 1997

66 Huth, Paul K., "Domestic Political Accountability and the Escalation and Settlement of International Disputes" 46 (46): 754-790, 2002

67 Smith, Alastair, "Diversionary Foreign Policy in Democratic Systems" 40 (40): 133-153, 1996

68 Japan Ministry of Defense, "Defense of Japan (Annual White Paper)"

69 Ignatius, David, "David Ignatius: China’s Xi Jinping consolidates power and brings stability"

70 Zhimin, Chen, "Construction of Chinese Nationalism in the Early 21st Century:Domestic Sources and International Implications" Routledge 2014

71 최운도, "Conditions for Peaceful Resolution in Territorial Disputes of Northeast Asia" 한국국제정치학회 49 (49): 35-53, 2009

72 Fujihira, Shinju, "Clash of National Identities: China, Japan, and the East China Sea Territorial Dispute" Wilson Center 2013

73 Zhao, Quansheng, "Clash of National Identities: China, Japan, and the East China Sea Territorial Dispute" Wilson Center 2013

74 Kyodo News, "Chinese protest at embassy over Japan's E. China Sea activities"

75 Xinhua, "Chinese protest Japanese ‘purchase’ of Diaoyu Islands"

76 Kokubun, Ryosei, "Chinese politics and changing Japan–China relations"

77 Asahi Shimbun, "Chinese patrol ships enter Japan territorial waters again"

78 Hille, Kathrin, "Chinese navy on exercise near Senkakus"

79 Wong, Edward, "Chinese Military Seeks to Extend Its Naval Power"

80 Perlez, Jane, "Chinese Leader Takes Conciliatory Tone in Meeting with Japanese Lawmaker"

81 Swaine, Michael D., "China’s Assertive Behavior – Part Two: The Maritime Periphery" 35 : 1-29, 2011

82 New York Times, "China: Anti-Japanese Protests Grow in Dispute Over Island Chain"

83 Christensen, Thomas J., "China, the US-Japan Alliance, and the Security Dilemma in East Asia" 23 (23): 49-80, 1999

84 Xinhua, "China's Xi calls ‘purchase’ of Diaoyu Islands ‘a farce,’ urges Japan to stop"

85 Zhao, Suisheng, "China's Global Search for Energy Security: cooperation and competition in Asia–Pacific" 17 (17): 207-227, 2008

86 Telegraph, "China blocked exports of rare earth metals to Japan, traders claim"

87 Economist, "China and Japan: Relations on the rocks"

88 BBC News, "China and Japan smooth over East China Sea island row"

89 Perlez, Jane, "China Steps Up Pressure on Japan in Island Dispute"

90 Ford, Christopher A., "China Looks at the West: Identity, Global Ambitions, and the Future of Sino-American Relations" University Press of Kentucky 2015

91 Kouchi, Yasushi, "Beijing bans anti-Japan protests"

92 Johnson, Ian, "Beijing Mixes Messages over Anti-Japan Protests"

93 Gelpi, Christopher, "Attracting Trouble: Democracy, Leadership Tenure, and the Targeting of Militarized Challenges, 1918-1992" 45 (45): 794-817, 2001

94 Asahi Shimbun, "Asahi poll: Abe Cabinet's approval rate rises to 50% following hostage crisis"

95 Asahi Shimbun, "Asahi poll: 39% prefer Abe as prime minister, 34% choose Noda"

96 Office of the Secretary of Defense, "Annual Report to Congress: Military Power of the People’s Republic of China"

97 Zhang, Yunbi, "Anger erupts at Japanese landing"

98 Global Times, "Abe says LDP to improve relations with China"

99 Yamaguchi, Nagato, "Abe pauses on Senkakus postings"

100 Reilly, James, "A Wave to Worry About? Public opinion, foreign policy and China's anti-Japan protests" 23 (23): 197-215, 2014

101 Hensel, Paul R., "A Road Map to War: Territorial Dimensions of International Conflict" Vanderbilt University Press 1999

102 Nippon Television, "2012 nen 5 gatsu teirei yoron chousa[2012 May Opinion Survey]"