1. Study Purpose and Analysis Outline
In order to suit the rapidly changing administrative environment, emphasis is put on the importance of revolutionary leadership and servant leadership which focuses on the motivation and growth of members, for ...
1. Study Purpose and Analysis Outline
In order to suit the rapidly changing administrative environment, emphasis is put on the importance of revolutionary leadership and servant leadership which focuses on the motivation and growth of members, for local government leaders. Importance of group efficacy which focuses on common conviction is emphasized for the constituent members.
Based on revolutionary and servant leadership, this research analyzed how each leadership type of government leaders affects group efficacy and organizational immersion. It set group efficacy which is considered an important factor of organizational performance as the parameter. Accordingly, the research examined whether the group efficacy displays the parameter in the relation between leadership type and organizational immersion.
The purpose of this research is to contribute to a healthy development of local governments by providing the direction of desirable leadership types. Its purpose is to also provide changes for a desirable leadership where the effect of group efficacy can be maximized. It also plans to examine the influence of leadership types on organizational immersion through a mediator variable of group efficacy. Based on such analytical results, it would recommend the most desirable type of leadership to local government leaders.
According to such purpose, this research set the leadership type of local government leaders as the main research subject, and the scope & methods of this research are as the following.
Firstly, the periodic scope is from May 1th to 25th, 2010. It used data acquired from the studies on public officials working in the local governments in Daegu. Local government leadership is limited to local government leadership behavior in Daegu.
Secondly, local governments in Daegu are set as the spatial scope in this research. The reason for selecting local government entities as the research subject is that substantial discussion on local government leadership is possible through surveys on major local government officials. Another reason is that local government officials are more influenced by their leaders than metropolitan officials since they have more frequent contact with their leaders.
Thirdly, this research conducted both documentary research and positive research through surveys. In documentary research, it systemized the relationship among revolutionary/servant leadership, group efficacy and organizational immersion through studies on preliminary researches from Korea and abroad. Specifically it used Bass & Avolio (1992) for revolutionary leadership, Barbuto & Wheeler (2006) for servant leadership, Riggs & Knight (1994) for group efficacy, and Meyer & Allen (1990) for organizational immersion. Moreover, it selected revolutionary leadership (charisma, individual consideration, intellectual stimulus) and servant leadership (altruistic calling, emotional therapy, wisdom, persuasion and steward mentality) as the independent variable, organizational immersion (emotional, consistent and normative immersion) as the dependent variable, and group efficacy as the parameter. In positive analysis, it used SPSS WIN 15.0 to examine statistical significance, and AMOS 7.0 in analyzing structural equation models to verify the research hypothesis. A positive research model for examining the influence of revolutionary/servant leadership on group efficacy and organizational immersion based on theoretic discussion is as <Fig. 1> below.
<Fig. 1> Research Model
Revolutionary Leadership•Revolutionary
•Individual Consideration
•Intellectual StimulusGroup EfficacyServant Leadership•Altruistic Calling
•Emotional Therapy
•Wisdom
•Persuasion
•Steward MentalityOrganizational
ImmersionH6: Leadership->Group Efficacy->Organizational Immersion
2. Analysis Result and Implications
Summary of this research analysis results is as the following.
Firstly, regarding the relation between group efficacy and revolutionary/servant leadership of government employees, this research found different results from those of preliminary studies that there was no influence of revolutionary leadership on group efficacy. However, there was a conclusion that servant leadership has influence on group efficacy of government officials.
Secondly, regarding the relation between organizational immersion and revolutionary/servant leadership of government employees, this research re-verified that revolutionary leadership has positive effects based on various other studies. Also, servant leadership allows subordinates to perceive the importance of work, allowing them to concentrate in their organization.
Thirdly, regarding the relation between organizational immersion and group efficacy, preliminary studies had mixed results of plus (+) and minus (-) effects. However, this research showed that group efficacy only had plus (+) effects on organizational immersion.
Next, although group efficacy did play some mediator roles, it had more influence on organizational immersion as an independent variable. This shows the necessity of various fundamental researches on the roles of group efficacy.
Moreover, it was found that revolutionary leadership of local government leaders had a larger plus (+) effect on organizational immersion than servant leadership. The research also showed that servant leadership had a larger plus (+) effect than revolutionary leadership on group efficacy. Based on such research results, servant leadership is relatively more desirable than revolutionary leadership in developing organizational immersion through the parameter of group efficacy within local government entities. This means local government leaders must display revolutionary leadership for organizational immersion, and servant leadership for group efficacy.
Based on such overall research results, the following matters can be proposed.
Firstly, when charisma and intellectual stimulus of revolutionary leadership greatly influences the improvement of organizational immersion, leaders must acquire knowledge and trust in the relationships with their subordinates while considering the fact that charisma comes from the intellect of leaders and trust of subordinates.
Secondly, leaders must perceive the fact that consideration of group efficacy is important in order to allow the employees to concentrate through servant leadership. They must pour effort to settle a group efficacy fit for the specific characters of individual local entities.
Thirdly, when the local government leaders plan to settle group efficacy in the organization, they must enable fluent interactions and common perceptions in the team. The reason is that the level of organizational immersion or identification of work may vary since the amount of information about their works, and the communication processes are different.