정신분석, 과학인가 문학인가? = Psychoanalysis is Science or Literature?

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Psychoanalysis can be considered as the condominium between the medicine and the literature, or the natural science and the human science, because it nowadays seems to be a kind of the 3rd alternative medicine. Psychoanalysis is obviously psychological therapeutic methodology for the various psychogenic mental conditions through the psychological approaches, nevertheless it has been ignored to many clinicians for the reason of the unscientific theoretical basis. But now we know that some neurologists and psychoanalysts have been cooperative to explore the so-called neurodynamics and neuro-mechanisms for the psychological phenomena in the analytic situations. Why not psychoanalysis is a science? And what is science?
We are sure that our psychic world can not be easily confirmed by scientific methodology, but I think that theory without practice is empty, and practice without theory is blind. Therefore I believe that contemporary many neuro-psychoanalytic researches will show us some clues to psychoanalytic theory and techniques, but there shall be many limitations. More deeply we explore the human psyche, more we can not assure that.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "in Psychiatry or The Perils of Progress" Brunner/Mazel Publishers 1993

2 "and the Making of Psychoanalysis" Yale Univ Press 1987

3 "The scientific status of unconscious process:Is Freud reallydead" 47 : 1061-1106, 1999

4 "The neurological legacy of psychoanalysis:Freudas a neurologist" 30 : 128-134, 1989

5 "The neuroimmune network and its relevance to psychoanalysis" 71 : 617-627, 2002

6 "The dialogue between psychoanalysis and neuroscience" 2 : 183-192, 2000

7 "The concepts of the pleasure principle and infantile erogenouszones shaped by Freud’s neurological education" 43 : 218-223, 1974

8 "The Psychoanalytic Theory of Neurosis" WW Norton & Company Inc 1945

9 "Split brains and psychoanalysis" 46 : 220-244, 1977

10 "Pursuit ofthe emerging dialogue between psychoanalysis and neuroscience" 85 : 1493-1496, 2004

11 "Psychotherapy and single synapse:the impact of psychiatricthought on neurobiologic research" 301 : 1028-1037, 1979

12 "Psychoanalysis and cognitive neuropsychology" 3 : 3-10, 2001

13 "Psychoanalysis and Its Experimental Researches" 15 : 21-32, 2004

14 "Project for a Scientific Psychology" Hogarth Press 1895

15 "Notes for a dialogue between psychoanalysis and neuroscience" 86 : 1405-1423, 2005

16 "New York Review of Books" 55-67, 199311

17 "How Brains Make Up Their Minds" ColumbiaUniv Press 2000

18 "Freud and the Question of Pseudoscience" Open Court Publishing Co 1998

19 "Freud and neurology" 19 : 18-26, 1978

20 "Emotions are expressed more intenselyon the left side of the face" 202 : 434-436, 1978

21 "Elements of Semiology and Clinical Mental Conditions" 1912

22 "Creativity and Psychopathology" 15 : 166-179, 2004

23 "Coca-Koller und seine Freunde. Zum 140. Geburtstagdes judisch-wienerischen Trios: Carl Koller (1857-1944)Sigmund Lustgarten (1857-1911) und Sigmund Freud (1856-1939)." 109 : 170-175, 1997

24 "Can Schizophrenia Be Localized in the Brain" Amer Psychiatric Press 1986

25 "Biologist of the Mind" Basic Books 1979

26 "Basic Theory of Psychoanalysis" Int Univ Press 1960

27 "A History of Psychoanalysis" Columbia Univ Press 1979