부하체면에 영향을 미치는 상사행위의 구성개념 및 측정에 관한 연구 = A Study on the Constructs and Measurement of Leader’s Behavior Influencing Subordinates’ Face

국문 초록 (Abstract)

  대인관계 상황에서 체면을 고려하는 것은 보편적인 현상일 뿐만 아니라 서구에 비해 우리나라에서 보다 중시되고 있지만 조직차원에서의 연구는 미흡하다. 특히 부하의 체면에 영향을 미치는 상사의 행위에 대해서는 연구가 매우 부족한 실정이다.<BR>  부하체면에 대한 상사행위의 구성개념과 타당성 있는 측정도구를 개발하기 위하여 군조직의 간부들을 대상으로 2단계의 연구가 진행되었다. 먼저, 연구 1에서는 상사의 부하에 대한 ‘체면세움행위’ 및 ‘체면손상행위’ 문항을 자유응답식 설문과 내용분석 과정을 통하여 도출하고, 육군 간부들로 이루어진 표본에 대하여 탐색적 요인분석을 통해서, 요인구조가 ‘능력체면행위’와 ‘인격체면행위’의 두 차원으로 이루어져 있음을 확인하였다. 연구 2에서는 독립적인 새 표본을 구성하여 개발된 문항들의 타당성을 검증하고 태도변수와의 관계를 확인하였다. 분석 결과, 개발된 측정도구는 교차타당성, 그리고 수렴 및 판별타당성이 있음을 확인할 수 있었다. 부하 태도변수와의 관계를 확인한 결과, 상사의 부하체면에 대한 체면세움 행위는 부하의 LMX, 직무만족, 조직몰입에 정의 관계를 보였고 이직의도에는 부의 관계를 나타내었다. 상사의 부하체면에 대한 체면손상행위는 부하의 LMX, 직무만족 및 조직몰입과 부의 관계가 있음을 확인할 수 있었다. 이는 부하체면에 대한 상사행위가 조직 유효성을 설명하는데 적절한 변수임을 의미한다. 마지막으로, 본 연구의 의의와 한계 및 미래 연구방향을 제시하였다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

  The issue of face in social interactions is more pervasive in Asian cultures than in Western ones. However, very few studies have investigated face in organizational context in Korea. Face is dependent on individual social status (Goffman, 1955; Ho, 1976), which points to the fact that leaders’ face is considered to be more important than subordinates’ face due to the status difference. Nevertheless, the importance of subordinates’ face is gradually becoming salient as the autocratic culture is transformed into a democratic one in modern organizations.<BR>  The majority of the studies on face have focused on the leaders’ face, which, in turn, has yielded no study of leader’s behavior influencing subordinates’ face. The subordinates’ attitudes and behaviors can obviously vary depending on whether their leader takes the subordinates’ face into consideration or not. The subordinates are said to possess favorable attitudes towards a leader who saves the subordinates’ face, while they are likely to maintain negative attitudes towards a leader who makes them lose their face. Thus, it is necessary to study on the relationship between leader’s behaviors concerning subordinates’ face and the subordinates’ attitudes and behaviors. Since there is no measure for leader’s behavior influencing subordinates’ face, the valid and reliable measure should be developed.<BR>  The current research was designed to identify the constructs of leader’s behavior influencing subordinates’ face (LBSF), and to develop and validate a sound psychometric measure of LBSF. This paper consists of two parts: in Study 1, we generated items of leader’s face-giving (LFGB) and face-threatening (LFTB) behavior towards subordinates, and identify the construct and factor structures of LBSF. In Study 2, a confirmatory factor analysis with independent samples showed the cross validity, convergent validity, and discriminant validity. Then, we verified the nomological validity and the potential utility of LBSF to predict organizational outcome variables. Finally, implications and possible research directions are discussed.<BR>  Respondents in the current research are officers and noncommissioned officers (NCOs) in the ROK (Republic of Korea) Army. In general, military organizations are more autocratic and hierarchical than the other civil organizations. Therefore, the subordinate’s face can be valued less than leader’s face. The difference between leaders who respect their subordinates’ face and leaders who do not can be easily distinguished in the military context. For this reason, military organization is suitable for the current research.<BR>  Study 1<BR>  In Study 1, we collected data from 98 officers and NCOs using open-ended questionnaire, which included two following questions: “What behavior of a leader made you save face?” and “What behavior of a leader made you lose face?” From the data, 623 LFGB items and 791 LFTB items were firstly derived. Next, we combined the items that had same contents and expressions into 113 LFGB and 154 LFTB items. Then, the content validation of the generated items was performed in three phases. Finally, 21 items for LFGB and 17 items for LFTB were used in the current study.<BR>  Using the data collected from 125 officers and NCOs, exploratory factor analyses with principal components were conducted. The results indicated that LFGB and LFTB consisted of two factors, ‘ability dimension’ and ‘character dimension.’ Specifically, LFGB consisted of 11 items, 6 items for ability-related LFGB (ALFGB) and 5 items for character-related LFGB (CLFGB). Likewise, LFTB also consisted of 12 items, 5 items for ability-related LFTB (ALFTB) and 7 items for character-related LFTB (CLFTB).<BR>  Study 2<BR>  The data, independent of Study 1, were used in Study 2. That is, the data from 156 officers and NCOs were used for LFGB, an

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 〈초록〉
  Ⅰ. 서론
  Ⅱ. 이론적 배경
  Ⅲ. 연구 1 : 상사의 부하체면행위 구성개념
  Ⅳ. 연구 2 : 타당성 분석 및 부하 태도변수와의 관계 검증
  Ⅴ. 토의 및 결론
  참고문헌
  〈부록〉
  ABSTRACT
  

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 최상진, "체면의 심리적 구조 in 1998 연차대회 논문집" 한국심리학회 1998

2 임태섭, "체면의 구조와 체면욕구의 결정요인에 대한 연구" 한국언론학회 32 : 207-247, 1994

3 김태현, "체면욕구가 목표설정, 몰입 및 체면손상정도에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구" 한국협상학회 10 (10): 73-95, 2004

4 김주엽, "체면에 대한 연구: 실증 연구를 위한 준비" 한국인적자원개발학회 5 (5): 63-81, 2003

5 이석재, "체면 지향행동의 이원구조모델 검증" 한국심리학회 15 (15): 65-83, 2001

6 오인수, "직무만족, 조직몰입, 성과, 이직의도 간의 관련성: 문헌고찰 및 메타분석" 한국인사, 조직학회 15 (15): 43-86, 2007

7 최상진, "정, 체면이 스트레스에 미치는 영향" 한국심리학회 4 (4): 41-56, 1999

8 임준철, "자긍심과 자기권능감에 영향을 미치는 선행요인에 관한 연구" 인사조직학회 1999

9 박오수, "상사의 체면과 반응행동" 서울대 경영연구소 30 (30): 67-124, 1996

10 박경환, "상급자의 공감, 직면 그리고 공격이 하급자의 자아존중감과 능력 활용에 미치는 영향" 대한경영학회 18 (18): 1391-1412, 2005

11 이군희, "사회과학 연구방법론" 법문사 2004

12 임효창, "부하의 특성이 상사의 반응 및 부하의 태도에 미치는 영향: 상사의 부하 신뢰의 매개효과를 중심으로" 한국인사관리학회 29 (29): 1-30, 2005

13 이규만, "부하의 체면중시가 상사-부하간 교환관계 및 조직행동에 미친 영향" 한국경영학회 30 (30): 1093-1114, 2001

14 이규만, "부하의 체면중시가 상사 - 부하간 교환관계 및 조직행동에 미친 영향" 한국경영학회 30 (30): 1093-1114, 2001

15 최상진, "권위에 관한 한국인의 의식체계: 권위, 권위주의와 체면의 구조에 대한 토착심리학적 접근" 한국심리학회 6 (6): 69-84, 2000

16 Lee, S-J., "Two-component model of chemyon-oriented behaviors" 15 (15): 65-83, 2001

17 Graen, G., "Toward a psychology of dyadic organizing" 9 : 175-208, 1987

18 Korman, A. K., "Toward a hypothesis of work behavior" 54 : 31-41, 1970

19 Choi, S-C., "The structure of authority, authoritarianism and chemyon in Korea: An indigenous analysis" 6 (6): 69-84, 2000

20 Lance, C. E., "The sources of four commonly reported cutoff criteria: What did they really say?" 9 : 202-220, 2006

21 Sivo, S. A., "The search for “optimal” cutoff properties: Fit index criteria in structural equation modeling" 74 (74): 267-288, 2006

22 Redding, S. G., "The role of face in the organizational perceptions of Chinese managers" 3 (3): 201-219, 1982

23 Ostroff, C., "The relationship between satisfaction, attitudes, and performance: An organizational level analysis" 77 : 963-974, 1992

24 Choi, S-C., "The psychological structure of face" Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Korean Psychological Association 1998

25 Allen, N. J., "The measurement and antecedents of affective, continuance and normative commitment to the organization" 63 : 1-18, 1990

26 Miner, J. B., "The management of ineffective performance in Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology" Rand McNally 1976

27 Judge, T. A., "The job satisfaction-job performance relationship: A qualitative and quantitative review" 127 : 376-407, 2001

28 Park, K-H., "The effects of the empathy, confrontation and attack on the self-esteem and ability utilization" 18 (18): 1391-1412, 2005

29 Lim, H-C., "The effects of subordinate’s characteristics on superior’s reaction and subordinate’s attitude: Focusing on the mediating variable of superior’s trust to subordinate" 29 (29): 1-30, 2005

30 Graen, G., "The effects of leader-member exchange and job design on productivity and satisfaction: Testing a dual attachment model" 30 : 109-131, 1982

31 Brown, B. R., "The effect of need to maintain face on interpersonal bargaining" 4 : 107-122, 1968

32 Kim, J. Y., "The concept and dynamics of face: Implications for organizational behavior in Asia" 9 : 522-534, 1998

33 Hu, H. C., "The chinese concept of face" 46 : 45-64, 1944

34 Riketta, M., "The causal relation between job attitudes and performance: A meta-analysis of panel studies" 93 : 472-481, 2008

35 Lowe, K. B., "Ten years of The Leadership Quarterly : Contributions and challenges for the future" 11 : 459-514, 2000

36 Goffman, E., "Symbols of class status" 2 (2): 294-304, 1951

37 Bae, B. R., "Structural equation modeling with LISREL: Concepts, applications, and programming" Chenglam 2006

38 Podsakoff, P. M., "Self-reports in organizational research: Problems and prospects" 12 : 531-544, 1986

39 Gardner, G. D., "Self-esteem and self-efficacy within the organizational context: An empirical examination" 23 : 48-70, 1998

40 Jackson, D. L., "Sample size and number of parameter estimates in maximum likelihood confirmatory factor analysis: A monte carlo investigation" 8 (8): 205-223, 2001

41 Lee, G. H., "Research methods for social science" Bobmunsa 2004

42 Oh, I-S., "Relationships among job satisfaction, organizational commitment, job performance, and turnover intention: A literature review and meta-analysis with Korean samples" 15 (15): 43-86, 2007

43 Levinson, H., "Reciprocation: The relationship between man and organization" 9 : 370-390, 1965

44 Nunnally, J. C., "Psychometric theory" McGraw-Hill 1976

45 Fein, S., "Prejudice as self-image maintenance: Affirming the self through derogating others" 73 : 31-44, 1997

46 Brown, P., "Politeness: Some universals in language use" Cambridge University Press 1987

47 Eisenberger, R., "Perceived supervisor support: Contributions to perceived organizational support and employee retention" 87 : 565-573, 2002

48 Eisenberger, R., "Perceived organizational support" 71 : 500-507, 1986

49 Ho, D. Y. F., "On the concept of face" 81 : 867-884, 1976

50 Goffman, E., "On face-work: An analysis of ritual elements in social interaction" 18 : 213-231, 1955

51 Hair, J. F., "Multivariate data analysis" Prentice-Hall 1998

52 Liden, R. C., "Multidimensionality of leader-member exchange: An empirical assessment through scale development" 24 : 43-72, 1998

53 Harman, H. H., "Modern factor analysis" University of Chicago Press 1967

54 O’Reilly, C. A. Ⅲ, "Managing marginal employees: The use of warnings and dismissals" 25 : 467-484, 1980

55 Park, O-S., "Leader’s face and behavioral responses in organizations" 30 (30): 67-124, 1996

56 Bass, B. M., "Leadership and performance beyond expectations" The Free Press 1985

57 배병렬, "LISREL 구조방정식 모델: 이해, 활용 및 프로그래밍" 청람 2006

58 Schriesheim, C. A., "Influence tactics used by subordinates: A theoretical and emporical analysis and refinement of the Kipnis, Schmidt, and Wilkinson Subscales" 75 : 246-257, 1990

59 Schriesheim, C. A., "Improving construct measurement in management research: Comments and a quantitative approach for assessing the theoretical content adequacy of paper-and-pencil survey-type instrument" 19 : 385-417, 1993

60 Marsh, H. W., "Goodness-of-fit indices in confirmatory factor analysis: The effect of sample size" 103 : 391-410, 1988

61 Liden, R. C., "Generalizability of the vertical dyad linkage model of leadership" 23 : 451-465, 1980

62 Bycio, P., "Further assessments of Bass’s (1985) conceptualization of transactional and transformational leadership" 80 : 468-478, 1995

63 Schmitt, N. W., "Factors defined by negatively keyed items; The results of careless respondents?" 9 : 367-373, 1985

64 Lim, T., "Facework: Solidarity, approbation, and tact" 17 : 415-450, 1991

65 Brown, B. R., "Face-saving following experimentally induced embarrassment" 6 : 255-271, 1970

66 Garland, H., "Face-saving as affected by subjects’ sex, audiences’sex and audience expertise" 35 (35): 280-289, 1972

67 Fairhurst, G. T., "Face support in controlling poor performance" 11 : 272-295, 1984

68 Morisaki, S., "Face in Japan and the United States in The challenge of facework" State University of New York Press 47-93, 1994

69 Hwang, K-K., "Face and favor: The chinese power game" 92 : 944-974, 1987

70 Oetzel, J., "Face and facework in conflict: A cross-cultural comparison of China, Germany, Japan, and the United States" 68 (68): 235-258, 2001

71 Roznowski, M., "Examination of the measurement properties of the job descriptive index with experimental items" 74 : 805-814, 1989

72 Lissitz, R. W., "Effects of the number of scale points on reliability: A monte carlo approach" 60 : 10-13, 1975

73 Fan, X., "Effects of sample size, estimation methods, and model specification on structural equation modeling fit indexes" 6 (6): 56-83, 1999

74 Choi, S-C., "Effects of cheong, chemyon-sensitivity on stress" 4 (4): 41-56, 1999

75 Hinkin, T. R., "Development and application of new scales to measure the French and Raven(1959) bases of social power" 74 : 561-567, 1989

76 Hofstede, G., "Cultures and organizations: Software of the mind" McGraw-Hill 1991

77 Tepper, B. J., "Consequences of abusive supervision" 43 : 178-190, 2000

78 Gao, G., "Communicating effectively with the Chinese" Sage Publications 1998

79 Podsakoff, P. M., "Common method biases in behavioral research: A critical review of the literature and recommended remedies" 88 : 879-903, 2003

80 Landau, J., "Clerical employees’ perceptions of intraorganizational career opportunities" 29 : 385-404, 1986

81 Mao. L. R., "Beyond politeness theory: ‘Face’ revisited and renewed" 21 : 451-486, 1994

82 Schutz, A., "Assertive, offensive, protective, and defensive styles of self-presentation: A taxonomy" 136 : 611-628, 1998

83 Brayfield, A. H., "An index of job satisfaction" 35 : 307-311, 1951

84 Tepper, B. J., "Abusive supervision in work organizations: Review, synthesis, and research agenda" 33 : 261-289, 2007

85 Dansereau, F., "A vertical dyad approach to leadership within formal organizations" 13 : 46-78, 1975

86 Kim, T-H., "A study on the effects of face-saving desire on the goal setting and commitment: A case of car dealers" 10 (10): 73-95, 2004

87 Kim, J-Y., "A study on face: Preparation for the empirical research" 5 (5): 63-81, 2003

88 Lim, T., "A study on face structure and determinants of face desires" 32 : 207-247, 1994

89 Lim, J., "A study on antecedents of self-esteem and self-efficacy" 1999

90 Graen, G., "A role making model in formal organizations: A developmental approach" Kent State Press 1975

91 Hinkin, T. R., "A review of scale development practices in the study of organizations" 21 : 967-988, 1995

92 Yang, M. C., "A Chinese village: Taitou, Shantung, Province" Columbia University Press 1945