국방 지식재산권 정책에 관한 소고 - 방위력개선사업을 중심으로 - = A Study on Defense Intellectual Property Policy - Focusing on Defense Force Improvement Projects -

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The government acquires weapon systems to provide defense services. The government procures weapon systems through defense force improvement projects that research and develop, or purchase weapon systems with government contracts.
The government has minimized legal disputes by directly owning IP rights applied to weapons systems in order to promote defense force improvement projects.
Meanwhile, if the government acquires the ownership of the IP from the defense company, a lack of incentives could negatively affect national security in the long run by lowering the overall technology level of defense companies.
“Act On The Agency For Defense Development” and “Defense Science And Technology Innovation Promotion Act” provide the fundamentals of the current defense IP policy, the ownership policy in which IP arising from defense force improvement projects are solely owned by the government or jointly owned by the government and the R&D company. However, the government's purpose of acquiring IP is to procure and operate weapons systems, not to commercialize. It is sufficient to achieve the government's purpose by acquiring only a license rather than ownership. Therefore, the ownership policy has the problem of acquiring excessive IP rights, and it is necessary to change the paradigm of the defense IP policy to the license policy also adopted by the United States, the United Kingdom, and France.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김선영, "최신 방위사업 개론" 북코리아 2020

2 김태완, "지식재산권의 공동소유" (435) : 2015

3 정상조, "지식재산권법" 홍문사 2020

4 김일중, "법경제학 : 이론과 응용" 해남 2011

5 임근영, "미국 공공기술이전 법제의 평가" 2 (2): 89-, 2005

6 윤권순, "미국 ‘특허강제실시’제도의 진화와 그 함의" 10 (10): 2015

7 이문태, "국방획득분야 지식재산권 전담지원팀 운영에 관한 제언" (497) : 2020

8 한국지식재산연구원, "국방지식재산소유권 민간이전 방안" 방위사업청 2013

9 유수봉 ; 김정중, "국방연구개발사업 성과에 대한 귀속 주체 및 제3자 실시방안 연구-전력지원체계사업을 중심으로-" 14 (14): 2019

10 한국지식재산연구원, "국방연구개발 결과물의 소유권 관리방안 연구" 방위사업청 2010

11 한승호 ; 권태복, "국방관련기술의 공동연구와 특허권 귀속" 인하대학교 법학연구소 20 (20): 2017

12 손좌근, "국방 지식재산권의 소유관계 변화에 따른 국방과학기술혁신 촉진법 개선방안 연구" 22 : 2021

13 윤권순, "국방 R&D 결과물의 특허권 귀속에 대한 고찰" 2011

14 김대인, "국가연구개발협약과 공·사법구별 - 대법원 2017. 11. 9. 선고 2015 다215526 판결에 대한 평석 -" 26 (26): 2018

15 George A. Akerlof, "The Market for “Lemons”: Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanism" 84 (84): 1970

16 Robert M. Farley, "Patents for Power : Intellectual Property Law and the Diffusion of Military Technology" The University of Chicago Press 2020

17 James G. McEwen, "Intellectual Property in Government Contracts" Oxford University Press 2009

18 Ralph C. Nash, JR, "Intellectual Property in Government Contracts" Wolters Kluwer 2008

19 Steven W. Feldman, "Government Contracts in a Nutshell" West Academic Publishing 2016

20 Elizabeth Reid, "Defence & Security Procurement 2021" Law Business Research Ltd 2021

21 The Judge Advocate General’s Legal Center and School, "Contract Attorney Deskbook 2022, U.S.Army" 2022

22 산업연구원, "23-27 방위산업발전 기본계획 수립연구" 방위사업청 2022

23 Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, "2022 SIPRI YEARBOOK" 2022