비밀을 이야기 하지 않는 아동의 진술특성: 준거기반내용분석(CBCA)을 중심으로 = Characteristics of statements of children who do not tell secrets: Focusing on Criteria Based Contents Analysis(CBCA)

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Reportedly, child victims of abuse often do not disclose some or any parts of the criminal behaviors they experience. The purpose of this study was to confirm the characteries of children’s statements when they attempt to keep secretes by re-analyzing data from an earlier experimental study(Yi, 2014). In that study, 71 children aged 3- to 6-year-olds were invited a photography event where a photographer took photos of the children while having a range of interactions with them, including putting on and removing costumes, asking them to assume certain poses, and forth. The photographer allowed each child to take a photo of the photographer, then asked the child to keep this a secret with promise of gifts if the child did not tell anyone. The results showed that, of 71 children, 35(49.3%) disclosed the secrets while 36(50.7%) keep the photographer’s confidence. Children who did not disclose the secrets provided significant smaller amounts of information about the incident. They were also more likely to give no response than children did disclose the secrets but the details provided by the secrets keepers were not necessarily inaccurate. CBCA was able to distinguish the statements of children who did disclose the secretes from those who did not. Children who disclosed the secretes had higher total mean CBCA scores. Moreover, the statements of disclosers more frequently included the features of criterion2, 3, 6 and 9. Finally, the implications of these finding for the investigative interviewing of children who did not disclose alleged incidents in forensic contexts are discussed.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

학대 피해 아동은 종종 자신이 경험한 사건의 일부 또는 전체 진술을 하지 않는 경우가 있다. 본 연구는 비밀을 이야기 하지 않는 아동의 진술 특성을 확인하기 위해 기존 실험 자료에 대한 재분석을 실시하였다. 총 71명의 3세에서 6세 아동은 사진사와 다양한 상호작용하였으며, 이후 ‘사진 찍기’에 대해 면담을 실시하였다. 사진사는 아동에게 자신의 사진을 찍어 달라고 한 후 아동이 사진기를 만지거나 사진을 찍은 사실에 대해 다른 사람에게 이야기 하지 않도록 요청하였다(이미선, 2014). 연구 결과, 35명(49.3%)의 아동은 추후 면담 과정에서 사진사와의 비밀을 이야기하였으며, 36명(50.7%)은 비밀을 지켰다. 비밀을 유지하는 아동은 그렇지 않은 아동에 비해 전반적으로 진술의 양이 적은 것으로 나타났다. 또한 비밀을 유지하는 아동은 무응답 비율이 유미하게 높았으나, 더 부정확한 정보를 포함하지는 않았다. CBCA는 비밀을 발설한 아동의 진술과 비밀을 유지하는 아동의 진술을 유미하게 구별해 주는 것으로 나타났다. 비밀을 발설하는 아동은 비밀을 유지하는 아동의 진술보다 CBCA 총점이 높았으며, 준거2(구조화되지 않은 표현), 준거3(세부내용의 풍부함), 준거6(대화의 인용), 준거9(부가적인 세부내용) 특징들이 더 존재하였다. 마지막으로 본 연구는 형사사법절차에서 진술거부 아동에 대한 수사면담 방안에 대해 논의하였다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이미선, "한국 성학대 의심 아동 조사면담" 케임브리지 대학교 2014

2 이미선, "경찰청 신규진술분석가 양성과정 교육자료" 2016

3 Somer, E, "Variables in delayed disclosure of childhood sexual abuse" 71 (71): 332-341, 2001

4 Oberlader, V. A, "Validity of content-based techniques to distinguish true and fabricated statements: A meta-analysis" 40 (40): 440-2016, 2016

5 Kellogg, N. D, "Unwanted and illegal sexual experiences in childhood and adolescence" 19 (19): 1457-1468, 1995

6 Kellogg, N. D, "Unwanted Sexual Experiencers in Adolescents: Patterns of Disclosure" 34 (34): 306-312, 1995

7 Amado, B. G, "Undeutsch hypothesis and Criteria Based Content Analysis: A meta-analytic review" 7 (7): 3-12, 2015

8 Hershkowitz, I, "Trends in children's disclosure of abuse in Israel: A national study" 29 (29): 1203-1214, 2005

9 Arata, C. M, "To tell or not to tell: Current functioning of child sexual abuse survivors who disclosed their victimization" 3 (3): 63-71, 1998

10 Steller, M, "The suggestibility of children’s recollections" American Psychological Association 1989

11 Bruck, M, "The suggestibility of children's memory" 50 (50): 419-439, 1999

12 Landis, J. R, "The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data" biometrics 159-174, 1977

13 Ahern, E. C, "The effects of secret instructions and yes/no questions on maltreated and non‐maltreated children's reports of a minor transgression" 34 (34): 784-802, 2016

14 Roberts, K. P, "The effects of rapport‐building style on children's reports of a staged event" 18 (18): 189-202, 2004

15 Quas, J. A, "The effects of promising to tell the truth, the putative confession, and recall and recognition questions on maltreated and non-maltreated children’s disclosure of a minor transgression" 166 : 266-279, 2018

16 Yi, M, "The effects of narrative practice on children's testimony and disclosure of secrets" 32 (32): 326-336, 2018

17 Summit, R. C, "The child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome" 7 (7): 177-193, 1983

18 Flåm, A. M, "Test balloons? Small signs of big events: A qualitative study on circumstances facilitating adults’ awareness of children's first signs of sexual abuse" 37 (37): 633-642, 2013

19 Roesler, T. A, "Telling the secret : Adult women describe their disclosures of incest" 9 (9): 327-338, 1994

20 DePaulo, B. M, "Telling ingratiating lies: Effects of target sex and target attractiveness on verbal and nonverbal deceptive success" 48 (48): 1191-, 1985

21 London, K, "Review of the contemporary literature on how children report sexual abuse to others:Findings, methodological issues, and implications for forensic interviewers" 16 (16): 29-47, 2008

22 Steller, M, "Psychological methods in criminal investigation and evidence" Springer-Verlag 1989

23 Anderson, J, "Prevalence of childhood sexual abuse experiences in a community sample of women" 32 (32): 911-919, 1993

24 O’Sullivan, M, "Police lie detection accuracy: The effect of lie scenario" 33 (33): 530-, 2009

25 Hershkowitz, I, "Individual and family variables associated with disclosure and nondisclosure of child abuse in Israel" 65-75, 2007

26 Kraut, R, "Humans as lie detectors" 30 (30): 209-218, 1980

27 Malloy, L. C, "Filial dependency and recantation of child sexual abuse allegations" 46 (46): 162-170, 2007

28 Lyon, T. D, "Eliciting maltreated and nonmaltreated children's transgression dis-closures: Narrative practice rapport building and a putative confession" 85 (85): 1756-1769, 2014

29 Roberts, K. P, "Effects of the timing of post-event information on preschoolers' memories of an event" 13 (13): 541-559, 1999

30 Hershkowitz, I, "Dynamics of forensic interviews with suspected abuse victims who do not disclose abuse" 30 (30): 753-769, 2006

31 Hershkowitz, I, "Does enhanced rapport-building alter the dynamics of investigative interviews with suspected victims of intra-familial abuse" 30 (30): 6-14, 2015

32 London, K, "Disclosure of child sexual abuse: What does the research tell us about the ways that children tell? Psychology" 11 (11): 194-, 2005

33 Alaggia, R, "Disclosing the trauma of child sexual abuse: A gender analysis" 10 (10): 453-470, 2005

34 Mann, S, "Detecting true lies: police officers' ability to detect suspects' lies" 89 (89): 137-, 2004

35 Vrij, A, "Detecting lies and deceit: Pitfalls and opportunities" John Wiley &Sons 2008

36 Gongola, J, "Detecting deception in children: A meta-analysis" 41 (41): 44-, 2017

37 Vrij, A, "Detecting Lies and Deceit: The Psychology of Lying and the Implications for Professional Practice" 2000

38 Cederborg, A. C, "Delay of disclosure, minimization and denial when the evidence is unambiguous. a mulit victim case" 2007

39 Smith, D. W, "Delay in disclosure of childhood rape: Results from a national survey" 24 (24): 273-287, 2000

40 Lewis, M, "Deception in 3-year-olds" 25 (25): 439-, 1989

41 Vrij, A, "Criteria-Based Content Analysis: A Qualitative Review of the First 37Studies" 11 (11): 3-, 2005

42 Lyon, T. D, "Coaching, truth induction, and young maltreated children’s false allegations and false denials" 79 (79): 914-929, 2008

43 Goodman, G. S, "Children’s eyewitness memory" Springer 1-23, 1987

44 Lamb, M. E, "Children's testimony: A handbook of psychological research and forensic practice" 131-145, 2002

45 Newton, P, "Children's everyday deception and performance on false‐belief tasks" 18 (18): 297-317, 2000

46 Keary, K, "Children's disclosure of sexual abuse during formal investigation" 18 (18): 543-548, 1994

47 Pipe, M. E, "Child sexual abuse: Disclosure, delay, and denial" Psychology Press 2013

48 Orbach, Y, "Assessing the value of structured protocols for forensic interviews of alleged child abuse victims" 24 (24): 733-752, 2000

49 Lamb, S, "Aspects of disclosure: Mediators of outcome of childhood sexual abuse" 9 (9): 307-326, 1994

50 Bond Jr, C. F, "Accuracy of deception judgments" 10 (10): 214-234, 2006

51 Lamb, M. E, "A structured forensic interview protocol improves the quality and informativeness of investigative interviews with children: A review of research using the NICHD Investigative Interview Protocol" 31 (31): 1201-1231, 2007