A Novel Approach to Improving the Reliability of Manual Semen Analysis: A Paradigm Shift in the Workup of Infertile Men

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Conventional semen analysis (SA) is an essential component of the male infertility workup, but requires laboratories to rigorously train and monitor technicians as well as regularly perform quality assurance assessments. Without such measures there is room for error and, consequently, unreliable results. Furthermore, clinicians often rely heavily on SA results when making diagnostic and treatment decisions, however conventional SA is only a surrogate marker of male fecundity and does not guarantee fertility. Considering these challenges, the last several decades have seen the development of many advances in SA methodology, including tests for sperm DNA fragmentation, acrosome reaction, and capacitation. While these new diagnostic tests have improved the scope of information available to clinicians, they are expensive, time-consuming, and require specialized training. The latest advance in laboratory diagnostics is the measurement of seminal oxidation-reduction potential (ORP). The measurement of ORP in an easy, reproducible manner using a new tool called the Male Infertility Oxidative Stress System (MiOXSYS) has demonstrated ORP’s potential as a feasible adjunct test to conventional SA. Additionally, the measurement of ORP by this device has been shown to be predictive of both poor semen quality and male infertility. Assessing ORP is a novel approach to both validating manual SA results and identifying patients who may benefit from treatment of male oxidative stress infertility.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Björndahl L, "‘How to count sperm properly’ : checklist for acceptability of studies based on human semen analysis" 31 : 227-232, 2016

2 Cooper TG, "World Health Organization reference values for human semen characteristics" 16 : 231-245, 2010

3 World Health Organization, "WHO laboratory manual for the examination of human semen and sperm-cervical mucus interaction" Cambridge University Press 107-, 1992

4 World Health Organization, "WHO laboratory manual for the examination of human semen and sperm-cervical mucus interaction" Cambridge University Press 67-, 1987

5 World Health Organization, "WHO laboratory manual for the examination of human semen and sperm-cervical mucus interaction" Cambridge University Press 128-, 1999

6 World Health Organization, "WHO laboratory manual for the examination of human semen and sperm-cervical mucus interaction" Press Concern 1980

7 World Health Organization, "WHO laboratory manual for the examination and processing of human semen. 5th ed"

8 Pathak P, "Varicocele management in the era of in vitro fertilization/intracytoplasmic sperm injection" 18 : 343-348, 2016

9 Dearing CG, "Validation of the sperm class analyser CASA system for sperm counting in a busy diagnostic semen analysis laboratory" 17 : 37-44, 2014

10 Tomlinson MJ, "Uncertainty of measurement and clinical value of semen analysis: has standardisation through professional guidelines helped or hindered progress?" 4 : 763-770, 2016

11 Borges E Jr, "Total motile sperm count has a superior predictive value over the WHO 2010 cut-off values for the outcomes of intracytoplasmic sperm injection cycles" 4 : 880-886, 2016

12 Mortimer ST, "The future of computer-aided sperm analysis" 17 : 545-553, 2015

13 Murray KS, "The effect of the new 2010 World Health Organization criteria for semen analyses on male infertility" 98 : 1428-1431, 2012

14 Meng MV, "Surgery or assisted reproduction? a decision analysis of treatment costs in male infertility" 174 : 1926-1931, 2015

15 Ehlers J, "Standardization of computer-assisted semen analysis using an e-learning application" 76 : 448-454, 2011

16 Hasani N, "Spermatogenesis disorder is associated with mutations in the ligand-binding domain of an androgen receptor" 51 : e13376-, 2019

17 Majzoub A, "Specialized sperm function tests in varicocele and the future of andrology laboratory" 18 : 205-212, 2016

18 Arafa M, "Semen quality and infertility status can be identified through measures of oxidation-reduction potential" 50 : 2018

19 Keel BA, "Results of the American Association of Bioanalysts national proficiency testing programme in andrology" 15 : 680-686, 2000

20 Figueroa D, "Real time monitoring and quantification of reactive oxygen species in breast cancer cell line MCF-7 by 2’,7’-dichlorofluorescin diacetate (DCFDA)assay" 94 (94): 26-33, 2018

21 Bar-Or R, "Raman spectral signatures of human liver perfusates correlate with oxidation reduction potential" 2 : 175-180, 2009

22 Glazer CH, "Racial and sociodemographic differences of semen parameters among US men undergoing a semen analysis" 123 : 126-132, 2019

23 Babigumira JB, "Projecting the potential impact of the Cap-ScoreTM on clinical pregnancy, live births, and medical costs in couples with unexplained infertility" 35 : 99-106, 2018

24 Patel AS, "Prediction of male infertility by the World Health Organization laboratory manual for assessment of semen analysis : a systematic review" 16 : 96-102, 2017

25 Rael LT, "Plasma oxidation-reduction potential and protein oxidation in traumatic brain injury" 26 : 1203-1211, 2009

26 Agarwal A, "Oxidation-reduction potential of semen: what is its role in the treatment of male infertility?" 8 : 302-318, 2016

27 Kobori Y, "Novel device for male infertility screening with single-ball lens microscope and smartphone" 106 : 574-578, 2016

28 Schaff UY, "Novel centrifugal technology for measuring sperm concentration in the home" 107 : 358-364, 2017

29 Agarwal A, "Multi-center evaluation of oxidationreduction potential by the MiOXSYS in males with abnormal semen" 21 : 565-569, 2019

30 Agarwal A, "Multi-center evaluation of oxidation reduction potential assay in the infertile male" 108 (108): e317-, 2017

31 Koch A, "Moving semen analysis into the future" 1 : 1-2, 2017

32 Agarwal A, "Mechanisms of oligozoospermia : an oxidative stress perspective" 60 : 206-216, 2014

33 Talarczyk-Desole J, "Manual vs. computer-assisted sperm analysis: can CASA replace manual assessment of human semen in clinical practice?" 88 : 56-60, 2017

34 Wang C, "Limitations of semen analysis as a test of male fertility and anticipated needs from newer tests" 102 : 1502-1507, 2014

35 Keel BA, "Lack of standardization in performance of the semen analysis among laboratories in the United States" 78 : 603-608, 2002

36 Agarwal A, "Laboratory assessment of oxidative stress in semen" 16 : 77-86, 2017

37 Alshahrani S, "Interpretation of semen analysis using WHO 1999and WHO 2010 reference values: abnormal becoming normal" 50 : e12838-, 2018

38 Rael LT, "Injury severity and serum amyloid A correlate with plasma oxidation-reduction potential in multi-trauma patients : a retrospective analysis" 17 : 57-, 2009

39 Agarwal A, "Influence of demographic and clinical factors on surgical outcomes of the transobturator tape procedure in patients with Stress Urinary Incontinence" 8 : 126-132, 2015

40 Alipour H, "Improved sperm kinematics in semen samples collected after 2 h versus 4-7 days of ejaculation abstinence" 32 : 1364-1372, 2017

41 Agarwal A, "Home sperm testing device versus laboratory sperm quality analyzer : comparison of motile sperm concentration" 110 : 1277-1284, 2018

42 Filimberti E, "High variability in results of semen analysis in andrology laboratories in Tuscany(Italy) : the experience of an external quality control(EQC)programme" 1 : 401-407, 2013

43 Punjabi U, "Fifteen years of Belgian experience with external quality assessment of semen analysis" 4 : 1084-1093, 2016

44 Henkel R, "Ethnic differences in male fertility parameters in 3,915men examined for infertility in a single center introduction. Paper presented at: The American Society of Andrology 44th Annual Conference; 2019 Apr 6-9; Chicago, IL, USA" 7 (7): 91-, 2019

45 Van Voorhis BJ, "Effect of the total motile sperm count on the efficacy and cost-effectiveness of intrauterine insemination and in vitro fertilization" 75 : 661-668, 2001

46 Vij SC, "Editorial on"An automated smartphonebased diagnostic assay for point-of-care semen analysis"" 5 : 507-, 2017

47 Barratt CL, "ESHRE special interest group for andrology basic semen analysis course: a continued focus on accuracy, quality, efficiency and clinical relevance" 26 : 3207-3212, 2011

48 Lammers J, "Doubleblind prospective study comparing two automated sperm analyzers versus manual semen assessment" 31 : 35-43, 2014

49 Agarwal A, "Diagnostic application of oxidation-reduction potential assay for measurement of oxidative stress : clinical utility in male factor infertility" 34 : 48-57, 2017

50 Sikka SC, "Current updates on laboratory techniques for the diagnosis of male reproductive failure" 18 : 392-401, 2016

51 Agarwal A, "Current limitation and future perspective of sperm DNA fragmentation tests" 6 (6): S549-S552, 2017

52 Esteves SC, "Critical appraisal of World Health Organization’s new reference values for human semen characteristics and effect on diagnosis and treatment of subfertile men" 79 : 16-22, 2012

53 Majzoub A, "Correlation of oxidation reduction potential and total motile sperm count: its utility in the evaluation of male fertility potential" 2019

54 Gatimel N, "Continued existence of significant disparities in the technical practices of sperm morphology assessment and the clinical implications : results of a French questionnaire" 107 : 365-372.e3, 2017

55 Amann RP, "Computer-assisted sperm analysis(CASA) : capabilities and potential developments" 81 : 5-17.e1-e3, 2014

56 Esteves SC, "Clinical relevance of routine semen analysis and controversies surrounding the 2010 World Health Organization criteria for semen examination" 40 : 443-453, 2014

57 Agarwal A, "Characterizing semen parameters and their association with reactive oxygen species in infertile men" 12 : 33-, 2014

58 Sigman M, "Cell phone microscope for semen analysis" 106 : 549-, 2016

59 Schinfeld J, "Cap-ScoreTM prospectively predicts probability of pregnancy" 85 : 654-664, 2018

60 Alvarez C, "Biological variation of seminal parameters in healthy subjects" 18 : 2082-2088, 2003

61 Blickenstorfer K, "Are WHO recommendations to perform 2 consecutive semen analyses for reliable diagnosis of male infertility still valid?" 201 : 783-791, 2019

62 Stagos D, "Application of a new oxidation-reduction potential assessment method in strenuous exercise-induced oxidative stress" 20 : 154-162, 2015

63 Tello-Mora P, "Acrosome reaction and chromatin integrity as additional parameters of semen analysis to predict fertilization and blastocyst rates" 16 : 102-, 2018

64 Zeginiadou T, "Acrosome reaction : methods for detection and clinical significance" 32 : 335-343, 2000

65 Esteves SC, "A translational medicine appraisal of specialized andrology testing in unexplained male infertility" 46 : 1037-1052, 2014