일본의 전자파 규제법제와 관련 분쟁사례 분석 = Regulations and Legal Dispute related to the Electromagnetic Fields in Japan

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

We are usually exposed to a lot of electromagnetic fields not only in electronic products such as TV, radio, cellular phones but also in diverse fields such as X-ray pictures or radioactive treatment etc. The fact that these electromagnetic fields can be harmful to human body now belongs to the common sense more or less to us. Of course, if we have obvious scientific supporting evidences or research results regarding the harmfulness of electromagnetic fields, we shall be able to open the possibility of the concrete relief or the regulation means to protect us from the harmfulness. However, in reality, it is difficult to search for the obvious scientific evidences as to the harmfulness of electromagnetic fields, and just only the possibility of danger is suggested. In these situations, the necessity is recognized to study the case of the disputes over the damages to the environment or health owing to electromagnetic fields in japan. So in this thesis we reviewed dispute cases and precedents related to the electromagnetic fields in Japan where the issues owing to electromagnetic fields have been recognized socially and the disputes therefrom have been experienced several times rather than in Korea. As the result of study, we could not confirm the precedent which accepted the request of construction prohibition, the request of withdrawal·transfer, the request of operation prohibition for the reason of health damages owing to electromagnetic fields related to power cables or mobile phone base stations in Japan. The biggest cause is in that the court doesn’t acknowledge concrete danger, high-degree probability, that is, the scientific cause and effect relationship between the exposure of electromagnetic fields and the damages thereby regarding the evidence as to the worry of health damage by electromagnetic fields the plaintiff submitted. At length, the portion to be confirmed through Japanese dispute cases and precedents means that the relief itself of the damages owing to electromagnetic fields is extremely difficult within the frame of previous judicial relief system. Therefore, as most of the countries don’t focus on the relief of the damages in the environmental health owing to the exposure of electromagnetic fields but they emphasize the prevention thereby and management, and a continuous research and development for the prevention of the damages, so it is important for us to establish the regulation standard by public law for the prevention of damage occurrence or management. Of course, we shall continue the study to verify the scientific cause and effect relationship between the exposure of electromagnetic fields and the damages therefrom.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이종영, "전자파의 위험가능성에 관한 법적문제" 24 (24): 1996

2 김상태, "전자파로 인한 신체적 손해배상에 관한 법리 －미국에서의 논의를 중심으로－" 한양법학회 23 (23): 37-65, 2012

3 박종원, "전자파 분쟁 해소를 위한 환경법의 역할, 미래·융합법제 연구보고서" 법제처 2013

4 김은주, "송전탑 건설을 중심으로 한 전자파 분쟁의 현황과 법적 과제" 한국토지공법학회 40 : 293-315, 2008

5 박종원, "송전선로 건설에 따른 전자파 분쟁과 환경법의 역할" 한국환경법학회 35 (35): 241-274, 2013

6 김현수, "미국법상 전자파에 의한 손해와 불법행위책임" 법학연구소 5 (5): 209-230, 2012

7 이준서, "독일의 전자파 관리법제의 동향" 한국법제연구원 2011

8 이종태, "대기오염의 건강 영향 평가를 위한 역학연구 설계 및 방법론" 34 (34): 2001

9 김민규, "경관이익의 침해와 불법행위책임법의 만남" 한국토지법학회 27 (27): 117-140, 2011

10 이상욱, "경관이익의 법적 보호에 관한 연구- 일본에서의 학설과 판례를 참조하여 -" 한국비교사법학회 13 (13): 403-426, 2006

11 永野秀雄, "電磁波訴訟の判例と理論" 三和書籍 2008

12 鈴木美惠子, "電磁波被曝で７つの腫瘍勞動基準局に再審査請求" (223) : 2010

13 清瀬信次郎, "眺望権論" 19 (19): 1985

14 大塚直, "環境法" 有斐閣 2006

15 星野英一, "現代社会と民法学の動向(上)" 有斐閣 1992

16 吉川日出男, "民法学と比較法学の諸相Ⅰ" 信山社 1996

17 長尾英彦, "景観権｣論の現状" 40 (40): 2006

18 岩間徹, "國際環境法上の予防原則について" (1264) : 2004

19 堀口健夫, "予防原則の規範的意義" (18) : 2002

20 松村弓彦, "ロースクール 環境法" 成文堂 2006

21 Sherry Young, "Regulatory and Judicial Responses to the Possibility of Biological Hazards from Electromagnetic Fields Generated by Powerlines" 36 : 129-, 1991

22 박종원, "REACH 규칙과 사전배려원칙" 한국환경법학회 31 (31): 109-148, 2009