유연안전성 담론과 전략에 대한 비판적 고찰 = A Critical Review of Flexicurity Dialogue and Its Strategy

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper is to critically review flexicurity dialogue and strategy and draw implications for labor market reform and social security system in Korea. While the so-called flexicurity strategy is to overcome hhe flexibilization at the margin, it is criticized for poor empirical evidences of its necessity and effectiveness, priority being given prior consideration for flexibility rather than security in its practice and application, and not being able to overcome labor market dualization. The social exchange of job protection and social protection is necessary for extending social security to unprotected areas of labor force, economic restructuring and technological development. For flexicurity strategy to succeed, however, low level of inequality in labor market, progressive social security system, provention of layoff by firms with moral hazards are necessary, and to establish effective social security system, establishing optimal EPL and considering individual‘s cultural mentality about security, particularly job security are very important. As an implication, Korea should try to reach optimal level of EPL and to establish proper social seucurity system step by step and simultaneously.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 정원호, "유럽의 유연안정성(flexicurity) 전략 연구: 직업훈련정책의 발전방향모색을 위한 기초연구" 한국직업능력개발원 2004

2 조돈문, "유럽연합의 유연안정성 모델과 유럽노총의 전략적 선택" 한국산업노동학회 21 (21): 125-161, 2015

3 조돈문, "유럽연합의 유연안정성 모델: 유연성과 안정성의 균형 실험" 한국산업노동학회 20 (20): 317-354, 2014

4 조돈문, "스웨덴 노동시장의 유연성-안정성 균형 실험: 황금삼각형과 이중보호체계" 한국산업노동학회 21 (21): 99-137, 2015

5 이호근, "비정규 근로 대책방안― 한국적 유연안정성모델의 정착을 위한 조건 ―" 한국사회정책학회 13 : 129-198, 2006

6 정원호, "덴마크의 유연안정성 정책에 관한 고찰" 한국EU학회 10 (10): 41-73, 2005

7 윤진호, "덴마크의 유연안전성에 관한 현황과 평가" 한국노동조합총연맹 중앙연구원 2008

8 Boeri, Tito, "Would you like to shrink the welfare state? A survey of European citizens" 16 (16): 7-50, 2001

9 Storm, Servaas, "Why labour market regulation may pay off: Worker motivation, co-ordination and productivity growth. Employment Analysis and Research Unit" Economic and Labour Market Analysis Department, ILO 2007

10 Alesina, Alberto, "Why Are Stabilizations Delayed?" 81 (81): 1170-1188, 1991

11 Holmlund, Bertil, "What do labor market institutions do?" 30 (30): 62-69, 2014

12 Frey, B., "What can Economists Learn from Happiness Research" XL : 402-435, 2002

13 Belot, M., "Welfare Improving Employment Protection" 74 : 381-386, 2007

14 Boeri, Tito, "Two Tier Reforms of Employment Protection:a Honeymoon Effect?" 117 : 357-385, 2007

15 Tangian, Andranik, "Towards Consistent Implementation of Flexicurity" 14 (14): 2008

16 European Commission, "Towards Common Principles of Flexicurity: More and Better Jobs Through Flexibility and Security" 2007

17 Keune M., "The rise of flexicurity in Europe. Why the Commission Adopted Flexicurity and How it Understands the Concept" 2006

18 Boeri, T., "The political economy of Flexicurity" 10 (10): 684-715, 2012

19 Blanchard, O., "The perverse effects of partial labour market reform: fixed-term contracts in France" 112 (112): 189-213, 2002

20 Crouch, Collin, "The governance of uncertainty and sustainability: tensions and opportunities" GUSTO 1-, 2009

21 Amable, Bruno, "The effect of employment protection and product market regulation on labour market performance : substitution or complementarity?" 43 (43): 449-, 2011

22 D'Orlando, Fabio, "The demand for job protection: Some clues from behavioural economics" 38 (38): 104-114, 2009

23 Blanchard, Olivier, "The Joint Design of Unemployment Insurance and Employment Protection: A First Pass" 6 : 45-77, 2008

24 ETUC, "The Flexicurity debate and the Challenges for the Trade Union Movement" 2007

25 Dewatripont, Mathias, "The Design of Reform Packages under Uncertainty" 85 (85): 1207-1223, 1995

26 Madsen, P.K., "The Danish Model of ‘Flexicurity’ A Paradise with some Snakes" Eurofound 2002

27 Cahuc, P., "Temporary jobs, employment protection and labour market performance" 9 (9): 63-91, 2002

28 Bonoli, Giuliano, "Social policy through labor markets: Understanding national differences in the provision of economic security to wage earners" 36 (36): 1007-1030, 2003

29 Jessoula, Matteo, "Selective Flexicurity’ in Segmented Labour Markets: The Case of Italian ‘Mid-Siders" 39 (39): 561-583, 2010

30 Clark, Andrew E., "Satisfaction and comparison income" CEPREMAP 1994

31 Agell J., "On the benefits from rigid labour markets: norms, market failures, and social insurance" 109 (109): 143-164, 1999

32 장신철, "OECD 국가의 노동시장 정책" 한국고용정보원 2011

33 Bergh, Andeas, "OECD recommends: A consensus for or against welfare states? Evidence from a new database" Ratio 2010

34 OECD, "OECD Employment Outlook" OECD 1999

35 OECD, "OECD Employment Outlook" OECD 1994

36 OECD, "Non-regular employment, job security and the labour market divide, OECD Employment Outlook 2014" 2014

37 Tangian, Andranik, "Monitoring Flexicurity policies in the EU with dedicated composite indicators" Hans Bockler Stiftung 2005

38 Blanchard O., "Macroeconomic effects of regulation and deregulation in goods and labor markets" 879-907, 2003

39 Storm, S., "Labour market regulation and productivity growth : evidence for twenty OECD countries(1984-2004)" 48 (48): 629-654, 2009

40 Sachs, Andreas, "Labour market performance in OECD countries: A comprehensive empirical modelling approach of institutional interdependencies" ZEW 2013

41 Freeman R., "Labour Market Institutions without Blinders: The Debate over Flexibility and Labour Market Performance" NBER 2005

42 Groot., Ayolt J. De, "Labour Market Effects Of Flexicurity From A Regional Perspective" 101 (101): 392-408, 2010

43 Koeniger, Winfried, "Labor Market Institutions and Wage Inequality" 60 (60): 340-356, 2007

44 Clark, Andrew, "Job security and job protection" 61 (61): 207-239, 2009

45 Bassanini, Andrea, "Job protection legislation and productivity growth in OECD countries" 24 : 349-402, 2009

46 Tangian, Andranik, "Is Europe Ready for Flexicurity? Empirical Evidence, Critical Remarks and a Reform Proposal" 2008

47 Bertola, G., "Institutions and Labour Reallocation" 41 : 1147-1171, 1997

48 Di Tella R., "Happiness adaptation to income and to status in an individual panel" NBER 2007

49 Nickell, S., "Handbook of Labor Economics, 3" 3029-3066, 1999

50 Braga de Macedo, Jorge, "Growth, Reform Indicators and Policy Complementaries" NBER 2006

51 Sapir, A, "Globalisation and the Reform of European Social Models" 44 : 369-390, 2005

52 Henning, Jørgensen, "From a Beautiful Swan to an Ugly Duckling: the Renewal of Danish Activation Policy since 2003" 11 (11): 337-368, 2009

53 Cahuc, Pierre, "For a unified contract" 3 (3): 191-206, 2012

54 Hoffer, Frank, "Flexicurity: The Broken Promise"

55 Camfors, Lars, "Flexicurity-An Answer or A Question? European Policy Analysis" Swedish Institute for European Policy Studies 2007

56 Davoine, Thomas, "Flexicurity, Taxes and Job Reallocatio" CESifo 2015

57 Olaf Van Vliet, "Flexicurity in the European Union:flexibility for outsiders, security for insiders" MPRA 2012

58 Wilthagen, Ton, "Flexicurity in the Crisis: the Case of Short-time Working Arrangements" 2010

59 Viebrock, Elke, "Flexicurity and Welfare Reform: A Review" 7 : 305-331, 2009

60 Klindt, Gjedde, "Flexicurity and Beyond: Finding a New Agenda for the European Social Model" Djoef Publishing 2006

61 Andersen, Torben, "Flexicurity - Labour Market Performance in Denmark" 53 : 389-429, 2007

62 Baker, Dean, "Fighting Unemployment: The Limits of Free Market Orthodoxy" Oxford University Press 2005

63 Allard, G. J., "Euro-Productivity and Euro-Jobs Since the 1960s: Which Institutions Mattered?" IE 2006

64 Fonseca, R., "Entrepreneurship, Start-up Costs and Employment" 45 : 692-605, 2001

65 Heyes, Jason, "Employment Protection Under Fire: Why labour market deregulation will not deliver quality jobs" 2012

66 OECD, "Employment Protection Regulation and Labour Market Performance, in Employment Outlook 2004" OECD 2004

67 Pissarides, C., "Employment Protection" 8 : 131-159, 2001

68 OECD, "Devided We Stand" OECD 2011

69 Méda, Dominique, "Deconstructing Flexicurity and Developing Alternative Approaches: Towards New Concepts and Approaches for Employment and Social Policy" Routledge 2014

70 Cahuc, Pierre, "De la précarité à la mobilité: vers une Sécurité sociale professionnelle" ministre de l’Finances et de l’’Cohésion sociale 2004

71 Zhou, J., "Danish for All? Balancing Flexibility with Security: The Flexicurity Model" IMF 2007

72 D'Orlando, Fabio, "Culturally based beliefs and labor market institutions" Elsevier 40 (40): 150-162, 2011

73 Blanchard, Olivier, "Contours of Employment Protection Reform" MIT Dept of Economics 2003

74 Algan, Yann, "Civic Attitudes and Design of Labor Market Institutions: Which Countries Can Implement the Danish Flexicurity Model?" 1 (1): 111-145, 2009

75 Boeri, Tito, "Beyond Eurosclerosis" 24 (24): 409-461, 2009

76 Howell, David, "Are Protective Labor Market Institutions at the Root of Unemployment? A Critical Review of the Evidence" 2 (2): 2007

77 Ichino, Andrea, "Are Judges Biased by Labor Market Conditions?" 47 (47): 913-944, 2003

78 Davoine, Thomas, "A Theoretical Rationale for Flexicurity Policies Based on Education" Institute for Advanced Studies, Vienna 2015

79 Bertola, G., "A Pure Theory of Job Security and Labour Income Risk" 71 (71): 43-61, 2004