This dissertation brings together inquiries into the development of narrative in language and drawing, two fields which have traditionally been studied in theoretical and empirical isolation from one another. They are considered as interrelated aspec...
This dissertation brings together inquiries into the development of narrative in language and drawing, two fields which have traditionally been studied in theoretical and empirical isolation from one another. They are considered as interrelated aspects of one overarching phenomenon—namely, the development and use of symbolic representation in early childhood. Testing procedures and coding methods were designed to allow analyses of developmental effects as well as direct comparisons of narrative structure in the two different media.
64 children, ages 3 and 5, were presented with one of two short movie excerpts and were asked both to tell an unfamiliar adult the stories they had seen and to draw the stories for another, also unfamiliar—but absent—adult. This procedure generated three types of narratives: oral, drawn (with no verbal descriptions), and drawn with accompanying verbal explanations. All data were coded for the presence of information contributing to the temporal, goal-oriented, and spatial structures of subjects' narratives and analyses were performed on between-groups and within-subjects factors. Developmental effects were found with respect to narrative length, accuracy, and completeness, and with respect to the presence of information about time, goals, and space. Stimulus effects were found such that differences in the spatial and goal structures of the two movies interacted to affect corresponding structures in the subjects' narratives. Finally, within-subjects analyses revealed that the three narrative types were distinct in their structural characteristics at both ages.
The results of this study carry clear implications for an understanding of narrative competence and symbolic representation. It was found that narrative structure develops similarly across different symbolic media, but that the specific kind of information included will vary, depending on the representational means used to construct a story. Representational development, then, operates by way of an interaction between domain-specific skills and more general cognitive capacities. Future studies must incorporate investigations of multiple modes of representation if we are to gain a more accurate understanding of the nature and development of symbolic representation in human cognition.