<오마이뉴스>와 전현직 기자 블로그의 저널리즘적 특성: 미국산 쇠고기 수입 관련 기사의 프레임 내용분석 = Journalistic Characteristics of Oh My News and Professional Journalists` Blogs: Framing Content Analysis of Stories about Import of Beef from the U.S.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

With the goal of finding out the differences between the Internet news media and blog in their news reports, this study has content-analyzed news reports of a major Internet news media, Oh My News and the contents of eight blog sites of professional journalists. Internet news media and blogs have shown little difference in six levels of framing, but both have contrasting differences in three levels. More than half of the news reports of Oh My News and the contents of blogs were written in negative tone. News value of proximity was found in all of the news reports and blog contents that were content analyzed. Three levels of framing where differences were found between Internet news media and weblogs are `time,` `narrative structure,` and `thematic vs. episodic` frame levels. In `time` level, the contents of the blogs were mostly focusing on the `present`, whereas Oh My News had more news reports about the `past` and `future` than did blog sites. In narrative structure, more story-telling narrative structure was found than chronicle narrative structure from both Oh My News and blog sites, but a lot more contents written in story-telling structure were found from blog sites than from Oh My News. Blog sites employed less episodic frame and more thematic frame than did Oh My News. Based on these similarities and differences between these two major Internet-based media, it is speculated if blogs can provide the Internet users with advanced news services while maintaining blog`s own features.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박광순, "인터넷의 웹블로그(Web-blog) 이용동기와 만족도에 관한 연구: 대학생 집단을 중심으로" 한국언론학회 48 (48): 270-294, 2004

2 진행남, "인터넷미디어의 뉴스 영역 및 유형에 관한 연구" 한국언론학회 46 (46): 20-632, 2002

3 이동근, "온라인 뉴스 미디어의 다양성에 관한 일고찰: 정보원 및 프레임 분석을 통하여" 한국언론학회 48 (48): 218-242, 2004

4 노기영, "블로그의 매체경쟁에 관한 연구: 관계지향 블로그와 정보지향 블로그의 적소분석을 통한 경쟁분석" 한국언론학회 49 (49): 318-345, 2005

5 이재현, "블로그와 저널리즘" 22-30, 2005

6 한선, "블로그(Blog)를 통한 의미실천 양상과 함의에 관한 연구" 한국언론학회 50 (50): 354-383, 2006

7 권상희, "블로그(Blog) 양식: 커뮤니케이터, 구성형태, 내용, 연결성에 따른 장르유형분석 연구" 사이버커뮤니케이션학회 15 (15): 93-134, 2005

8 권상희, "블로그(Blog) 미디어 연구 블로그 이용 및 만족과 인지 행태에 관한 연구" 한국방송학회 19 (19): 419-460, 2005

9 김영주, "블로그 1인 미디어의 가능성과 한계" 한국언론재단 2005

10 이정환, "블로거가 본업 ‘이정환 닷컴’: 정치적으로 올바른 ‘다른 경제’를 꿈꾼다" 신문과방송 2008

11 Wimmer,R., "매스미디어 조사방법론" 나남 1994

12 김고은, "네티즌,더 이상 뉴스 소비자가 아니다:행동하는 블로거,정책검증에 의제설정까지" PD저널 2008

13 김 예란, "가상공간의 공동체 문화 탐색:사이월드 문화를 중심으로" 성곡언론문화재단 12 (12): 55-89, 2004

14 Blood,Rebecca, "Weblogs:A history and perspective In Living in the Information Age" Wadsworth 2005

15 Matheson,D, "Weblogs and the epistemology of the news:Some trends in online journalism" 6 : 443-468, 2004

16 Blood,Rebecca., "Weblogs and journalism: Do they connect?" 61-63, 2003

17 Bowman,S., "We media:How audiences are shaping the future of news and information" The Media Center at the American Press Institute 2003

18 McCombs,M., "The convergence of agenda setting and framing. In Framing Public Life:Perspectives on Media and Our Understanding of the Social World" Lawrence Erlbaum 67-81, 2001

19 Matthes,J., "The content analysis of media frames:Toward improving reliability and validity" 58 : 258-279, 2008

20 Shulevitz, J., "The close reader: At large in the blogosphere" The New York Times 31-, 2002

21 McCombs,M., "Setting the agenda of attributes in the 1996 Spanish general election" 50 : 77-92, 2000

22 Altheide,L.D, "Qualitative media analysis" Sage 1996

23 Stroller, M, "Presidential session at bloggercon"

24 Cohen,E.L., "Online journalism as market-driven journalism" 46 : 532-548, 2002

25 Wood,A., "Online communication: Linking technology, identity and culture" Lawrence Erlbaum 2000

26 Bricklin, D, "Observations from a weblogger"

27 Donohew,L, "Newswriting styles:What arouses the reader?" 3 : 3-6, 1983

28 Price,V., "News values and public opinion:A process:How political advertising and TV news prime viewers to think about issues and candidates. In Television and Political Advertising" Lawrence Erlbaum 265-309, 1995

29 Shoemaker,P., "Mediating the Message:Theories of Influences on Mass Media Content" Longman 1996

30 Chyi,H., "Media salience and the process of framing:Coverage of the Columbine school shootings" 81 (81): 22-35, 2004

31 Balnaves,M., "Media professions and the new humanism" 18 (18): 191-203, 2004

32 Wicks,R., "Going negative:Candidate usage of Internet web sites during the 2000 Presidential campaign" 80 (80): 128-144, 2003

33 Entman,R.M, "Framing:Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm" 43 : 51-58, 1993

34 Ghanem,S, "Filling in the tapestry:The second level of agenda setting. In Communication and Democracy." Lawrence Erlbaum 3-14, 1997

35 Yoon,D., "Content comparison of Presidential election campaigns: Functional approach to the candidate’s and their party’s web sites and tv spots" 2005

36 Weare,C., "Content analysis of the world wide web: Opportunities and challenges" 18 : 272-292, 2000

37 Holsti,O., "Content Analysis for the Social Sciences and Humanities" Addison-Wesley 1969

38 Bichard,S., "Building blogs:A multi-dimensional analysis of the distribution of frames on the 2004 presidential candidate web sites" 83 (83): 329-345, 2006

39 Welch, M., "Blogworld and its gravity: Weighing the bloggers" 42 (42): 2003

40 Lawson-Borders,G., "Blogs in campaign communication" 49 (49): 548-559, 2005

41 Keren,M., "Blogging and the politics of melancholy" 29 : 5-23, 2004

42 Wolcott, J., "Blog nation. Business 2.0"

43 Fleishmann,G, "Been"Blogging"? Web discourse hits higher level. In We’ve Got Blog:How weblogs are changing our culture" Perseus Publishing 107-111, 2002

44 Riffe,D., "Analyzing media messages:Using quantitative content analysis in research" Lawrence Erlbaum 1998

45 Sullivan, A, "A blogger manifesto: Why online weblogs are one future for journalism"