델파이 조사법을 이용한 의료 자원 사용의 효율성 평가지표 개발 = Development of efficiency indicators for medical resources use using Delphi technique

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Because of the rising healthcare costs, there is a growing need for developing efficiency indicators for medical resources use and measuring efficiency of healthcare providers and healthcare systems using them. In this study, we aimed to develop efficiency indicators for medical resources use by means of Delphi technique.
We systematically reviewed the existing measures of medical resource use. Thirty nine indicators were selected as a candidates across the six domains: medical personnel, medical equipment, medical facilities, ethical management, resource efficiency, and drug use. To develop efficiency indicators with professional consensus, a 2-round Delphi survey was conducted among 29 professional experts. The following indicators were selected based on the Delphi survey results: adjusted number of the patient per day and level of the nurse number medical personnel in medical personnel domain; the number of the scan a professional physician and the quality of the scan in medical equipment domain; bed utilization rate in medical facility domain; drug price reported pharmaceutical price by medical institutions, medical fee billing transparency, and medical care appropriateness in ethical management domain; costliness index in resource efficiency domain; and utilization of high cost drug and items per prescription in drug use domain.
The efficiency indicators could provide valid information about efficiency of healthcare providers and healthcare systems with respect to their resources use and facilitate policies to improve their efficiency.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 보건복지부, "한국보건산업진흥원. 의료기관평가지침서" 보건복지부, 한국보건산업진흥원 2003

2 한국의료영상품질관리원, "특수의료장비관리자 교육" 한국의료영상품질관리원 3-95, 2008

3 김 윤, "질 평가자료 수집시스템 개발에 관한 연구" 건강보험심사평가원 2007

4 보건복지가족부, "지역거점 공공병원 운영평가 지침서" 보건복지가족부, 한국보건산업진흥원 2007

5 보건복지가족부, "종합전문요양기관 인정제도 및 평가계획" 보건복지가족부 2008

6 보건복지가족부, "종합병원 의료기관평가결과" 보건복지가족부 2007

7 건강보험심사평가원, "의약품 공급기관 거래형태별 의약품 공급현황" 건강보험심사평가원 의약품관리종합정보센터 2009

8 차영주, "의료장비의 질관리를 위한 연구:진단검사의학과 의료장비 중심" 건강보험심사평가원 2008

9 권영대, "의료의 결과 평가와 위험요인 보정" 15 (15): 48-56, 2007

10 건강보험심사평가원, "요양기관 프로파일 사용자 지침서" 건강보험심사평가원 2008

11 지원철, "요양기관 종합정보를 활용한 종합관리중재대상기관 선정방안에 대한 연구" 건강보험심사평가원 2008

12 조우현, "요양급여의 초․중․장기 평가대상 개발에 관한 연구" 연세대학교 보건정책 및 관리 연구소 2001

13 최윤정, "요양급여 적정성 평가를 위한 기준개발" 건강보험심사평가원 2009

14 김 윤, "요양급여 적정성 평가 효과분석 모형개발 연구" 건강보험심사평가원 2009

15 건강보험심사평가원, "심사평가 길잡이" 건강보험심사평가원 2011

16 조민창, "서울시 초, 중, 고 학생을 대상으로 한 집단뇨검사의 단백뇨와 혈뇨" 대한가정의학회 27 (27): 170-174, 2006

17 보건복지가족부, "국가 응급의료체계 모니터링 지표 개발 및 활용 방안 연구" 보건복지가족부, 서울대학교 2007

18 Lilford R, "Use and misuse of process and outcome data in managing performance of acute medical care: avoiding institutional stigma" 363 : 1147-1154, 2004

19 Andrews R, "Trends in hospital risk-adjusted mortality for select diagnoses and procedures 1994-2004" AHRQ 2007

20 Lammers JC, "Total quality management in hospitals: The contributions of commitment, quality councils, teams, budgets, and training to perceived improvement at Veterans Health Administration hospitals" 4 (4): 463-478, 1996

21 Turoff M, "The policy delphi, In the delphi method: Techniques and applications"

22 Donabedian A, "The definition of quality and approaches to its assessment" Health Administration Press 1980

23 Straube B, "The CMS Quality Roadmap: quality plus efficiency" W5-555-7-, 2005

24 Estabrooks CA, "The impact of hospital nursing characteristics on 30-day mortality" 54 (54): 74-84, 2005

25 "Taiwan Joint Commission on Hospital Accreditation"

26 Krumholz HM, "Standards for measures: efficiency in health care" 52 (52): 1518-1526, 2008

27 Vuori HV, "Quality assurance of health services: Concepts and methodology" World Health Organization 1982

28 The White House, "Promoting Quality and Efficiency Health Care in Federal Government Administered or Sponsored Health Programs"

29 AQA, "Principles of efficiency measures"

30 Center for medicare and medicaid services, "Medicare Resource use Measurement Plan" CMS 2009

31 Cassel CK, "Managing medical resources: return to the commons?" 297 (297): 2518-2521, 2007

32 최윤정, "MRI 급여전환에 대비한 관리방안 연구" 건강보험심사평가원 2004

33 Fiscella K, "Inequality in quality: Addressing socioeconomic, racial, and ethnic disparities in health care" 283 (283): 2579-2584, 2000

34 Schuster MA, "How good is the quality of health care in the United States?" 76 (76): 517-563, 1998

35 Hearld LR, "How do hospital organizational structure and processes affect quality of care?: a critical review of research methods" 65 (65): 259-299, 2008

36 Pennsylvania Health care cost containment council, "Hospital performance report 2009"

37 Hartz AJ, "Hospital characteristics and mortality rates" 321 (321): 1720-1725, 1989

38 O'Kane M, "Crossroads in quality" 27 (27): 749-758, 2008

39 Helms LB, "Comparison of continuing care communication" 30 (30): 255-260, 1998

40 Milstein A, "Comparing physicians on efficiency" 357 (357): 2649-2652, 2007

41 "Care Quality Commission"

42 Hussey PS, "A systematic review of health care efficiency measures" 44 (44): 784-805, 2009

43 건강보험심사평가원, "2010 하반기 약제 급여적정성평가 결과" 건강보험심사평가원 2010

44 대한병원협회, "2006년도 병원경영통계" 대한병원협회 2008