수학적 토론에서 의사소통적 갈등과 인지 갈등의 관계 = The Relationship between Cognitive Conflicts and Commognitive Conflicts in Mathematical Discussion

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In this study, we analyzed a mathematical discussion in the Calculus Ⅱ course of the Gifted Science Academy and individual interviews to determine the relationship between cognitive conflicts and commognitive conflicts. The mathematical discussion began with a question from a student who seemed to have a cognitive conflict about the osculating plane of a space curve. The results indicated that the commognitive conflicts were resolved by ritualizing and using the socially constructed knowledge, but cognitive conflicts were not resolved. Furthermore, we found that the cause of the cognitive conflict resulted from the student’s imperfect analogical reasoning and the reflective discourse about it could be a learning opportunity for overcoming the conflict. These findings imply that cognitive conflicts can trigger the appearance of commognitive conflicts, but the elimination of commognitive conflicts does not imply that cognitive conflicts are resolved.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구에서는 의사소통적 갈등과 인지 갈등의 관계를 확인하기 위해 과학영재학교 3학년 미적분학Ⅱ 수업시간에 이루어진 수학적 토론 및 개별 면담 사례를 분석하였다. 교실에서 수학적 토론은 접촉평면에 관하여 인지 갈등을 보이는 한 학생의 질문에서 시작되었다. 분석 결과 토론 과정에서 사회적으로 구성된 지식을 관습화하여 사용함으로서 의사소통적 갈등이 해소되고 있지만 인지 갈등은 완전히 해소되지 않고 있음을 확인하였다. 또한 토론을 촉발한 학생의 인지 갈등의 원인이 불완전한 유추의 사용에서 비롯되었음을 확인하였으며, 유추 활동에 대한 반성적 담론의 조성이 인지 갈등을 극복하는 학습 기회가 된다는 것을 발견하였다. 본 연구를 통해 인지 갈등이 의사소통적 갈등의 출현을 촉발할 수 있지만, 의사소통적 갈등의 해소가 인지 갈등의 해소를 함의하지는 않는다는 것을 알 수 있다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이경화, "수학적 지식의 구성에서 유추적 사고의 역할" 대한수학교육학회 19 (19): 355-369, 2009

2 정영옥, "수학교육학 연구방법론" 경문사 2006

3 지정은, "수학 교실의 토의 담화 분석" 서울대학교 대학원 2006

4 황혜정, "수학 교과에서의 집단탐구식 수업 방법에 관한 고찰" 대한수학교육학회 12 (12): 1-16, 2002

5 O'Connor, M. C., "“Can any fraction be turned into a decimal?” A case study of a mathematical group discussion" 46 (46): 143-185, 2001

6 Sfard, A., "When the rules of discourse change, but nobody tells you : Making sense of mathematics learning from a commognitive standpoint" 16 (16): 567-615, 2007

7 Lampert, M., "When the problem is not the question and the solution is not the answer : Mathematical knowing and teaching" 27 (27): 29-63, 1990

8 Hoyles, C., "What is the point of group discussion in mathematics?" 16 (16): 205-214, 1985

9 Thomas, G. B., "Thomas' calculus early transcendentals" Pearson 2010

10 Sfard, A., "Thinking as communicating:Human development, the growth of discourses, and mathematizing" Cambridge University Press 2008

11 Sfard, A., "There is more to discourse than meets the ears: Looking at thinking as communicating to learn more about mathematical learning" 46 (46): 13-57, 2001

12 Piaget, J., "The principles of genetic epistemology" Basic Books 1972

13 Cobb, P., "The emergence of mathematical meaning: Interaction in classroom cultures" Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 1995

14 Soucy McCrone, S., "The development of mathematical discussions : An investigation in a fifth-grade classroom" 7 (7): 111-133, 2005

15 Yackel, E., "Sociomathematical norms, argumentation, and autonomy in mathematics" 27 : 458-477, 1996

16 Cresswell, J. C., "Research design:Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches" Sage 1994

17 Sfard, A., "Reification as the birth of metaphor" 14 (14): 44-55, 1994

18 Cobb, P., "Reflective discourse and collective reflection" 28 : 258-277, 1997

19 Von Glasersfeld, E., "Radical constructivism:A way of knowing and learning" The Falmer Press 1995

20 Steffe, L. P., "Radical constructivism in mathematics education" Kluwer Academic Publishers 177-194, 1991

21 Richards, J., "Radical constructivism in mathematics education" Kluwer Academic Publishers 13-51, 1991

22 Merriam, S. B., "Qualitative research and case study applications in education" Jossey-Bass 1998

23 Voigt, J., "Patterns and routines in classroom interaction" 6 (6): 69-118, 1985

24 Freudenthal, H., "Mathematics as an educational task" Reidel 1973

25 Polya, G., "Mathematics and plausible reasoning Ⅰ: Induction and analogy in mathematics" Princeton University Press 1954

26 박진석, "Mathematica를 활용한 미분기하학 개론" 경문사 2010

27 Bartolini Bussi, M., "Mathematical discussion and perspective drawing in primary school" 31 (31): 11-41, 1996

28 Pirie, S. E. B., "Mathematical discussion and mathematical understanding" 19 : 459-470, 1988

29 Weber, K., "Learning opportunities from group discussions : Warrants become the objects of debate" 68 (68): 247-261, 2008

30 Sfard, A., "Introduction : Developing mathematical discourse—Some insights from communicational research" 51 : 1-9, 2012

31 Bauersfeld, H., "Hidden dimensions in the so-called reality of a mathematics classroom" 11 (11): 23-41, 1980

32 Cobb, P., "Constructivist, emergent, and sociocultural perspective in the context of developmental research" 31 (31): 175-190, 1996

33 Sfard, A., "Cognition as communication: Rethinking learning-by-talking through multi-faceted analysis of students'mathematical interactions" 8 (8): 42-76, 2001

34 English, L. D., "Analogical reasoning and the development of algebraic abstraction" 30 (30): 135-157, 1996

35 Yackel, E., "A journey in mathematics education research" Springer 2011