Appraisal of Guidelines for Research & Evaluation (AGREE) II를 이용한 교통사고 상해증후군의 국내·외 기개발 임상진료지침의 평가 = Appraisal of Guidelines for Research & Evaluation II Appraisal of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Traffic Injuries

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Objectives This study was aimed to evaluate clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) of traffic injuries, which has already been developed at domestic or outside of country, and to explore the Korean medical treatments included in the CPGs.
Methods Twelve electronic databases (PubMed, Cochrane library, China National Knowledge Infrastructure [CNKI {Chinese Academic Journals, CAJ}], Research Information Sharing Service [RISS], Oriental Medicine Advanced Searching Integrated System [OASIS], KoreaMed, Korean Medical Guideline Information [KoMGI), National Guideline Clearinghouse [AHRQ], Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials Initiative Website [COMET], Turning Research into Practice [TRIP], The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence [NICE], and Medical Research Information Center [MedRIC]) up to July 2021 were searched. Only systematically developed CPGs for traffic injuries were selected and appraised. The appraisal was conducted by using Appraisal of Guidelines for Research & Evaluation (AGREE) II tool.
Results Six CPGs were included and evaluated. All CPGs were appraised as highly recommended because they exceeded 60% in more than 4 among 6 domains of AGREE II, including domain of ‘rigor of development’, and 30% in the rest. Recommendations related to Korean medicine treatments such as on manual therapy related to Chuna were given in 6 CPGs, 4 for acupuncture, 1 for Qigong and 1 for Taping.
Conclusions The 6 CPGs were developed up to now through a systematic development methodology and there were many recommendations for Korean medical treatments related to manual (Chuna) treatment, acupuncture and Qigong. However, the evidence for the side effects and risk factors of Korean medical treatments was scantly reflected in CPGs. Therefore, it is considered that balanced CPG with benefits and risks should be developed, covering Korean medical diagnosis, treatment and prognosis. (J Korean Med Rehabil 2021;31(4):129-143)

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박정오, "급성 경⋅요추 염좌로 진단된 교통사고 환자에서 歸脾湯과 當歸鬚散의 효과에 대한 임상 연구" 한방재활의학과학회 25 (25): 81-90, 2015

2 신희라, "교통사고 환자 237예에 대한 한의치료 만족도 조사" 한방재활의학과학회 28 (28): 67-78, 2018

3 Korea Transportation Safety Authority, "Traffic accidents by year"

4 Bussieres AE, "The treatment of neck pain-associated disorders and whiplash-associated disorders : a clinical practice guideline" 39 (39): 523-564, 2016

5 Ciapponi A, "The quality of clinical practice guidelines for preoperative care using the AGREE II instrument : a systematic review" 9 (9): 1-16, 2020

6 Spitzer WO, "Scientific monograph of the Quebec Task Force on Whiplash-Associated Disorders : redefining"whiplash"and its management" 20 (20): 1-73, 1995

7 Bryans R, "Practice guide for the management of whiplash-associated disorders in adults"

8 Guideline center for Korean Medicine, "Manual for developing Evidence based Clinical Practice Guidelines of Korean Medicine" Koonja Publishing 11-17, 2018

9 Shin BC, "Korean medicine clinical practice guideline for traffic injuries" Guideline Center for Korean Medicine 2020

10 The Society of Korean Medicine Rehabilitation, "Korean Rehabilitation Medicine" Koonja Publishing 236-239, 2015

11 Steering Committee for Clinical Practice Guideline, "Korean Appraisal of Guidelines for Research & Evaluation II"

12 Ministry of Land, "Infrastructure and transport"

13 Cameron I, "Guidelines for the management of acute whiplash associated disorders for health professionals" State Insurance Regulatory Authority 2014

14 Wong JJ, "Clinical practice guidelines for the management of conditions related to traffic collisions : a systematic review by the OPTIMa collaboration" 37 (37): 471-489, 2015

15 Scholten-Peeters GG, "Clinical practice guideline for the physiotherapy of patients with whiplash-associated disorders" 27 (27): 412-422, 2002

16 National Clearinghouse for Korean Medicine, "Clinical practice guideline"

17 Moore A, "Clinical guidelines for the physiotherapy management of whiplash associated disorder" Chartered Society of Physiotherapy 2005

18 Cameron I, "Clinical guidelines for best practice management of acute and chronic whiplash-associated disorders" Motor Accident Commission (MAC), South Australian Centre for Trauma and Injury Recovery (TRACsa) 2008

19 Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service, "2020 automobile insurance medical expense statistic"