대규모 국제 체육행사로서 올림픽 경기가 국가의 법규범의 변화에 미치는 영향 = The Impacts of the Olympic Games on the State as an International mega-Sports Events

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Mega sporting events can be defined by their impacts on the society and state and complexity in organization and delivery channel. I challenge the events which include its various characteristics such as economy, culture, law, politics and they must not be treated as just typical single and simple sports event. The top of the ideology and value system of Olympic games may be deduced from the philosophy of Olympicism. The games are organized under the framework that made by International Olympic Committee and Olympic spirits as driving forces are strongly impact on the growth of the events.
The paper concludes that while the prospect of economic growth is the driving force behind bids for hosting the mega sports event (i.e., Olympic Games), the legacies that follow their hosting are difficult to quantify, prone to political interpretation and multifaceted.
Single and multi-sport events of all natures are multiplying, an increasing number of cities and countries want to host such events, and sponsorship is on the rise both in terms of the number of business organizations wanting to be involved as well as the dollar amounts associated with sponsoring event. These statements are especially true for mega sporting events. Such events are traditionally defined as events designated as being a ‘must-see’ event able to attract worldwide publicity.
Countries and cities vigorously compete to host sports mega-events because they perceive that doing so will enhance their image and stimulate or boom-up their economies.
International sporting events necessarily require substantial expenditures on infrastructure, organization and security and critically depend, therefore, on public subsidization.
Accordingly, careful attention is paid to the presence of constraints on interest and concerns on the goods and service and on the sources of many side of Olympic business and capital investments.
One of the reasons for the increased popularity of mega sporting events is the supposed legacies the events can bring to the host region. These legacies are thought to change or impact the host region arguably for the better. Therefore, we should consider the inner and exterior elements of the event, size of the festival, certain degree of intervention of government or private corporation, and public entities, etc. These range of the political, social, economical, physical and cultural effects comes from sports event can be negative as well as positive.
This paper reviews the literature on the features of such events and, drawing particular examples from recent Olympic Games which was held over the world cities, it identifies the nature and extent of their impacts on the host country and community. This work analysed many kinds of effect on the society that stemming from the sports and especially legal side of the effects were narrowly examined. Furthermore, my arguments are focused on the reviewing both positive and negative point of view of the impacts of the mega sports events.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

대규모 스포츠 행사로서 올림픽은 경제, 문화, 법, 정치 등의 영역에서 다양한 특징들을 내포하고 있기 때문에 본고에서는 올림픽 경기를 하나의 전형적이고 단순한 대규모 체육행사로서만 취급되어서는 안 된다는 것을 분석을 통하여 제시하고자 한다. 올림픽 경기들은 올림픽주의라고 하는철학으로부터 최고의 이념이나 가치가 도출된다. 국제올림픽위원회가 정한 엄격한 틀 내에서 경기가 조직되고 올림픽주의라는 정신이 그 성장과 발전에 원동력으로서 영향을 미친다.
대규모 스포츠 행사의 유치는 다양한 혜택을 가져오게 되고 이것은 본질적으로 도시나 지역개발을 위한 정부의 주도권에서부터 사경제 영역의 이익을 얻기 위한 주도권에 이르기까지 다양한범위에 걸친 이해관계와 관련되어 있다. 그 결과 조직위원회는 갈등이 배제된 다양한 이해관계를다루어야 하는 바 이것은 그들이 아주 복잡한 업무를 수행해야 함을 의미한다. 대규모 스포츠 행사를 개념 정의함에 있어서 우리는 이 행사에 미치는 영향의 정도를 추가할 필요가 있고 내부적인결정인자들은 조직적인 측면에 있어서 복잡성뿐만 아니라 그 행사의 규모와 기간도 포함하고 정부와 사기업, 그리고 공공단체와 같은 다양한 단체의 개입정도도 고려해야만 한다.
대규모 스포츠 행사가 그와 같은 순기능을 실제로 발휘하는지 여부에 대해서는 여러 학자들에의해서 논쟁이 제기되었다. 대규모 스포츠 행사가 유치도시와 지역에 미치는 영향은 그 정도가 크고 범위가 다양하며, 이와 같은 행사는 어느 국가이든지 긍정적인 결과를 야기할 수 있다는 생각이 여러 문헌들에 의해서 지지를 받고 있다. 본고에서는 대형 스포츠 행사가 우리사회에 미치는다양한 영향에 대해서 논의하는데 특히 법규범에 미치는 변화를 살펴보았다. 나아가 스포츠 행사가 미치는 영향의 긍정적인 측면에 대한 반론에 대해서도 초점을 맞추어 고찰하였다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김종호, "올림픽 헌장의 법적 기초와 구체적 규범성에 관한 연구" 한국스포츠엔터테인먼트법학회 17 (17): 71-106, 2014

2 한희원, "올림픽 운동과 올림픽 시스템에 대한 규범적 고찰 - 스포츠의 국제적 법체계 -" 중앙법학회 12 (12): 293-332, 2010

3 정희준, "스포츠메가이벤트와 경제효과:그 진실과 허구의 재구성" 한국스포츠사회학회 21 (21): 229-251, 2008

4 박경열, "스포츠 메가이벤트의 경제성 분석에 관한 연구 : 2020 부산 하계올림픽 개최의 비용편익 분석을 중심으로" 20 (20): 163-187, 2008

5 박영옥, "국제스포츠 이벤트의 사회경제적 효과와 평가방법" 2009

6 Hellenic Tourism Board, "Tourists' arrivals in Greece" Hellenic Tourism Board 2004

7 Morphet J, "The real thing" 65 (65): 312-314, 1996

8 Theodoraki E, "The making of the UK Sports Institute" 4 (4): 187-200, 1999

9 Sola F. E, "The impact of mega-events" 25 (25): 241-245, 1998

10 Ritchie J. R, "The impact of a mega-event on host awareness : a longitudinal study" 30 (30): 3-10, 1991

11 Beaty A, "The homeless Olympics? in Homelessness : the Unfinished Agenda" University of Sydney 1999

12 Mossberg L, "The event market" 24 (24): 748-751, 1997

13 Hall C. M, "The effects of hallmark events on cities" 26 (26): 44-45, 1987

14 Manchester 2002, "The city will rise to the challenge" Electronic publication

15 Nash R, "The case of Euro 96 : where did the party go?" 2-4, 1998

16 Schimmel K. S, "The Stadium and the City" Keele University Press 1995

17 Toohey K, "The Olympic Games : A Social Science Perspective" CABI Publishing 2000

18 De Moragas M, "The Keys to Success, Centre d’Estudis Olimpics i de l’Esport" Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona 1995

19 Miguelez F, "The Keys to Success" Centre d'Estudis Olimpics i de l’Esport, Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona 1995

20 De Guevara L. M, "The Keys to Success" Univ. of Barcelona 1995

21 Jennings A, "The Great Olympic Swindle : When the World Wanted its Games Back" Simon and Schuster 2000

22 Whitson D, "The Global Circus : International Sport, Tourism, and the Marketing of Cities" 23 (23): 278-295, 1996

23 Lucas J. A, "The Future of the Olympic Games" Human Kinetics 1992

24 De Moragas M, "Television, sport and the Olympic Movement" 26 (26): 77-82, 1996

25 Athens 2004, "Television Rights and the Athens Games" June Press Release 2004

26 Pyo S, "Summer Olympic tourism market : learning from the past" 9 (9): 137-144, 1988

27 Horin A, "State of despair haunts a score of western suburbs" Sydney Morning Herald 1999

28 Dunn M. K, "Staging the Olympics : The Event and its Impacts" Centre for Olympic Studies 1999

29 Hall C. M, "Sport, Culture and Identity" Meyer and Meyer Verlag 1998

30 Peter Taylor, "Sport and the City : the Role of Sport in Economic and Social Generation" Routledge 214-, 2001

31 Hooper I, "Sport and the City : the Role of Sport in Economic and Social Generation" Routledge 219-, 2001

32 Ingerson L, "Sport and the City : the Role of Sport in Economic and Social Generation" Routledge 2001

33 Jill Haynes, "Socio-economic impact of the Sydney 2000 Olympic Games"

34 London 2012, "Short listing of candidate cities" February Press Release 2012

35 De Knop P, "Ready for action" 19 (19): 18-20, 1999

36 Christodoulakis A. G, "Procedures-express for the creation of new companies"

37 Preuss H, "Problemizing the Arguments of the Opponents of Olympic Games" Johannes Gutenberg-University Mainz 1998

38 Mechicof B, "Olympism : the humanitarian philosophy of the new millennium" 2000

39 Hughes H, "Olympic tourism and urban regeneration" 1 (1): 157-162, 1993

40 Stevens T, "Olympic legacy" 19 (19): 16-19, 1999

41 Hill C, "Olympic Politics" Manchester Univ. Press 1992

42 Essex S, "Olympic Games-catalyst of urban change" 17 (17): 187-206, 1998

43 Burbank M, "Olympic Dreams : the Impact of Mega-events on Local Politics" Lynne Rienner Publishers 2001

44 Hiller H. H, "Mega-events, urban boosterism, and growth strategies : an analysis of the objectives and legitimations of the Cape Town 2004 Olympic bid" 24 (24): 439-458, 2000

45 Rochie Maurice, "Mega-events, culture and modernity : expos and the origin of public culture" 5 (5): 1-31, 1999

46 Rochie Maurice, "Mega-events and urban policy" 21 (21): 1-19, 1994

47 Rochie Maurice, "Mega-Events and Modernity : Olympics and Expos in the Growth of Global Culture" Routledge 2000

48 International Olympic Committee, "Marketing Revenue : Facts and Figures of the International Olympic Committee" IOC

49 Cochrane A, "Manchester plays games : exploring the local politics of globalisation" 33 (33): 1319-1336, 1996

50 Graham S, "Managing Cities : The New Urban Context" Wiley, London 169-189, 1995

51 Kang S, "Long-term impact of a mega-event on international tourism to the host country : a conceptual model and the case of the 1988 Seoul Olympics" 6 (6): 205-225, 1994

52 Helen Jefferson Lenskyj, "Inside the Olympic Industry : Power, Politics and Activism" 26 (26): 685-688, 2001

53 Ferrnce Weicker & Co, "Impact of 2010 Olympic Winter Games and Paralympic Games on Vancouver’s Inner City Neighbourhoods" Ference Weicker & Co 2002

54 International Olympic Committee, "IOC Olympic Charter"

55 International Olympic Committee, "IOC Annual Report" IOC 2001

56 International Olympic Committee, "IOC Annual Report" IOC 2003

57 Chaudhary V, "Golden goals" Guardian 23-, 1999

58 Dobson N, "Football came home" 17 (17): 16-19, 1997

59 Getz D, "Event management and event tourism" 25 (25): 248-249, 1998

60 Preuss H, "Economics of the Olympic Games : Hosting the Games 1972-2000" Walla Walla Press 2000

61 Crompton J, "Economic analysis of sport facilities and events : eleven sources of misapplication" 9 (9): 14-35, 1995

62 Eitzen D. S, "Classism in sport : the powerless bear the burden" 20 (20): 95-105, 1996

63 Mberi N, "Civil war at Marathonas" Eleftherotypia 17-, 2001

64 Kitchen T, "Cities and the ‘world events’ process" 65 (65): 314-317, 1996

65 Truno E, "Centre d’Estudis Olimpics i de l'Esport" Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona 1995

66 Brunet F, "Centre d’Estudis Olimpics de l’Esport" Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona 1995

67 Horin A, "Budget hotels baulk at rooms for homeless during Games" Sydney Morning Herald 1998

68 Cramer J, "Brave start" 17 (17): 20-23, 1997

69 Preuss H, "Blickpunkt Olympia : Entdeckungen, Erkentnisse, Impulse" Agon Sportverlag 322-336,

70 Tzelis K, "Athens 2004 : Timetable for the Works" Imerisia 6-, 2001

71 Ritchie J. R, "Assessing the impact of hallmark events : conceptual and research issues" 23 (23): 2-11, 1984

72 Ntaliani D, "Arrest of 17th November members" Ta Nea 2003

73 Lawson T, "After it s all over" 68 (68): 20-24, 1996

74 김철수, "2015 광주 하계 유니버시아드에 대한 단상, 기고"