1. Introduction
This study is to examine alternatives to enhance the service quality (or higher satisfaction of customers to tourist hotel fitness center. Traditional studies have much focussed on alternatives for higher service quality of tourist ho...
1. Introduction
This study is to examine alternatives to enhance the service quality (or higher satisfaction of customers to tourist hotel fitness center. Traditional studies have much focussed on alternatives for higher service quality of tourist hotels. However, this study has focussed on alternatives to enhance the service quality of the fitness center of a hotel.
Specifically speaking, the relationships of importance and satisfaction levels of the fitness center service factor attributes to the service qualities were explored and alternatives were proposed to enhance the service quality in the hotel fitness center. The conceptual framework of the study is conceived as follows:
◁그림 삽입▷(원문을 참조하세요)
(Figure 1) Conceptual Framework for this Study
Nine hypotheses developed reflecting the relationships of the above variable contexts in the framework are as follows:
H_(1): The service quality level that the male customers conceive using the tourist hotel fitness center will be significantly related to that of female customers.
H_(2): The service quality levels by age that the customers conceive using the tourist hotel fitness center will show a significant difference.
H_(3): The service quality levels by occupation that the customers conceive using the tourist hotel fitness center will show a significant difference.
H_(4): The service quality levels by income that the customers evaluate using the tourist hotel fitness center will show a significant difference.
H_(5): The service quality levels that the customers conceive using the tourist hotel fitness center will show a significant difference by their use pattern.
H_(6): The service importance level that the customers of the tourist hotel fitness center conceive will be significantly related to the service satisfaction level that the customers conceive in terms of the facilities items/operation specialty factor.
H_(7): The service importance level that the customers of the tourist hotel fitness center conceive will be significantly related to the service satisfaction level that the customers conceive in terms of the facility convenience factor.
H_(8): The service importance level that the customers of the tourist hotel fitness center conceive will be significantly related to the service satisfaction level that the customers evaluate in terms of the employee service quality factors.
H_(9): The service factor importance level that the customers evaluate will be significantly related to the service satisfaction level that the customers evaluate in terms of the relative contribution level to the service quality of the fitness center.
2. Methodologies
The original questionnaire items of the study were composed of 23 items. However, following the exploratory factor analyses and reliability test, the number of final questionnaires was set to 20 items for the empirical survey.
The study collected 321 samples from the hotel guests who used the fitness center and refined them to 305 usable and reliable ones.
For the empirical analyses, a Questionnaire survey was carried out against customers to hotels in Gyeongju offering fitness service.
All data gathered was encoded and processed statistically using a SPSS WIN 10.0 package using Likert 5-point scale. To test the hypotheses, this study employed the analysis tools including Frequency analysis, T-test, F-test, ANOVA, Duncan, IPA, and Regression analysis as well as confirmatory factor analysis and reliability test(Cronbach's-a) for pilot test.
3. Findings
Findings of the study are summarized as follows:
1) Hypotheses test for the service rluality difference by demographic variables
(1) The average values of male and female fitness customers were shown to be 3.7897 and 3.9025 respectively with t-value=-2.829(p=.005), and it has proved that the two values are significantly different in terms of sample distribution. The H2, therefore, was confirmed to be true. This analysis cites that the female customers need to be more sport-lighted than males in managing the hotel fitness target markets in terms of analyzing the female use patterns of the fitness facilities.
(2) In the analysis of service quality perception by age on a five point Likert scale the F-value was calculated to be 1.747 with p=.124. This statistics show that the average values of the service quality perception have no significant statistical difference among the five age groups. Therefore, the H_(2) was proved to be false. Elaborated in the data, while the average value 3.6067 of the service quality evaluated by the 20 years or less class customer is relatively lower than the average values of the other age belt customers, the average value 3.9443 of forty age belt customers is the highest. These calculations seem to assume that the interests to economy, fitness and physical health are considerably different in ages of the 20 or less and the 40's.
(3) The average value difference analysis of the customer service quality by occupation has revealed that the average values by occupation are significantly different each another with the F-value=2.847(p= .007). The H3, therefore, was found to be true. Elaborately reviewed, the higher average values 3.9856 and 3.9119 by private businessman and housewife than by other groups imply that the two groups deserve to be more Interested in terms of segmenting the markets.
(4) Drawn on ANOVA was the F-value 4.707 with p=.000 of the service quality perception by income of the customers and the H_(4) was examined to be true. This outcome tells that the customers with monthly income 5 million or more in Korean currency have more positive[higher] perception(4.1949) than the others in evaluating the service quality of the fitness center on a Likert 5 point scale.
(5) Finally, according to the analysis of the average value difference by fitness use pattern, the average value of membership was found to be significantly related to that of non-membership with the t-value 3.575(p=.000) and the H_(5) was revealed to be true. This outcome is, hopefully, recommended to deserve a major item in terms of the segmented market as well.
2) Tests of hypotheses on relationships of importance and satisfaction
(1) The average value of importance 4.0408 was known to be higher than the value satisfaction 3.4732 of the first factor including facility items/operation specialty factor attributes with t-value 17.415(p=.000). Therefore, the H_(6) was proved to be true. Reviewed in detail, the higher value(4.0408) In the importance than that(3.4732) in the satisfaction in this first factor cites that the facility items/operation specialty are in need to improve to meet the needs of the customers.
(2) 4.3107, the average value of the importance, was found to be higher than the value satisfaction 3.4902 of the second factor including facility use convenience factor attributes with t-value 9.970(p=.000) and the H_(7) was examined to be true. Elaborated in detail, the higher value(4.3107) in the importance than that(3.4902) in the satisfaction in the second factor implies that the facility use convenience factor items have are hoped to improve to meet needs of the customers.
(3) Shown to be higher than the value(3.8628) of the satisfaction was 4.1864, the importance average of the third factor, including employee service level factor attributes with t-value 19.645(p=.000), Therefore, the H_(8) was examined to be true. As same in the examination of the hypotheses 6 and 7, the higher value(4.1864) in the importance than that(3.8628) in the satisfaction in this third factor cites that the employee service factor items are in need as well for improvement to meet needs of the customers.
3. Examinations of hypotheses on the importance and satisfaction of the service quality factors to the attractiveness of the hotel fitness center
With the regression equation including the three independent factors to the attractiveness of the hotel fitness center, the first independent factor including facility items/operation specialty was proved to have a positive and significant impact to the attractiveness of the hotel fitness center with the βeta value = .415(t=6.634, p=.000). The importance of the second factor attributes including the 'employee service quality' was found to have also a positive and significant impact to the attractiveness of the hotel fitness center with the βeta value= .304 (t=5.217 , p=.000). Finally, with the βeta value= .121(t=2.574, p= .001), the importance of the third factor attributes including the 'employee service quality' was found to have a positive and significant impact as well to the attractiveness of the hotel fitness center. Totally, the importance level of the three independent variables explained the regression model with F= 130.417(R^(2)=.565, p=.000) to be positively influential to the attractiveness of the service quality of the tourist hotel fitness center. Therefore, the H_(9) was examined to be true.
4. Implications
Examining the hypotheses established, the study suggests some implications as follows:
First, in terms of the average values by demographic variables such as gender, income and fitness use pattern were evaluated to be significantly different. In particular, as the female average value showing to be significantly higher than that of males respondents, the housewife customers need to be more interested sources in managing the hotel fitness target markets.
Second, in the analyses of importance and the satisfaction impacts of the three factors to the service quality in the regression model the satisfaction variable was explored to be more influential to the service quality. This outcome implies that the satisfaction of facility use needs to be more highlighted by the hotel strategic management team in terms of managing the fitness center. More specifically speaking, the enhancement of the customer satisfaction level has to be a primary task to attract more customers to the center.
Third, the practitioners are encouraged to consider the importance of examining priority of factors giving impacts to the attractiveness of the fitness center. The facility items/operation specialty factor was found to be most influential and the employee service factor to be the second most and finally, the facility convenience to be the third largest influential to the attractiveness of the fitness center. Based on the above analyses, a variety of fitness facilities and more reasonable operation of the center need to be treated as major sources to enhance the level of the customer satisfaction.
Fourth, the big gap between importance-satisfaction levels on facility convenience factor was found to be a major source that brings a significant relationships of the two sources to the service quality. In other words, the βeta value of facility convenience factor importance to the service quality was calculated to be .121 with p=.001 in the regression equation while the βeta of the satisfaction of the same factor to the dependent was found to be .179 with p=.000 in the regression equation. This data notes that some alternatives need to be developed to enhance the service quality using the factor satisfaction attributes as the factor satisfaction item is more important for higher service quality.
5. The Study Limitations and Suggestions for Future Study
Despite of above study outcomes, this study have some limitations and the subsequent studies over the topic are hoped to bring more elaborative perspectives as follows:
First, the sampling of this study was limited to some hotels in Gyeongju, Gyeongsangbuk-do, Korea. Hopefully, the subsequent study will secure balanced sampling over more hotels and to broader areas to generalize the discussion and implications of the analysis outcomes.
Second, this study has primarily focussed on investigating the relationships of three service quality factors (including facility operation specialty, employee service level and facility convenience) to the demographic factors (including gender, age, occupation, monthly income and the use pattern). The subsequent studies need to explore the relationships by province, hotel location(type) and price belt, etc. In addition, a variety of analyses need to be employed to bring more implicative practical outcomes for higher productivity in the hotel fitness center business. Hopefully, the research outcomes of the study will be of assistance to the practitioners concerned.