The present society provides us with convenient life by the science and technology development, and rapid industrialization and urbanization. Along with these positive aspects, however, several side effects came up such as serious emotional absence phenomenon, which aggravates sense of alienation, emotional conflict, and impersonalization.
In particular, emotional absence phenomenon affects teenagers more seriously that it causes grave juvenile problems such as frustration and chaos of sense of value. Desirable leisure activities are necessary in order to solve today's teenager problems. Sound leisure activities during youth age provide opportunity to establish the sense of value by finding self-consciousness and identity, provide opportunity to cultivate emotion by satisfying various cultural desires, and help enhance human relations, overcome sense of alienation, and release frustration.
Yet, it is a matter of fact that our social reality fails to provide our youth with sufficient program and space in which leisure time can be spent in a various and desirable way. The existing spaces and facilities for youth leisure are far from satisfying rapidly changing teenager leisure behaviors and desire.
In order to gather basic data for the plan, design, and improvement of juvenile leisure space as well as to contribute to the preparation of various youth leisure spaces in consideration of rapidly changing leisure patterns in youth activities, this study examines and analyzes leisure space planning factors. It uses sufficient amount questionnaires and a physical environment analysis at downtown parks and in the Tongdaemun fashion complexes, in which various teenager leisure activities are conducted. In addition, importance and performance analysis was conducted on planning factors of each derived leisure space.
Analysis results of this study can be summarized as follows.
Ⅰ. Planning elements for Space Ⅰ(Space for dancing)
1. accessibility (4.08, 2.34)
2. consideration for natural conditions(sunshine, wind, etc.) (2.66, 2.12)
3. dividing each space properly (2.32, 3.82)
4. designing a stage to gather eyes from seats (2.30, 4.18)
5. providing maximum open spaces (3.76, 2.84)
6. designing seats which is concerned a view from a stage (2.70, 3.77)
7. providing a natural lighting and draft (3.23, 2.37)
8. designing a stage to be opened to all sides except a backside
(4.00, 2.85)
9. separation for the stage and seats (3.00, 3.46)
10. providing a flow planning for audiences (2.18, 2.26)
11. providing a easy flow planning (2.09, 2.28)
12. providing the space for a stage (2.77, 4.35)
13. providing open spaces in seats (3.85, 2.83)
14. providing vertical elements in the backside of the stage (2.81, 4.02)
15. providing temporary roof for raining (1.73, 4.27)
16. providing lighting for night (1.49, 4.50)
17. providing psychological boundaries between a stage and seats
(2.99, 2.76)
18. using minimum structures in the space (3.66, 2.74)
19. using flat and soft materials for paving (1.75, 4.37)
20. using rubber and resins for stage paving (1.33, 4.41)
21. no planting (4.07, 2.01)
Ⅱ. Planning elements for Space Ⅱ(Space for performance)
1. accessibility (3.23, 3.01)
2. consideration for natural conditions(sunshine, wind, etc.) (1.91, 1.93)
3. dividing each space properly (3.93, 3.09)
4. providing maximum open spaces (2.80, 2.43)
5. providing a natural draft (3.72, 1.96)
6. separation for the stage and seats (3.96, 3.26)
7. providing a surrounded space (2.85, 4.64)
8. providing a circulation flow planning (2.66, 1.87)
9. providing the space for a stage (3.70, 4.66)
10. providing vertical elements in the backside of the stage (2.18, 4.01)
11. providing temporary roof for raining (1.39, 4.34)
12. providing lighting for night (1.43, 4.38)
13. providing electric facilities for using equipments (1.47, 4.59)
14. providing structures as seats (3.04, 2.90)
15. providing open space between a stage and seats (3.16, 2.60)
16. using flat and hard materials for paving (4.00, 2.82)
17. providing hard materials for a stage (4.32, 2.61)
18. providing soundproof planting around seats (2.53, 3.06)
Ⅲ. Planning elements for Space Ⅲ
(Space for roller-skate and inline-skate)
1. accessibility (3.34, 4.04)
2. consideration for natural conditions(topography) (2.90, 2.88)
3. providing maximum open spaces (2.30, 4.45)
4. providing a natural lighting and draft (2.74, 2.11)
5. designing a space as a opened form (3.90, 4.50)
6. providing a space with various topographies (1.80, 3.53)
7. providing a circulation flow planning (3.60, 2.84)
8. providing wide open spaces (2.40, 4.68)
9. providing a little sloped spaces (1.47, 2.96)
10. providing bollards for resting and putting skate on (1.69, 3.67)
11. providing structures as obstacles (1.54, 2.54)
12. providing structures to perform a feat (1.27, 3.88)
13. providing convenient facilities (2.86, 2.83)
14. using flat and soft materials for paving (3.14, 2.92)
15. using resins for floor paving materials (1.48, 2.93)
16. providing paving materials for safety (1.62, 2.72)
17. planting for a resting space (2.19, 2.49)
Ⅳ. Planning elements for Space Ⅳ (Space for meeting and chatting)
1. selecting site for screening (3.12, 3.12)
2. selecting site for silence (2.44, 3.59)
3. designing buffer zones between spaces for meeting (2.27, 3.16)
4. separation between spaces (1.76, 4.12)
5. providing a natural lighting and draft (3.33, 1.93)
6. providing a surrounded space (2.22, 4.62)
7. providing a sunken space (1.45, 3.89)
8. providing a flow planning for considering privacy of each space
(1.69, 4.48)
9. providing small spaces for meeting (1.66, 4.57)
10. providing buffer zones between spaces (1.90, 3.93)
11. providing resting facilities in each space (3.80, 3.57)
12. providing convenient facilities (3.03, 2.43)
13. using soft paving materials (2.33, 2.32)
14. planting for screening around spaces (2.19, 3.47)
15. planting in each space (1.88, 2.14)
Planning factors of each leisure space were derived through a preliminary research, and importance-performance analysis was conducted on such planning factors. Through the performance analysis, we examined how many factors for space planning have been applied for today's youth leisure spaces. Through the importance analysis, priority and necessity of planning factors to be considered at early stage of planning and design of juvenile leisure space were examined. Researched planning factors of each leisure space and the mean values of importance and performance are as follows.
Through performance and importance analysis of planning factors, we found that planning factors were well applied and considered at present juvenile leisure spaces when performance was high. When importance was high, we also found that importance is a planning factor to be considered preferentially at the planning of juvenile leisure space by each leisure pattern.
By integrating the relation of importance and performance, matters to be considered and applied for the leisure space improvement were analyzed by four steps of prior correction, continuous effort, low priority order and avoidance of over-effort. Planning factors to be corrected preferentially with high gravity at the improvement of teenager leisure space were planning factors of 3, 4, 6, 12, 15, 16, and 20 including introduction of stage space, simple frame roof, and lighting facility at leisure space I, and planning factors of 7, 10, 11, 12, and 13 of leisure space II, and 3, 6, 10, and 12 of leisure space III, and 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, and 14 of leisure space IV.
Planning factors to be maintained as a present condition by continuous efforts are 9 and 14 of leisure space I, 6 and 9 of leisure space II, 1, 5, and 8 of leisure space III, and 2 and 11 of leisure space IV. Planning factors of low priority order are 2, 4, 8, and 18 of leisure space I, 7, 10, 11, 12, and 13 of leisure space II, 5, 9, 11, 16, and 17 of leisure space III, and 3, 13, and 15 of leisure space IV. Planning factors to be avoided over-efforts are 5, 7, 8, 11, 13, 17, 18, and 21 of leisure space I, 1, 3, 5, 14, 15, 16, and 17 of leisure space II, 2, 4, 7, 13, and 14 of leisure space III, and 1, 5, and 12 of leisure space IV.
With the analysis result, it was found that planning factors to be corrected preferentially at present teenager leisure spaces consisted of most planning factors of facility part. This seems the deficiency of facilities resulted from failure of existing youth leisure spaces to adapt to rapidly changing teenager leisure patterns. In addition, planning factors in need of continuous efforts are befitting factors for feature of each leisure activity. Thus, characteristics of leisure pattern have critical influence on the planning and preparation and improvement of teenager leisure space of each leisure pattern.
As a result, effective and efficient preparation of youth leisure space for desirable leisure life of the youth should be carried out after finding out characteristics of teenager leisure spaces, deriving and integrating suitable planning factors for each characteristics, and finally adapting such derived planning factors by performance and importance. The future space for youth leisure should be improved and prepared after conducting logical consideration of importance and performance of planning factors, which are suited for leisure pattern and characteristics of teenager leisure spaces.