English education in elementary school is designed to accomplish communicative competence. Communicative competence is able to be improved by integrated use of four language skills. In reality, spoken language has been emphasized too much. In contras...
English education in elementary school is designed to accomplish communicative competence. Communicative competence is able to be improved by integrated use of four language skills. In reality, spoken language has been emphasized too much. In contrast, written language has been neglected and given the least time. As a result, students have a hard time writing English in middle school which has no connection with English writing in elementary school.
The purpose of this study was to compare guided writing with controlled writing regarding Korean elementary students' English ability and find out the effects of English writing and affective aspects through guided writing and controlled writing. For this study, an experiment was conducted for 8 weeks with 40 students of two classes in the fifth grade. One class was supposed to do fill-in the blank activity where students put a word in the blank to complete the sentence. This was the type of controlled writing. The other class was provided with a picture-guided writing activity where students made sentences with reference to the pictures. Both writing activities were conducted 4 times and there were four tests based on the same topic during the experiment. They were a pre-test, middle- test 1, 2, and a post-test. The scoring rubric was made for writing assessment and consisted of content, grammar and mechanics which were suitable for the English writing achievement standard in elementary school.
The main results of this experimental study are as follows:
First, both classes showed an improvement in their writing ability after 8 weeks' experiments. However, there were significant differences between guided writing and controlled writing when it comes to the improvement of their English writing ability. The guided writing class had an improvement in content and grammar. The controlled writing class showed an improvement in content and the spelling aspect in the writing test. Both classes improved in the same content aspect. This indicates that both writing activities had a positive effect on content in free writing.
Secondly, there were significant differences between guided writing and controlled writing in terms of their writing ability. Guided writing was more effective than controlled writing in improving students’ writing in content and grammar aspects of writing. However, in the spelling of mechanics aspect of free writing, controlled writing was more effective than guided writing. Advantages of picture- guided writing were that pictures made students interested in the writing continuously and students were motivated to make more sentences besides the sentences related to the pictures. Guided writing was highly effective in the content and grammar aspects in the writing test. In contrast, controlled writing was more effective in spelling than guided writing because the fill-in the blank activity tends to cause words to be accurately completed in the blank. From these content and grammar aspects, this indicates continuous practice of sentences written in guided writing, were able to improve students' writing skills more than the practice of writing accurate words in controlled writing.
Finally, two classes showed an improvement in affective aspects regardless of the kinds of writing. As a result of the questionnaires, it was found that both classes gained interest, a better attitude and confidence toward English writing. Students in both classes perceived that their English writing ability improved after 8 weeks' experiments. This means that continuous writing practice helps students to be motivated to learn writing skills. It seemed to work for both a guided writing class and controlled writing class.
As shown from these results of the study, guided writing and controlled writing can have positive effects on writing ability and affective aspects. These writing practices helped students become motivated and enjoy writing, which they felt uninteresting and difficult before the experiment. This study, as such, is hoped to provide L2 learners and teachers in elementary schools with valuable information to write effectively and systematically.