The citizen participatory budgeting system(hereinafter "PB") is a kind of decision-making process that local residents directly take part in local budget allocation process. Before PB was introduced, the right of budget allocation only belonged to loc...
The citizen participatory budgeting system(hereinafter "PB") is a kind of decision-making process that local residents directly take part in local budget allocation process. Before PB was introduced, the right of budget allocation only belonged to local government head and local council. As a result, it was difficult for the citizens to state their views about local budget and public policies.
PB contributes to financial democracy by giving residents the authorities in local budget allocation process. Also, by implementing PB, local municipalities make efforts to manage and operate their budget in a more transparent, responsible and responsive manner. Consequently, it is highly probable that the transparency, responsibility and efficiency in local finance will be improved when compared to previous years.
PB first emerged in the city of Porto Alegre, Brazil. Buk-Gu, Gwangju is the first city to implement PB in Korea in 2003. As of September 2010, 91 local municipal governments have established ordinances about operating PB.
The ordinances on PB can be divided into three types depending on their contexts. ①First type is the ordinance which follows the standard ordinance made by Ministry of Government Administration and Home Affairs without modification. ②The second type is the ordinance having provision about operating citizen participatory budget committee. And ③the third type is the ordinance that has detailed process and organization such as regional meeting, subcommittee, private-public meeting, school of budget, workshop and so on.
Meanwhile, local municipalities have had lax management by increasing function·festival costs and private transfer expenses. This study analyzes whether PB effects the local governments' function·festival costs and private transfer budget cuts. Moreover, it focuses on whether the different types of ordinances elicit different effects. The method of analysis is regression analysis with the cross-sectional data of fiscal year 2011.
The result was statistically significant in that the proportion of the function·festival costs reduced when PB existed. However, PB didn't have significant effect on reducing private transfer expenses. Also, no different effects occurred according to different ordinance types.
However, it is difficult to determine that PB has no effect in reducing the budget waste only with these results. For example, the PB in Buk-Gu, Gwangju, had effect on reducing budget waste. It is necessary that this research to be supplemented by further qualitative analysis.
PB can be perfunctory and symbolic system depending on how local governments operate it. This study verified that PB has significant effect on function·festival cost budget, so it is not merely perfunctory. In addition, PB is one of the most important measures to achieve financial democracy. Therefore local government, council and citizens should implement PB maturely in their region. It is important to create and foster cultures that induce more residents to participate and get involved in budgeting process.