The purpose of this study is to investigate the influence of interactional justice, trust within organization, reflective learning on work behaviors of HRD practitioners in the workplace. This study is examined by analyzing the relationship among inte...
The purpose of this study is to investigate the influence of interactional justice, trust within organization, reflective learning on work behaviors of HRD practitioners in the workplace. This study is examined by analyzing the relationship among interactional justice, trust within organization, reflective learning, and work behaviors while focusing on the mediating role of reflective learning.
The subjects of this study are HRD practitioners and lifelong educators working at the education department in organizations. Non-probability sampling as well as snowball sampling techniques are used to select the sample. The survey is administrated by sending an email directly. The online survey measures participants’ perceptions on interactional justice, supervisor trust, co-worker trust, organizational trust, reflective learning, and work behaviors. 248 subjects have sent survey responses, but only 231 responses are used in the final analysis due to 17 insufficient response.
The findings of this study are as follows:
First, the result indicates that only reflective learning, interactional justice, and co-worker trust have a positive effect on all work behaviors, by analyzing whether there’s a positive effect on work behaviors among interactional justice, trust within organization (supervisor trust, co-worker trust, organizational trust), and reflective learning. According to the analysis of effects by four sub-work behaviors such as career awareness, asking for feedback, critical opinion-sharing, and experimentation, reflective learning and organizational trust have a positive effect on career awareness behaviors. Work behavior of asking for feedback has a positive effect on interactional justice, reflective learning, and co-worker trust. Also, critical opinion-sharing behavior has a positive effect on interactional justice and reflective learning. In addition, experimentation behavior has a positive effect on reflective learning and organizational trust.
Second, the result indicates that reflective learning has a mediation effect between interactional justice and all work behaviors, trust within organization (supervisor trust, co-worker trust, organizational trust) and all work behaviors. In addition, reflective learning has a mediation effect on the relationship between interactional justice and four sub-work behaviors (career awareness, asking for feedback, critical opinion-sharing, and experimentation), and between trust within organization and sub-work behaviors. Meanwhile, three sub variables of reflective learning (habitual action, reflection, critical reflection) also have a mediation effect on the relationship between interactional justice and sub-work behaviors, but not on the relationship between interactional justice and asking for feedback. As for the analysis of mediation effect on the relationship between trust within organization and sub-work behaviors, the result indicates that habitual action has a mediation effect on the relationship between trust within organization and sub-work behaviors, but not on the relationship between supervisor trust and sub-work behaviors, between organizational trust and the behaviors, and between co-worker trust and asking for feedback. Reflection and critical reflection also have a mediation effect on the relationship between trust within organization and sub-work behaviors.
Based on these findings, following conclusions are reached:
First, in order to improve the employee’s task performance and contribution to organizational innovation, reflective learning should occur during the course of daily working routines.
Second, to evaluate the level of employee’s reflection and enhance the reflection level from nonreflective learning to critical/intensive reflective learning, the strategic intervention plans that can provide effective contexts for reflective learning should be developed and implemented.
Third, the organization should make an effort to create appropriate conditions and organizational culture that supports individual development, task performance improvement, business innovation.
Fourth, further studies should consider how other variables such as individual’s willingness to improve work performance affect reflective learning.
Fifth, further studies are needed to examine the validity and reliability of the instrument used for figuring out individual’s reflective learning and work behaviors in the workplace and develop generalized instruments.