Performance management in public sector is used for the improvement of effectiveness, efficiency, adaptiveness and innovativeness of public organizations. The performance management of the government contributes to the innovation in response to three ...
Performance management in public sector is used for the improvement of effectiveness, efficiency, adaptiveness and innovativeness of public organizations. The performance management of the government contributes to the innovation in response to three environmental needs, namely, challenges from the social environment, policy issues, and the growth of civil society. Korean government is utilizing the performance management in improving the its functions by measuring the innovation performance in the public sector. To see it more concretely, the public sector introduced and is implementing following systems to improve the organizational performance: MBO (Management By Objectives), Job Incentive Payment System, Performance Budgeting System, BSC(Balanced Score Card), and Performance Management System according to the Fundamental Law on the Assessment of Government Service.
Meanwhile, most of the research works on the BSC Model and the PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act) Model that are most often used by the public sector recently are mere introduction of those systems or suggestion of future directions, while the empirical studies remain insufficient. Especially, few research works exist that link BSC perspectives to individual stages of the PDCA model. This study discusses the introduction of the private sector's BSC techniques into the public sector as the model for continuous change and innovation.
The aims of this study are as follows: first, it aims to examine the feasibility of BSC application, the needs for its introduction, and the strategies of its implementation within the public sector, and other aspects that need to be taken into consideration. Second, this study is to identify variables affecting the organizational performances throughout the BSC implementation process, also defined as the "Plan-Do-Check-Act" cycle. Third, it seeks to consider policy implications for the government to transform into a performance - centered and customer - oriented organization by successfully introducing and implementing the BSC.
For the purpose of this study, 111 copies of the questionnaire had been distributed to and answered by performance managers of around 70 public organizations implementing the BSC. Their answers were analyzed using the Statistical Package of Social Science (SPSS WIN 12.0).
This paper consists of six chapters. Chapter 1 (Introduction) describes the purpose, and methodology of the study. In Chapter 2, comparisons and analyses of the existing theoretical and empirical research, the main factors of the BSC, and the success factors are presented as a theoretical investigation. In Chapter 3, researching model and hypothesis are established, and manipulative definition of the variables and contents of the questionnaire are composed. In Chapter 4, the reliability and validity of the samples and technical statistics are analyzed, and the hypothesis is tested. In Chapter 5, the organizational performances by stage and variable of the PDCA are additionally analyzed. In the summary in Chapter 6, the policy implications to be considered, the limits of this study, and future research directions are presented.
This study analyzed the co-relations between the determinant factors as the independent variable and the organizational performances as the dependent variable. The eight independent variables are: setting up vision/strategies and developing strategic index at the "Plan" stage; executing strategic tasks and managing executive tasks at the "Do" stage monitoring and measuring performances at the "Check" stage and reviewing correction prevention and managing growth/changes at the "Act" stage.
To summarize the outcomes of this study, first, the statistical co-relation between the variables in the public sector were relatively high. Second, only part of the variables at the "Plan," "Check," and "Act," stages had impacts on the organizational performances, and the "Do" stage was found to have no impact. Third, the variables identified as having positive impact on the organizational performances were: the setting-up of vision/strategy at the "Plan" stage, the measurement and assessment of performance at the "Check" stage, and the review of correction prevention at the "Act" stage.
The summary of the policy implications of this study for the government to enhance its organizational performance continuously by successfully implementing the BSC in public sector can be presented as follows;
First, it is necessary to shape an organizational policy, and strategic environment that helps promote and maintain the BSC within an organization. Second, it can be said that the biggest difficulty in implementing the BSC in the public sector is the institutional restraints and shift of personnel in charge of BSC implementation. Third, the most plausible reasons for the failure of performance management systems in the public sector are the lack of definite and objective measurement criteria and the insufficiency of the appropriate rewards. Fourth, it can be concluded that the executive members and employees of public institutions should develop more strategic way of thinking in order to secure competitiveness of the sector.