The purpose of this study was to: (1) identify the factors that motivate or deter formal and informal workplace learning at a commercial law firm; (2) assess whether there are factor mean differences based on demographic and situational variables and...
The purpose of this study was to: (1) identify the factors that motivate or deter formal and informal workplace learning at a commercial law firm; (2) assess whether there are factor mean differences based on demographic and situational variables and; (3) assess to what extent the combination of demographic and situational variables, and the motivation and deterrent factors, explain differences in actual participation. Understanding who participates in work-related learning, and why, is of practical significance for organizations that spend billions of dollars annually on training, and who are facing an unprecedented need for employees to learn continuously.
This study used a web-based survey to collect data on demographic and situational characteristics, formal and informal work-related learning activities, and reasons that motivated or deterred learning participation. Motivator and deterrent scales were based on versions of Darkenwald and Valentine's Deterrents to Participation Scale-G (1985) and Boshier's Education Participation Scale (1971, 1991). These were modified to reflect the study setting and the fact that these scales had not previously been used to measure informal learning.
Formal and informal learning had distinct motivator and deterrent patterns indicating that these types of learning have similar but not identical motivational underpinnings, and that these scales are effective at distinguishing between them. The most important motivator factors were Skills and External Expectations. The most important deterrent factors were Time Constraints and Organizational Support. In general, females rated the motivator and deterrent factors more highly than males. Age and position also explained significant differences in factor importance. In terms of participation, there were two main clusters of employees: female staff with a Bachelor's degree or less, and male attorneys. Motivator and deterrent factors were not significant predictors of participation.
Future research should replicate the study in other settings to confirm the formal and informal factors influencing learning participation, explore how the demographic variables influence participation, and to identify the best set of variables to consistently predict participation.