미술교사의 정체성 형성에 대한 해석학적 탐구 = Hermeneutic Reflection on the Formation of Art Teachers’ Identities

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Hermeneutic inquiry into art education provides a variety of theoretical tools and interpretational strategies to employ when we interrogate why we teach art in the way that we do, and thus, for example, expose the cultural bias of art practice and understanding. This study explores three different hermeneutic approaches to teachers’ identities constructed in art education based on the three categories: conservative hermeneutics, moderate hermeneutics, and critical hermeneutics. These hermeneutic understandings have an important implication for identity formation in art education: how different identities are formed within different hermeneutic frameworks.
From the point of view of conservative hermeneutics, an interpretation reproduces precisely the meaning intended by the author/artist, and it supports the essentialist idea of identity. In moderate hermeneutics the interpreter is involved in a negotiation between the object to be interpreted and his or her contextual horizon which forms a fore-structure for meaning and sense to form. This implicates that identities are diverse and changing, in the symbolic systems through which we make sense of our own positions. Critical hermeneutics attempts to reveal systematic prejudices and biases or ideological positions that act to celebrate and include particular art practices and cultural identities, but in doing so exclude others which are equally legitimate. Therefore hermeneutic inquiry of identity formation provides an important implication to expose ideological interests and political forces embedded within institutionalized art education.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 양해림, "현대해석학 강의" 집문당 2007

2 최명선, "해석학과 교육" 교육과학사 2005

3 이상오, "교육해석학" 학지사 2008

4 Gadamer, H. G., "Truth and method" Sheed and Ward 1989

5 Habermas, J, "The structural transformation of the public sphere: inquiry into a category of bourgeois society" Blackwell Publishers Ltd 1989

6 Davey, N, "The hermeneutics of seeing, In Interpreting visual culture: explorations in the hermeneutics of the visual" Routledge 1999

7 Bourdieu, P, "The forms of capital, In Sociology of Education" RoutledgeFalmer 2004

8 Bourdieu, P, "The field of cultural production" Polity Press 1993

9 Dilthey, W, "Selected writings" Cambridge Universitiy Press 1977

10 Foster, H, "Return of the Real" MIT Press 1996

11 Bourdieu, P, "Reproduction in education, society and culture" Sage 1977

12 Hall, S, "Old and new identities, old and new ethnicities, In Culture, globalization and the world-system: Contemporary conditions for the representation of identity" the University of Minnesota Press 1997

13 Hall, S, "Introduction: who needs ‘identity’?, In Questions of cultural identity" SAGE Published Ltd 1996

14 Ball, S. J, "Introduction. In Sociology of Education" RoutledgeFalmer 2004

15 Schleiermacher, F, "Hermeneutik:Nach den Handschriften neu herausgegeben und eingeleitet von Heinz Kimmerle" Heidelber Akademie der Wissenschaft 1977

16 Ricoeur, P, "Hermeneutics and the human sciences" Cambridge Universitiy Press 1981

17 Gallagher, S, "Hermeneutics and education" State University of New York 1992

18 Palmer, R. E, "Hermeneutics - interpretation theory in Schleiermacher, Dilthey, Heidegger, and Gadamer" Northwestern Univ. Press 1975

19 Finayson, J. G, "Habermas: a very short introduction" Oxford University Press 2005

20 Ball, S. J, "Foucault and Education: Disciplines and Knowledge" Routledge 1990

21 Freire, P, "Education for critical consciousness" Sheed & Ward, Continuum International Publishing 2005

22 Hall, S, "Cultural identity and diaspora, In Identity" Lawrence & Wishart 1991

23 Thompson, J. B, "Critical hermeneutics : a study in the thought of Paul Ricoeur and Jurgen Habermas" Cambridge University Press 1983

24 Bleicher, J, "Contemporary hermeneutics: hermeneutics as method, philosophy and critique" Routledge & Kegan Paul 1980

25 Woodward, K, "Concepts of identity and difference, In Identity and difference" SAGE Publications Ltd 1997

26 Heidegger, M, "Being and Time" SCM Press Ltd 1962

27 Atkinson, D, "Art,equality and learning:pedagogies against the state" Sense Publishers 2011

28 Atkinson, D, "Art in education: identity and practice" Kluwer Academic Publishers 2002