사회사상사적 독립협회 연구의 확립과 문제점 = The Establishment and the Problems of Research on the Independence Club from the Perspective of History of Social Thoughts : Focusing on Shin Yongha, [A Study on the Independence Club]

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Shin Yongha's A Study on the Independence Club was published in 1976 and has been has held a ground breaking position in modern Korean political history research. His works accomplished researches and preposition regarding Independence Club and he has represented the research on Independent Club ever since. This remarkable book is a masterpiece that has carried an enormous amount of historical resources and a large scale.
No one has topped his work truthfully and has been a milestone in modern Korean Political history and also has been used in textbook descriptions regularly. Furthermore, the reasoning that him acceding The Independence Club which Enlightenment Faction (Ksehwepe) that he established and the popular movements resulted in Patriotic Enlightenment Movement is commonly accepted.
Although he has detailed reference quotes, he often avoids or denies references that donot match his own reasoning. Additionally, he has created his own social ideas in a phase in Independent Club and overestimated the content possessing a perfect structure that has never came up to this day. Therefore, his research has a very positive side, yet has the propensity to be ideological.
Furthermore, Shin Yongha's research does not have international affairs at the time enough in his view and has a consistent reasoning that is very narrow perspective. Korea at the time was already incorporated in the structural plan of global capitalism and this condition worsened after the Sino-Japanese War. Consequently, Independence Club Movement has been continued under secretive relationship with World Power everlasting change of the friend or enemy.
Also, since Independent Club has gone through various changes from the beginning until the end corresponding to the international affairs especially Russia's change in Korean policy, is a dynamic understanding is needed.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 『독립협회 연구』의 문제의식
• Ⅱ. 『독립협회 연구』의 내용소개
• Ⅲ. 『독립협회 연구』에 대한 논쟁
• Ⅳ. 『독립협회 연구』의 문제점
• Ⅴ. 향후 독립협회 연구의 과제
• 참고문헌
• 〈ABSTRACT〉

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 주진오, "한국근대 정치사와 왕권" 한국역사연구회 (50) : 2003

2 최덕수, "제1차 헤이그 세계평화회의(1899년)와 독립신문" 민족문화연구원 (47) : 279-308, 2007

3 신용하, "신판 독립협회연구 상, 하" 일조각 2006

4 신용하, "서평－한국근대농업사연구" 13 : 1976

5 김용섭, "서평－독립협회연구" 12 : 1976

6 주진오, "서재필－민족을 떠난 근대주의자" 13 : 2003

7 최덕수, "독립협회의 정체론 및 외교론 연구" 고려대학교 민족문화연구소 13 : 1978

8 주진오, "독립협회의 대외인식의 구조와 전개" 연세대학교 사학연구회 8 : 1987

9 주진오, "독립협회의 경제체제개혁 구상과 그 성격 in: 한국민족주의론 Ⅲ" 창작과 비평사 1985

10 신용하, "독립협회와 대한제국 in: 한국사연구입문 2" 지식산업사 1987

11 신용하, "독립협회 연구" 일조각 1976

12 강만길, "대한제국의 성격" 48 : 1978

13 교수신문, "고종황제 역사청문회" 푸른역사 2005

14 이태진, "고종시대의 재조명" 태학사 2000

15 신용하, "『 독립협회 연구』 이후 나의 민족운동연구" 91 : 1991

16 신용하, "‘광무개혁론’의 문제점" 49 : 1978

17 주진오, "19세기 후반 개화 개혁론의 구조와 전개 - 독립협회를 중심으로" 연세대학교 1995