조직시민행동과 조직성과의 관계에 대한 비판적 고찰

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Does organizational citizenship behavior(OCB) promote organizational performance without fail? Previous researchers on OCB have maintained that such behaviors may stem from other-serving (altruistic) motives, have good influences upon employees, and consequently be critical for organizational efficiency and effectiveness. By and large, prior articles published in recent decades about OCB also have pointed to the merits and advantages of voluntary or extra-role activities extended in the workplace. Therefore, contemporary literature on OCB has been primarily focusing on the functional aspects (i. e. benefit-side) of the `good soldier syndrome`. In contrast to this standpoint we suggest a different view by illuminating the latent dysfunctions (i. e. cost-side) of OCB. This paper conceptually criticizes the underlying assumptions of theory on OCB and argues that prior researches have emphasized the partial (positive) features of such behaviors while generally disregarding the potentially negative connotations of them. By so doing, it is proposed here that OCB may not promote or even demote organizational performance if the benefits fail to outweigh the costs. Three overlooked presumptions that alternative causes and effects of OCB may exist in organization are as follows. First, OCB may originate from self-serving motives. Employees who engage in OCB might help coworkers, stay late, and so on, to enhance their rewards and/or self-images rather than only to support the organization itself. Second, OCB may bring about undesirable outcomes for individual workers. Employees who perform considerable OCB might experience role-overload and role-ambiguity, be susceptible to the conflict with their supervisor or resentment among peers, be left with less time to devote to their own tasks or personal lives, and so forth. Third, OCB may not or even negatively influence the major objective indexes of organizational performance as evidenced by few empirical studies. Organizations of which performance appraisal systems are inappropriate, formal functions are substituted (or hindered) by OCB or impression management, and OCBs are abused by employees and/or middle managers may have further difficulties in trying to improve their performances through OCB against all expectations. After giving due considerations to the practical and conceptual issues (e. g. OCB quality, reverse causality of OCB-performance, so-called group think phenomenon, level of analysis of performance, additional debates on behavioral motives, and the like) in the sphere of OCB research, we discussed a number of theoretical and managerial implications of this complementary viewpoint along with some significant agendas for future research in depth as well.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박종혁, "팀제 하에서 성과주의 보상시스템의 동기유발 효과: 과업특성의 조절효과를 중심으로" 30 (30): 87-119, 2006

2 김경석, "조직시민행동의 하위차원에 대한 고찰: 연역적 분류 틀의 정립을 위한 탐색적 연구" 30 (30): 149-175, 2006

3 김경석, "조직시민행동의 부정적 효과에 대한 연구: 소진의 매개역할을 중심으로" 30 (30): 91-120, 2006

4 문형구, "조직시민행동(OCB) 연구에 대한 비판적 고찰: 한국에서의 연구를 중심으로" 35 (35): 609-643, 2006

5 장용선, "조직문화 연구의 동향과 과제" 16 (16): 65-114, 2008

6 서재현, "조직공정성이 조직후원인식에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구: 상사에 대한 신뢰의 매개역할을 중심으로" 29 (29): 451-472, 2000

7 박상언, "성과주의 인사제도 운용의 딜레마: 후지츠사 사례의 교훈" 15 (15): 135-174, 2007

8 김동환, "성과주의 보상제도의 정착을 위한 탐색적 연구: 조직공정성 차원을 중심으로" 30 (30): 117-132, 2007

9 양동훈, "보상제도가 협동행동에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구" 13 (13): 1-41, 2005

10 한정화, "기업구성원의 가치특성과 자원봉사활동이 조직시민행동에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구" 28 (28): 1099-1131, 1999

11 권순식, "근로자의 공정성 지각과 조직시민행위: 고용형태가 미치는 영향에 대한 탐색적 연구" 13 (13): 1-34, 2005

12 "orientations and reactions: Toward alternative human resource management practices" 51 : 571-588,

13 Stamper, C. L., "Workstatus and organizational citizenship behavior: A field study of restaurant employees" 22 : 517-536, 2001

14 Perlow, L., "Who’s helping whom? Layers of culture and workplace behavior" 23 : 345-361, 2002

15 Shanock, L. R., "When supervisors feel supported: Relationships with subordinates’ perceived supervisor support, perceived organizational support, and performance" 91 : 689-695, 2006

16 Dirks, K. T., "Trust in leadership: Meta-analytic findings and implications for research and practice" 87 : 611-628, 2002

17 Aryee,S., "Trust as a mediator of the relationship between organizational justice and work outcomes: Test of a social exchange model" 23 : 267-285, 2002

18 Cialdini, R. B., "Transgression altruism: A case for hedonism" 9 : 502-516, 1973

19 Podsakoff, P. M., "Transformational leader behaviors and their effects on followers’ trust in leader, satisfaction, and organizational citizenship behaviors" 1 : 107-142, 1990

20 Graen, G. B., "Toward a psychology of dyadic organizing" 9 : 172-208, 1987

21 Hochschild,A.R., "The time bind" Metropolitan Books 1997

22 Katz, D., "The social psychology of organizations" John Wiley and Sons, Inc. 1966

23 Wayne, S. J., "The role of fair treatment and rewards in perceptions of organizational support and leader-member exchange" 87 : 590-598, 2002

24 Ostroff, C., "The relationship between satisfaction, attitudes, and performance: An organizational level analysis" 77 : 963-974, 1992

25 Bolino, M. C., "The personal costs of citizenship behavior: The relationship between individual initiative and role overload, job stress, and work-family conflict" 90 : 740-748, 2005

26 Bergeron, D. M., "The paradox potential of organizational citizenship behavior: Good citizens at what cost?" 32 : 1078-1095, 2007

27 Bolino, M. C., "The other side of the story: Reexamining prevailing assumptions about organizational citizenship behavior" 40 : 229-246, 2004

28 Popper, K. R., "The open society and its enemies" Routledge & Kegan Paul 1945

29 Gouldner, A. W., "The norm of reciprocity: A preliminary statement" 25 : 161-178, 1960

30 LePine, J. A., "The nature and dimensionality of organizational citizenship behavior: A critical review and meta-analysis" 87 : 52-65, 2002

31 Fandt, P. M., "The management of information and impressions: When employees behave opportunistically" 45 : 140-158, 1990

32 Sitkin, S. B., "The legalistic organization: Definitions, dimensions, and dilemmas" 4 : 345-351, 1993

33 Christensen,C.M, "The innovator's dilemma: When new technologies cause great firms to fail" Harvard Business School Press 1997

34 Haworth, C. L., "The importance of instrumentality beliefs in the prediction of organizational citizenship behaviors" 59 : 64-75, 2001

35 Barnard,C.I., "The functions of the executive" Harvard University Press 1938

36 Allen, T. D., "The effects of organizational citizenship behavior on performance judgments: A field study and a laboratory experiment" 83 : 247-260, 1998

37 Koys, D. J., "The effects of employee satisfaction, organizational citizenship behavior, and turnover on organizational effectiveness: A unit-level, longitudinal study" 54 : 101-114, 2001

38 Mueller, C. W., "The degree to which justice is valued in the workplace" 13 : 1-24, 2000

39 Paine, J. B., "The cultural matrix of organizational citizenship behavior: Some preliminary conceptual and empirical observations" 10 : 45-59, 2000

40 Rioux, S. M., "The causes of organizational citizenship behavior: A motivational analysis" 86 : 1306-1314, 2001

41 Parker, S. K., "That is my job’: How employees’ role orientation affects their job performance" 60 : 403-444, 2007

42 Chen, Z. X., "Test of a mediation model of perceived organizational support" 66 : 457-470, 2005

43 Tesser, A., "Some effects of task relevance and friendship on helping: You don’t always help the one you like" 16 : 582-590, 1980

44 Judge, T. A., "Social context of performance evaluation decisions" 36 : 80-105, 1993

45 Greenberg, J., "Social comparison processes in organizations" 102 : 22-41, 2007

46 Morrison, E. W., "Role definitions and organizational citizenship behavior: The importance of the employee's perspective" 37 : 1543-1567, 1994

47 Vigoda-Gadot,E., "Rewarding the boundaries of OCB? An empirical explanation of compulsory extra-role behavior in the workplace" 21 : 377-405, 2007

48 Oyserman, D., "Rethinking individualism and collectivism: Evaluation of theoretical assumptions and meta-analysis" 128 : 3-72, 2002

49 Ford, J. D., "Resistance to change: The rest of the story" 33 : 362-377, 2008

50 Lam, S. S. K., "Relationship between organizational justice and employee work outcomes: A cross-national study" 23 : 1-18, 2002

51 Grant,A.M., "Relational job design and the motivation to make a prosocial difference" 32 (32): 393-417, 2007

52 Turnley, W. H., "Reexamining the effects of psychological contract violations: Unmet expectations and job dissatisfaction as mediators" 21 : 25-42, 2000

53 Fisher, J. D., "Recipient reactions to aid" 91 : 27-54, 1982

54 Allen, T. D., "Ratings of organizational citizenship behavior: Does the source make a difference?" 10 : 97-114, 2000

55 Robinson, S. L., "Psychological contracts and OCB: The effect of unfulfilled obligations on civic virtue behavior" 16 : 289-298, 1995

56 Rousseau, D. M., "Psychological and implied contracts in organizations" 12 : 121-139, 1989

57 Brief,A.P., "Prosocial organizational behaviors" 11 : 710-725, 1986

58 Frese, M., "Personal initiative: An active performance concept for work in the 21st century. In Research in Organizational Behavior" JAI Press 133-187, 2001

59 Kristof, A. L., "Person-organization fit: An integrative review of its conceptualizations, measurement, and implications" 49 : 1-49, 1996

60 Gilbert, D. T., "Overhelping" 70 : 678-690, 1996

61 Randall, M. L., "Organizational politics and organizational support as predictors of work attitudes, job performance, and organizational citizenship behavior" 20 : 159-, 1999

62 Schnake, M., "Organizational citizenship: A review, proposed model, and research agenda" 44 : 735-759, 1991

63 Walz, S. M., "Organizational citizenship behaviors: Their relationship to organizational effectiveness" 24 : 301-319, 2000

64 Podsakoff, P. M., "Organizational citizenship behaviors: A critical review of the theoretical and empirical literature and suggestions for future research" 26 : 513-563, 2000

65 Podsakoff, P. M., "Organizational citizenship behaviors and sales unit effectiveness" 31 : 351-363, 1994

66 Podsakoff, P. M., "Organizational citizenship behaviors and managerial evaluations of employee performance: A review and suggestions for future research" 1993

67 Organ,D.W., "Organizational citizenship behavior: The good soldier syndrome" Lexington Books 1988

68 Smith, C. A., "Organizational citizenship behavior: Its nature and antecedents" 68 : 653-663, 1983

69 Organ,D.W., "Organizational citizenship behavior: It's construct clean-up time" 10 : 85-98, 1997

70 Farh, J. L., "Organizational citizenship behavior in the People’s Republic of China" 15 : 241-253, 2004

71 Podsakoff, P. M., "Organizational citizenship behavior and the quantity and quality of work group performance" 82 : 262-270, 1997

72 Fisher, C., "On the dubious wisdom of expecting satisfaction to correlate with performance" 5 : 607-612, 1980

73 Farh,J.L., "On the cross-cultural validity of Holland's model of vocational choices in Hong Kong" 52 : 425-440, 1998

74 Tepper, B. J., "Moderators of the relationship between coworkers’ organizational citizenship behavior and fellow employees' attitudes" 89 : 455-465, 2004

75 Lewicki, R. J., "Models of interpersonal trust development: Theoretical approaches, empirical evidence, and future directions" 32 : 991-1022, 2006

76 Barksdale, K., "Managerial ratings of in-role behaviors, organizational citizenship behaviors, and overall performance: Testing different models of their relationship" 51 : 145-155, 2001

77 Roethlisberger,F.J., "Management and the worker" Wiley 1939

78 Bass,B.M., "Leadership and performance beyond expectations" Free Press 1985

79 Pillai, R., "Leadership and organizational justice: Similarities and differences across cultures" 30 : 763-779, 1999

80 Ilies, R., "Leader-member exchange and citizenship behaviors: A meta-analysis" 92 : 269-277, 2007

81 Tepper, B. J., "Justice, citizenship, and role definition effects" 86 : 789-796, 2001

82 Bateman, T. S., "Job satisfaction and the good soldier: The relationship between affect and employee citizenship" 26 : 587-595, 1983

83 Wiesenfeld, B. M., "Is more fairness always preferred? Self-esteem moderates reactions to procedural justice" 50 : 1235-1253, 2007

84 Rotter,J.B., "Interpersonal trust, trustworthiness, and gullibility" 35 : 1 -7, 1980

85 Van der Vegt, G. S., "Interdependence in project teams" 139 : 202-214, 1999

86 Hui, C., "Instrumental values of organizational citizenship behavior for promotion: A field quasiexperiment" 85 : 822-828, 2000

87 Adams, J. S., "Inequity in social exchange. In Advances in experimental social psychology" Academic Press 267-299, 1965

88 Moorman, R. H., "Individualism-collectivism as an individual predictor of organizational citizenship behavior" 16 : 127-142, 1995

89 Farh, J. L., "Individual-level cultural values as moderators of perceived organizational support-employee outcome relationship in China: Comparing the effects of power distance and traditionality" Academy of Management Jo 2007

90 Ertk, A., "Increasing organizational citizenship behaviors of Turkish academicians: Mediating role of trust in supervisor on the relationship between organizational justice and citizenship behaviors" 22 : 257-270, 2007

91 Vey, M. A., "In-role and extra-role organizational citizenship behavior: Which are we measuring?" 17 : 119-135, 2004

92 Eastman, K. K., "In the eyes of the beholder: An attributional approach to ingratiation and organizational citizenship behavior" 37 : 1379-1391, 1994

93 Werner,J.M., "Implications of OCB and contextual performance for human resource management" 10 : 3-24, 2000

94 Farh, J. L., "Impetus for action: A cultural analysis of justice and organizational citizenship behavior in Chinese society" 42 : 421-444, 1997

95 IBM, "IBM 한국보고서" 한국경제신문사 2007

96 DeVoe, S. E., "Hourly payment and volunteering: The effect of organizational practices on decisions about time use" 50 : 783-798, 2007

97 Janis,I.L., "Groupthink: Psychological studies of foreign policy decisions and fiascoes (2nd ed.)" Houghton-Mifflin 1982

98 Collins,J.C., "Good to great: Why some companies make the leap and others don't" Harper-Collins Publishers 2001

99 Deckop, J. R., "Getting more than you pay for: Organizational citizenship behavior and pay for performance system" 42 : 420-428, 1999

100 Arthur, J. B., "Gain-sharing as organizational learning: An analysis of employee suggestions over time" 44 : 737-754, 2001

101 Lewin,K., "Frontiers in group dynamics" 1 : 5-41, 1947

102 George, J. M., "Feeling good-doing good: A conceptual analysis of the mood at work-organizational spontaneity relationship" 112 : 310-329, 1992

103 Van Dyne, L., "Extra role behaviors: In pursuit of construct and definitional clarity (a bridge over muddied waters)" 17 : 215-285, 1995

104 Tekleab, A. G., "Extending the chain of relationships among organizational justice, social exchange, and employee reactions: The role of contract violations" 48 : 146-157, 2005

105 Borman, W. C., "Expanding the criterion domain to include elements of contextual performance. In Personnel selection in organizations" Jossey-Bass 71-98, 1993

106 Blau,P.M., "Exchange and power in social life" John Wiley and Sons, Inc. 1964

107 Van Scotter, J. R., "Effects of task performance and contextual performance on systemic rewards" 85 : 526-535, 2000

108 MacKenzie, S. B., "Do citizenship behaviors matter more for managers than for salespeople?" 27 : 396-410, 1999

109 Andrews, M. C., "Discriminating among organizational politics, justice, and support" 22 : 347-366, 2001

110 Werner,J.M., "Dimensions that make a difference: Examining the impact of in-role and extra-role behaviors on supervisory ratings" 79 : 98-107, 1994

111 Bettencourt, L. A., "Customercontact employees: Relationships among workplace fairness, job satisfaction and prosocial service behaviors" 73 : 39-61, 1997

112 Brockner, J., "Culture and procedural justice: The influence of power distance on reactions to voice" 2001

113 Tepper, B. J., "Consequences of abusive supervision" 43 : 178-190, 2000

114 Vigoda-Gadot, E., "Compulsory citizenship behavior in organizations: Theorizing some dark sides of the good soldier syndrome" 36 : 77-93, 2006

115 Van Dyne, L., "Collectivism, propensity to trust and self-esteem as predictors of organizational citizenship in a non-work setting" 21 : 3-23, 2000

116 Organ, D. W., "Cognitive versus affective determinants of organizational citizenship behavior" 74 : 157-164, 1989

117 Bolino, M. C., "Citizenship behavior and the creation of social capital in organizations" 27 : 505-522, 2002

118 Konovsky, M. A., "Citizenship and social exchange" 37 : 656-669, 1994

119 Bolino,M.C., "Citizenship and impression management: good soldiers or good actors?" 24 : 82-98, 1999

120 Colbert, A. E., "CEO Transformational leadership: The role of goal importance congruence in top management teams" 51 : 81-96, 2008

121 Shepperd, J. A., "Behavioral other-enhancement: Strategically obscuring the link between performance and evaluation" 60 : 79-88, 1991

122 Graham.J.W., "An essay on organizational citizenship behavior" 4 : 249-270, 1991

123 Meyer, J. P., "Affective, continuance, and normative commitment to the organization: A meta-analysis of antecedents, correlations, and consequences" 61 : 20-52, 2002

124 Zellars,K.L., "Abusive supervision and subordinates’ organizational citizenship behavior" 87 : 1068-1076, 2002

125 Organ, D. W., "A reappraisal and reinterpretation of the satisfaction-causes-performance hypothesis" 2 : 46-53, 1977

126 Griffin, M. A., "A new model of work role performance: Positive behavior in uncertain and interdependent contexts" 50 : 327-347, 2007

127 Organ, D. W., "A meta-analytic review of attitudinal and dispositional predictors of organizational citizenship behavior" 48 : 775-802, 1995

128 Bettencourt, L. A., "A comparison of attitude, personality, and knowledge predictions of service-oriented organizational citizenship behaviors" 86 : 29-41, 2001