A Comparative Study on the Teaching-Learning Contents between Two Elementary School Lessons: Application of Lemke's Frame of Instruction Analysis

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article examines the teaching-learning contents of two elementary school lessons by analyzing semantic relationships and thematic patterns which are constructed through teacher's initiation-student's response-teacher's evaluation or follow-up(I-R-E/F) sequence. Thematic pattern of a subject content describe a shared pattern of semantic relationships in a lesson dialogue(Lemke, 1990). Two distinct lessons in which the same learning theme from the third grade social studies curriculum are analysed using micro-ethnographic approach. The results of the analysis are as follows: 1) Thematic patterns occur more concurretly in the lesson constructed by ‘Teacher A' than that constructed by ‘Teacher B' and attainability of the learning theme is more substantial in the lesson of ‘Teacher A' than in that of ‘Teacher B'. 2) The thematic patterns taught and learned in two lessons are largely constructed by teachers' follow-up act and students' learning activities are those that repeat after the thematic patterns prearranged by teacher in the stage of introduction of learning activities. The findings show that the analytic method examined in this article for teaching-learning contents can be viable for analysing lesson content and instructional supervision.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 고창규, "한국과 일본 초등학교 수업의 말차례 가지기 규칙과 기법의 비교연구" 한국교원교육학회 21 (21): 253-274, 2004

2 조영달, "한국 중등학교 교실수업의 이해" 교육과학사 2001

3 경상남도창원교육청, "학습지도연구대회 교수 학습지도안"

4 고창규, "초등학교 수업의 바로잡기 유형 및 계열 연구" 11 (11): 1-19, 2001

5 고창규, "초등학교 수업의 말차례 가지기(turn-taking) 기법" 3 (3): 1-18, 2000

6 고창규, "초등학교 수업의 교사 바로잡기(repair) 기법" 29 (29): 163-191, 2002

7 고창규, "초등학교 1학년 수업의 참여구조에 관한 연구" 1-23 3 (3): 1-23, 2000

8 고창규, "초등학교 '좋은' 수업의 특성 연구 -담화행위(act), 유도행위, 교수행동요소, 바로잡기(repair)를 중심으로-" 한국열린교육학회 14 (14): 25-49, 2006

9 이혁규, "중학교 사회과 교실수업에 대한 일상생활기술적 사례 연구" 서울대학교 대학원 1996

10 조영달, "정형화된 사회적 공간에서의 한국적 상호작용유형의 이해-어느 고등학교 경제수업의 Turn-Taking과 사회적 참여구조 연구" 16 : 309-363, 1992

11 주삼환, "장학의 이론과 기법" 학지사 2003

12 김해교육청, "수업장학을 위한 수업관찰. 장학자료 2006-5호"

13 고창규, "수업의 질문-대답 계열 연구" 4 (4): 1-23, 2001

14 대전법동초등학교, "수업분석연수자료"

15 고창규, "수업대화 분석틀의 비교 연구-Mehan, Sinclair와 Coulthard, Lemke의 연구를 중심으로" 6 (6): 113-144, 2006

16 경상남도교육청, "수업! 경상남도 교육청 장학자료 2001-13"

17 임찬빈, "수업 전문성 일반 기준과 활용 방안. 한국교육과정평가원 연구자료 ORM 2006-24-1"

18 김영천, "네 학교 이야기: 한국초등학교의 교실생활과 수업" 교육과학사 1997

19 이정아, "교육과정 변천에 따른 초등 과학 교과서 텍스트에 대한 체계기능언어학적 분석" 27 (27): 242-252, 2007

20 경상남도교육청, "교원능력개발평가 선도학교 담당자 연수회. 교원능력개발평가 장학자료 2007-1"

21 고창규, "‘바다’초등학교 수업의 말차례 가지기 규칙" 10 (10): 1-20, 2000

22 Erickson, F., "organization of participation structure in two classroom of indian students In: Doing the ethnography of schooling" Holt,Rinehart& Winston 88-123, 1982

23 Edwards, D., "knowledge: The development of understanding in the classroom" Routledge 1987

24 Nassaji, H., "What's the use of triadic dialogue?: An investigation of teacher-student interaction" 21 (21): 376-406, 2000

25 Sinclair, J. M., "Towards an analysis of discourse: The English used by teachers and pupils" Oxford University Press 1975

26 McHoul, A. W., "The organization of turns at formal talk in the classroom" 7 : 183-213, 1978

27 McHoul, A. W., "The organization of repair in classroom talk" 19 : 349-377, 1990

28 Lemke, J. L., "Talking science: Language, learning and values" Ablex 1990

29 Au, K. Hu-pei, "Social organizational factors in learning to read: The balance of rights hypothesis" 17 (17): 115-152, 1981

30 Wells, G., "Reevaluating the IRF sequence: A proposal for the articulation of theories of activity and discourse for the analysis of teaching and learning in the classroom" 5 : 1-37, 1993

31 Philips, S., "Participant structures and communicative competence: Warm Springs children in community and classroom In: Functions of language in the classroom" Teachers College Press 370-394, 1972

32 Young, R. F., "Modes of meaning in high school science" 23 (23): 348-372, 2002

33 Mehan, H., "Learning lessons" Harvard University Press 1979

34 Chapman, A., "Intertextuality in school mathematics: The case of function" 7 : 243-262, 1995

35 Erickson, F., "Ethnographic microanalysis of interaction In: The handbook of qualitative research in education" Academic Press Inc. 201-225, 1992

36 Cazden, C., "Classroom discourse: The language of teaching and learning" Heinemann 1988

37 Cazden, C., "Classroom discourse In: of research on teaching" Macmillan 432-463, 1986

38 Shultz, J., "Aspects of social relationships in communication at home and at school In: Children in and out of school: Ethnography and education" Center for Applied Linguistics 88-123, 1982