Q 방법론을 이용한 예산 황새마을 조성사업의 갈등구조 분석 = Conflict Structure Analysis on the Construction of stork Eco-Village in Yesangun Using Q methodology

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Ecotourism has the potential to boost the energy of a village as it pays keen attention to the ecosystem and the residents of the village. It is empowered by participation of and cooperation among stakeholders who are closely involved in ecotourism. However, many of them express difficulty in striking a right balance between development and conservation with regard to promoting ecotourism. Against this backdrop, this research paper investigates the structure of conflict that the stakeholders, especially those in Stork Village in Yesan County, South Chungcheong Province of Korea, experience during the process of establishment of government-led ecotourism. In addition, this study examines the problems of government-led ecotourism model and how they can be addressed. To analyze conflict structure, this paper used Q methods and found out that the budget-related stakeholders are largely divided into four groups as who; a) complain about how business profits are distributed; b) secure profits by expanding programs; c) consider human settlement, and; d) broaden people`s participation. The biggest contributor to the conflicts is found that compensation was given discriminately to different jurisdictions. The second finding is that residents became less cooperative when the financial compensation did not live up to their expectation. For instance, they would demand the tourism facility physically expanded, repeatedly complain about the process of the work, and even accuse the government of degrading ecosystem. In other words, unless the compromise is reached with the residents regarding financial compensation, it could be difficult to encourage their participation and develop as a program-oriented tour. Lastly, the tour program needs to induce voluntary participation of the residents and deliver proper information on ecosystem and natural resources so as to last as sustainable ecotourism. The success of ecotourism will be subject to the cooperation of stakeholders in a region, conservation of our fragile ecosystem, and realization of sustainable growth through sharing economic benefits. This study looks into the cause of the conflicts of ecotourism sites and their structure. If this paper can bring about cooperation of stakeholders, the management and operation of ecotourism sites would be more sustainable.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이재혁, "지속가능한 생태관광을 위한 평가지표 개발 및 적용에 관한 연구" 대한지리학회 47 (47): 853-869, 2012

2 김진, "생태관광활동 참여에 따른 관광환경태도의 변화 - 우포늪 습지 방문객을 중심으로 -" 한국조경학회 39 (39): 56-64, 2011

3 이호영, "생태관광지 유형별 탐방객 특성 및 자연환경 훼손에 대한 인식 비교 연구" 한국환경생태학회 26 (26): 264-272, 2012

4 김정민, "산림기반형 한방치유 관광상품의 선호도에 관한 연구" 한국환경생태학회 26 (26): 463-471, 2012

5 조중현, "농촌지역개발사업 추진과정에서 표출된 주민 간 갈등의 근거 이론적 해석 : 농촌체험마을 사례를 중심으로" 한국농촌계획학회 14 (14): 1-12, 2008

6 Jungdo Ilbo, "Yes or No about Yesan Stork Eco-village Development"

7 YTN, "Where is stork Restoration Project going"

8 Hunter, W. C., "Understanding Resident Subjectivities toward Tourism Using Q method:Orchid Island, Taiwan" 21 (21): 331-354, 2013

9 Kim, S. E., "Theory and Philosophy of the Q Methodology" 20 (20): 1-25, 2010

10 Russell C. Hurd, "The Future of the Q Methodology Movement" 28 (28): 58-96, 2004

11 Kyunghyang Shinmun, "Stork-village which Attack Storks"

12 Yesangun, "Regional Plan of Stork Village in Yesan, Chungcheongnamdo"

13 이순자, "Q 방법론을 활용한 갈등행위자 인식유형 및 특성에 관한 연구 : 가로림조력발전소 건설계획을 중심으로" 한국지방행정연구원 25 (25): 271-302, 2011

14 김흥규, "Q 방법론 (과학철학, 이론, 분석 그리고 적용)" 커뮤니케이션북스 2008

15 Kim, H. G, "Q Methodology(Philosophy of Challenges of Planned Eco- tourism: Q Methodology and AHP Analysis for Stakeholders’ Response" 2008

16 Kim, S. E., "Q Method & Sociology" Gold Well Publishing Inc 2007

17 White, N. E, "International Handbook on Ecotourism" Edward Elgar Publishing 2013

18 Coles, T., "Ecotourism, NGOs and Development. A Critical Analysis" 12 (12): 295-296, 2009

19 Wunder, S., "Ecotourism and Economic Incentives—an Empirical approach" 32 (32): 465-479, 2000

20 Lee, J. H., "Current Status and Challenges of Planned Eco- tourism: Q Methodology and AHP Analysis for Stakeholders’ Response, Focusing on Maha eco-tourism site in Pyeongchang-gun where 2018 Olympic & Paralympic Winter Games will be held" 2013

21 Korean Research Institute for Humen Settlement, "Conflict Management in Spatial Development Project ; Exploring People’s Conception and Finding Policy Application" Korean Research Institute for Humen Settlement 2010

22 Gurung, D. B, "Community-based Ecotourism in Bhutan: Expert Evaluation of Stakeholder-based Scenarios" 15 (15): 397-411, 2008

23 Graci, S., "Collaboration and Partnership Development for Sustainable Tourism" 15 (15): 25-42, 2013

24 Chungcheong Today, "Chungnam, Preparing Budget without any Plan"

25 García-Melón, M., "A Combined ANP-delphi Approach to Evaluate Sustainable Tourism" 34 : 41-50, 2012