심리적 부검 연구에 관한 논고: 한국 심리적 부검 연구방법에 대한 비판적 검토 = A Critical Review of the Study Method of Psychological Autopsy in South Korea

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Social interest in `psychological autopsy` has been increasing due to the high suicide rate in Korea. The purpose of this study was to check up the characteristics and limitations of Korea psychological autopsy study method conducted so far. To achieve the aim of this study, total 15 articles about `psychological autopsy` were analyzed according to the general review method of literature. The author classified the articles according to commonalities and differences. Also, the researcher checked fundamental purpose and the original research method of psychological autopsy to compare studies mutually. Based on the results, a research framework was constructed. The analytical framework of the study was comprised of `the type of research`, `efforts to enhance reliability,` and `the role of the researchers.` As a result, this study pointed out that the limitations of previous studies was lack of real application about psychological autopsy studies, lack of efforts to ensure the reliability of research and lack of the researcher`s role. Based on the results of this research, researcher suggested that a practical study and a depth interview study should be spread, new strategies to secure for rigor of research that is suitable for the psychological autopsy be established and it should be needed for researcher to conduct a direct interview to overcome the limitations of psychological autopsy studies.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 서종한, "한국 자살사망자 특징: 사례-대조 심리적 부검 연구" 한국심리학회 31 (31): 323-344, 2012

2 권호인, "청소년 자살자에 대한 심리적 부검 방법론에 대한 고찰" 대한소아청소년 정신의학회 25 (25): 121-127, 2014

3 김영천, "질적연구방법론Ⅰ" 아카데미프레스 2012

4 유기웅, "질적 연구방법의 이해" 박영사 2012

5 조용환, "질적 연구: 방법과 사례" 교육과학사 1999

6 Heidegger, M., "존재와 시간" 까치글방 1998

7 고제원, "정신분석적 심리부검을 통한 자살방법의 연구" 한국과학수사학회 8 (8): 255-264, 2014

8 문국진, "자살의 증명과 심리부검" 15 (15): 1-13, 1991

9 이구상, "자살사망자의 축약 심리적부검에 관한 연구" 3 : 18-24, 2012

10 한국자살예방협회, "자살사망자 심리적 부검 및 자살시도자 사례관리서비스 구축방안" 보건복지부 2009

11 이원욱, "연구조사방법의 이해와 적용 : 질적연구와 사례연구 방법" 형설출판사 2011

12 Strauss, L. C., "야생의 사고" KBS사업단 1990

13 김선현, "심리부검에서 임상미술치료 활용방안에 관한 연구" 8 (8): 5-12, 2013

14 최광현, "심리부검(Psychological Autopsy)의 필요성에 관한 제언"

15 Shneidman, E. S., "심리부검 인터뷰" 학지사 2014

16 신성원, "심리부검 연구의 실무적 활용 및 윤리적 고려사항" 1 (1): 231-252, 2005

17 나경세, "심리부검 : 우리나라에서 향후 방향에 대한 검토 및 고찰" 대한신경정신의학회 54 (54): 40-48, 2015

18 박성희, "생애사에 기초한 질적 연구방법" 원미사 2011

19 Padgett, D. K., "사회복지 질적 연구 방법론" 나남 2005

20 민동용, "동반자살로 본 실태-문제점 / 자살사이트 망령 여전히 살아있다"

21 Glaser, B. G., "근거이론 분석의 기초 : 글레이저의 방법" 학지사 2014

22 전충현, "군자살자의 자살원인에 대한 효과적인 심리부검 적용 방안" 한국과학수사학회 6 (6): 79-91, 2012

23 송혜진, "군 자살자에 대한 심리부검; 해군 장병을 중심으로" 한국과학수사학회 7 (7): 126-137, 2013

24 황태윤, "‘심리적 부검’에 의한 공무상 질병의 판단 - 대상판결 : 서울고법 2013. 12. 19. 선고 2012누27505 판결 -" 법과정책연구원 20 (20): 595-618, 2014

25 Kjølseth, I., "Why Suicide? Elderly People Who Committed Suicide and Their Experience of Life in the Period Before Their Death" 22 (22): 209-218, 2010

26 Henry, M., "Therapeutic Effects of Psychological Autopsies" 30 (30): 20-24, 2009

27 Shneidman, E. S., "The Psychological Autopsy pp. 42-56 In Guide to the Investigation and Reporting of Drug Abuse Deaths" 11 (11): 325-340, 1977

28 Shneidman, E. S., "The Los Angeles Suicide Prevention Center : A Demonstration of Public Health Feasibilities" 55 (55): 21-26, 1965

29 Owens, C., "Tales of Biographical Disintegration : How Parents Make Sense of Their Sons’ Suicides" 30 (30): 237-254, 2008

30 Lindeman, S., "Suicide Among Medical Doctors : Psychological Autopsy Data on Seven Cases" 4 (4): 135-141, 1998

31 Robins, E., "Some Clinical Considerations in The Prevention of Suicide Based on a Study of 134Successful Suicides" 49 (49): 888-899, 1959

32 Kizza, D., "Qualitative Psychological Autopsy Interviews on Suicide in Post-Conflict Northern Uganda : The Participants’Perceptions" 63 (63): 235-254, 2011

33 Owens, C., "Public Involvement in Suicide Prevention : Understanding and Strengthening Lay Responses to Distress" 9 (9): 1-9, 2009

34 OECD, "OECD Health Data 2014"

35 Kizza, D., "Men in Despair:A Qualitative Psychological Autopsy Study of Suicide in Northern Uganda" 1-22, 2012

36 Dyregrov, K. M., "Meaning-Making Through Psychological Autopsy Interviews : The Value of Participating in Qualitative Research for Those Bereaved by Suicide" 35 : 685-710, 2011

37 Jesson, J., "How to Do(or not to Do)a Critical Literature Review" 6 (6): 139-148, 2006

38 Hawgood, J., "Farmer Suicide: Data From the Queensland Suicide Register(QSR) and Psychological Autopsy Case Studies" 2010

39 Hatch, J. A., "Doing Qualitative Research In Education Settings" State University of New York Press 2002

40 Charmaz, K., "Constructing Grounded Theory" Sage 2006

41 Upanne, M., "Can Suicide Be Prevented? The Suicide Project in Finland 1992-1996: Goals, Implementation and Evaluation" STAKE National Research and Development Center for Welfare and Health 1999

42 Corbin, J., "Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques" Sage 1990

43 Kizza, D., "An Escape From Agony : A Qualitative Psychological Autopsy Study of Women’s Suicide in a Post-Conflict Northern Uganda" 7 : 1-14, 2012

44 Kizza, D., "Alcohol and Suicide in Postconflict Northen Uganda" 33 (33): 95-15, 2012

45 오윤성, "A Study of Relevant Factors for an Effective Psychological Autopsy in Military : Focused on the Korea Army Conscripts’Cases" 한국공안행정학회 19 (19): 271-300, 2010

46 Owens, C., "A Qualitative Study of Help Seeking and Primary Care Consultation Prior to Suicide" 55 : 503-509, 2005

47 아주대학교, "2013 자살 실태조사" 보건복지부 205-337, 2013