인문,사회과학편 : 사회인야구 배트 규제 논쟁에 대한 덕 윤리적 접근 = A Virtue-Ethical Approach to the Dispute over the Restriction on Baseball Bat in Amateur Baseball League

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study was to try to find an ethical solution to restriction problem on baseball bat in amateur baseball league. For the moment, the trace of debate on restriction on baseball bat was reviewed before the arguments for or against the restriction on baseball bat were comparatively analyzed. The arguments for the restriction on baseball bat were based on the prevention of a wound and accidents, the pursuit of record and a ‘win at all cost’ attitude, and unfair advantage. The arguments against the restriction on baseball bat on the other hand were based on the infringing the autonomy of baseball club members, the revitalization of the market of baseball equipments, a general practice, and the reduction of pleasure of batting. Virtue ethics was proposed as a complimentary solution to solve this sharp conflict between the two arguments. Participants in amateur baseball league were supposed as members of a specified community such as a community of amateur baseball league from the standpoint of virtue ethics, not separate and isolated individuals from that community. Therefore, members of amateur baseball league would have to find a clue for solving the dispute over the restriction on baseball bat in amateur baseball league by controling their desire in the pursuit of the common good of a community of amateur baseball league.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김상돈, "학으로서 윤리학'의 위기" 한국윤리학회 1 (1): 25-47, 2006

2 박동희, "프로야구보다 더 오래된 ‘청합’"

3 홍성우, "자유주의와 공동체주의 윤리학" 선학사 2005

4 김원철, "월드컵 다 봤어? 우리는 야구한다: 전국 열풍! 사회인야구"

5 박성주, "스포츠윤리의 이론적 기초" 한국체육철학회 22 (22): 77-97, 2014

6 김도헌, "스포츠산업 ‘공생의 길’ 모색하다"

7 Hamilton, M. J., "소크라테스, 야구장에 가다 (" 야구장에 가다 182-199, 2013

8 Feezell, R., "소크라테스, 야구장에 가다" 미다스북스 161-181, 2013

9 Morgan, W. J., "소크라테스, 야구장에 가다" 미다스북스 221-237, 2013

10 강유원, "사회인야구의 맛과 멋, 그리고 매력" 한국체육철학회 18 (18): 45-61, 2010

11 박상용, "사회인 야구동호인의 하위 문화적 특성: 야구용품 구입을 중심으로" 한국체육과학회 20 (20): 205-218, 2011

12 정현태, "사회인 야구 동호인의 참여 속성, 결과 및 가치" 한국사회체육학회 (55) : 147-158, 2014

13 권기성, "사회인 야구 대회 개최를 통하여 온라인 소매업체가 적용한 관계마케팅 전략의 효과성 검증" 국민체육진흥공단 부설 한국스포츠개발원 25 (25): 48-64, 2014

14 서기열, "문체부, 스포츠산업 중장기 발전계획 발표: 스포츠에 IT 접목해 53조 시장 키운다"

15 小林正彌, "마이클 샌델의 정치철학" 황금물고기 2012

16 송형석, "도핑은 왜 비도덕적인가? - 도핑금지담론의 비판적 고찰 -" 한국체육학회 45 (45): 31-40, 2006

17 김태호, "규제없는 사회인 야구: ‘단무지 배트’공포"

18 "국민생활체육 전국야구연합회 홈페이지"

19 "게임원 홈페이지"

20 Crisp, R., "Virtue Ethics" Oxford University Press 1-25, 1997

21 Etzioni, A., "Rights and the Common Good: The Communitarian Perspective" St. Martin's Press 1995

22 Sandel, M. J., "Liberalism and the Limits of Justice" Cambridge University Press 1998

23 MacIntyre, A., "After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory" University of Notre Dame Press 1984

24 더그아웃 매거진, "2014 배트 컨퍼런스"