우리나라에서의 환경침해에 대한 留止請求權의 논의현황

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

ⅰ) The legal basis of injunctions against environmental nuisances has been theoretically disputed on, and also precedents have not clarified such problems. On the other hand, the Supreme Court gave a decision on the matter that the owner of a building may apply for an injunction against a noise nuisance on the basis of its ownership. In addition, it explicitly recognized that injunctions against environmental nuisances are based on ‘Article 214 of Civil Act’.
ⅱ) However, it is stipulated that the question of whether a nuisance is endurable shall be judged with reference to various circumstances such as the characteristics of damage, the degree of damage, the public I-nterest of damage, the characteristics of harmful acts, the public interest of harmful acts, harmer’s countermeasures against damage, the possibility that the harmer will avoid responsibility, the authority of public law, locality, the priority of land use and otherwise. It is considered as unreasonable. However, the duty of endurance is reasonable to be judged by Article 217 of Civil Act based on the article 906 of German civil law.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 序
• Ⅱ. 法的 根據
• Ⅲ. 請求權의 要件
• Ⅳ. 請求權의 排除
• Ⅴ. 請求權의 內容과 方法
• 참고문헌
• 〈Abstract〉

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 尹眞秀, "환경침해를 이유로 하는 유지청구의 許容與否" 1996

2 전경운, "환경침해로 인한 위법성판단과 환경정책기본법 제31조의 효력" 한국민사법학회 (22) : 2002

3 吳錫洛, "환경소송의 제문제" 삼영사 1996

4 金永振, "우리나라 公害訴訟의 判決例" 2 : 1979

5 陳順碩, "교육환경권침해와 유지청구" 10 : 1995

6 趙誠民, "環境侵害와 妨害排除請求權의 認否" 1996

7 전경운, "環境侵害被害의 私法上 救濟法理" 한국환경법학회 25 (25): 14-390, 2003

8 金相容, "物權法(전정판)" 법문사 2000

9 郭潤直, "物權法(신정수정판)" 박영사 1999

10 李英俊, "物權法" 박영사 1990

11 곽윤직, "民法注解(Ⅴ)" 박영사 1992

12 Karl Larenz, "eherbuch des Schuldrechts, Band Ⅱ/2, 13. Aufl." 1994

13 "ders, Ausbau des Individualschutzes gegen Umweltbelastungen als Aufgabe des bürgerlichen und des öffentlichen Rechts" DJT 1986

14 Peter Marburger, "Zur zivilrechtlichen Haftung für Waldschäden, in: Waldschäden als Rechtsproblem" UTR Band 2

15 Harry Westermann, "Westermann Sachenrecht, 7. Aufl." 1998

16 "Staudingers Kommentar zum Bürgerlichen Gesetzbuch, 12. Aufl" 1989

17 Karl Heinz Schwab, "Sachenrecht, 32. Aufl." 1994

18 Jan Wilhelm, "Sachenrecht, 2. Aufl." 2002

19 Manfred Wolf, "Sachenrecht, 13. Aufl." 1996

20 Jürgen F. Baur, "Lehrbuch des Sachenrechts, 16. Aufl." 1992

21 Peter Baumann, "Die Haftung für Umweltschäden aus zivilrechtlicher Sicht"

22 Gert Brüggemeier, "Deliktsrecht"

23 Klaus Fritz, "Das Verhältnis von privatem und öffentlichem Immissionsschutzrecht nach der Ergänzung von §906 Ⅰ BGB"