병원전문화 전략유형의 적합성과 조직성과 분석 = The Fitness and Organizational performance Analysis of Hospital Specialization Strategy Types

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This research classified hospital specialization strategy types through cluster analysis, analyzed fitness of hospital specialization strategy types for external environment or organizational structure, and examined relation between hospital specialization strategy types and organizational performance. This research surveyed 1,437 hospitals which have more than 30 patient`s bed and practice national health service in Korea. Specifically, this research divided into two part : external fit - analysis of relation between external environment and specialization strategy, internal fit-analysis of relation between organizational structure factors and specialization strategy. also, as the organizational performance for achieving specialization strategic purpose, not only the productivity, efficiency, profit but also the medical quality was considered. In case of external fit, many hospitals chose integration type if there are a lot of competitive hospitals and regional population. Particularly, if there are many competitive hospitals, concentration type is chosen. In contrast, if there are many doctors in the region, differentiation type is chosen. In case of internal fit, according to organization type and patient`s bed number, hospitals chose different types. If it is a general hospital and has a few bed number, generalization or concentration type is chosen. Tertiary hospital or the hospital with many patient`s bed chose differentiation type. According to the number of specialists, if there are a few specialists, generalization or concentration type is chosen. If there are many specialists, differentiation type has high fitness for the hospital. In relation to strategy types and organizational performance, differentiation type has best result. Differentiation type has a good result in 7 items out of 11.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김원중, "중소병원의 전문화와 경영성과 -수익성분석을 중심으로-" 4 (4): 85-105, 1999

2 정우진, "중소병원의 발전구상(Ⅰ): 병원전문화를 중심으로" 3 (3): 11-19, 1997

3 김영훈, "중소병원 경쟁력 강화방안" 한국보건산업진흥원·대한병원협회 2012

4 김영훈, "전문병원제도란 무엇인가?" 병원경영진단사협회 2011

5 김미선, "전문병원과 일반병원의 서비스의 질과 환자만족도에 관한 실증적 분석" 한국병원경영학회 11 (11): 31-53, 2006

6 한국보건산업진흥원, "전문병원 제도 도입에 관한 연구" 2003

7 이광수, "의료기관 서비스 전문화 수준의 측정 및 분석" 한국보건행정학회 18 (18): 67-85, 2008

8 김영훈, "병원경영학원론" 수문사 2011

9 Tabachnick, B.G, "Using multivariate statistics" Allyn and Bacon 2001

10 Skinner W, "The focused factory" 52 (52): 113-122, 1974

11 Iglehart JK, "The emergence of physician-owned specialty hospitals" 352 : 78-84, 2005

12 Barro J.R, "The Effect of Cardiac Specialty Hospital on the Cost and Quality of Medical Care" 25 : 702-721, 2006

13 Kilduff, P, "Strategic and Organizational response to increasing environmental turbulence in the textile and apparel industries" 4 (4): 11-26, 2002

14 Kimberly, J.R, "Strategic adaptation in health care organizations : Implications for theory and research" 42 (42): 267-301, 1985

15 Luke, R.D, "Strategic Making in health care organizations. Health Care Management : Organization Design and Behavior. 4th ed" Delmar Publishers 2000

16 Greenwald, L, "Specialty versus community hospitals: referrals, quality, and community benefits" 25 (25): 106-118, 2006

17 Devers, K.J, "Specialty hospital : focused factories or cream skimmers?" Center for Studying Health System Change 2003

18 GAO, "Specialty Hospitals : information on national market share, physician ownership and patients served" United States General Accounting Office 1-20, 2003

19 XiaoKai, Y, "Specialization and economic organization : A new classical microeconomics framework" 1993

20 Luke R.D, "Spatial competition and cooperation in local hospital markets" 48 (48): 207-237, 1991

21 Lee K.S, "Reforming the hospital service structure to improve efficiency : urban hospital specialization" 87 : 41-49, 2008

22 GAO, "Physician-owned specialty hospitals" United States General Accounting Office 1-51, 2005

23 Galbraith, J.R, "Organizing for the future : the new logic for managing complex Organizations" Jossey-Bass 1993

24 Scott, W. R, "Organizations : Rational, Natural, and Open System. Pearson Education" 2003

25 Miles, R.E, "Organizational strategy, structure, and process" 3 (3): 546-562, 1978

26 Okasha, A.A, "Modeling the determinants of hospital services differentiation and specialization. Unpublished and context" 19 : 115-147, 1995

27 Dayhoff D.A, "Measuring differences and similarity in hospital caseloads : a conceptual and empirical Analysis" 28 (28): 293-312, 1993

28 Farley, D. E, "Measuring casemix specialization and the concentration of diagnoses in hospitals using information theory" 8 : 185-207, 1989

29 Ginsberg A, "Measuring and Modeling change in strategy : Theoretical foundations and empirical directions" 9 : 559-757, 1988

30 Herzlinger R.E, "Market drive healthcare, who wins, who loses in the transformation of Americas largest service industry" Addisson- Wesley 1997

31 McCarthy M, "Is the performance of cancer services influenced more by hospital factors or by specialization?" 30 (30): 69-74, 2007

32 Evans, R.G, "Information theory and the analysis of hospital cost structure" 5 (5): 398-418, 1972

33 Eastaugh, S.R, "Hospital specialization and cost efficiency : benefits of trimming product line" 37 (37): 223-235, 1992

34 Trinh, H.Q, "Helpful or harmful? The impact of strategic change on the performance of U.S. urban hospitals" 37 (37): 143-169, 2002

35 Shortell, S.M, "Health Care Management : A Text in Organizational Theory and Behavior" John Wiely & Sons 1983

36 Casalino, LP, "Focused factories? Physician-owned specialty facilities" 22 : 56-67, 2003

37 Meyer H, "Focused Factories" 72 (72): 24-30, 1998

38 Succi M.J, "Effects of market position and competition on rural hospital closures" 31 (31): 679-699, 1996

39 Zwanziger, J, "Differentiation and specialization in the California hospital industry 1983 to 1988" 34 (34): 361-372, 1983

40 Michael J.B, "Data Mining Techniques For Marketing. Sales and Customer Support" John Wiley & Sons 1997

41 Tushman, M.L, "Convergence and upheaval : managing the unsteady pace of organizational evolution. In Managing Strategic Innovation and Change" Oxford University Press 583-594, 1997

42 Urquhart DJB, "Consumer-driven health care: implications for providers, payers, and policy makers Chapter 58" Jossey-Bass 2004

43 Porter, M. E, "Competitive advantage : creating and sustaining superior performance" Free press 1985

44 Galbraith, J. R, "Competing with flexible lateral organizations. 2nd Edition" Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Inc 1994

45 Farley, D.E, "Case-mix specialization in the market for hospital services" 25 (25): 757-783, 1990

46 Kass, G, "An exploratory technique for investigating large quantities of categorical data" 29 (29): 119-129, 1980