The Impacts of Media Symbol Variety on Performance in Virtual Teams

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study is to examine the impacts of media symbol variety on group performance in virtual teams. Symbol variety is defined as the number of ways in which information can be communicated and includes Daft and Lengel [1986]’s multiplicity of cues and language variety. According to media richness theory and media synchronicity theory, the use of media with high symbol variety is assumed to facilitate and promote communications among virtual team members. Therefore, it is expected that the media symbol variety is positively associated with group performance in virtual teams. Furthermore, online relationship building is expected to mediate the impacts of symbol variety on the performance. To confirm the suppositions, a controlled lab experiment was conducted with 60 undergraduate students as subjects. In the experimental virtual teams, subjects were allowed to communicate with other members using text-based messenger with emoticons. Subjects in the control virtual teams were allowed to communicate using only text-based messenger. The direct impact of symbol variety on group performance in virtual teams was found insignificant. However, the online relationship was found to completely mediate the positive impact of symbol variety on group performance. The implications and limitations of this study are also discussed for future research.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Warkentin,M, "Virtual Teams Versus Face-to-face teams：An Exploratory Study of a Webbased Conference System" 28 (28): 975-996, 1997

2 Rheingold, H, "The Virtual Community" Addison- Wesley publishing 1993

3 Chin,W, "The Partial Least Squares Approach to Structural Equation Modeling" Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 295-336, 1998

4 Barclay, D, "The Partial Least Squares (PLS) Approach to Causal Modeling, Personal Computer Adoption and Use as an Illustration" 2 (2): 285-324,

5 Raymond, E. S, "The New Hacker’s Dictionary, 2nd ed" The MIT Press 162-163, 1994

6 Dennis,A.R, "Testing Media Richness Theory in the New Media ：the Effects of Cues,Feedback and Task Equivocality" 9 (9): 256-274, 1998

7 Kiesler,S, "Social Psychological Aspects of Computer-Mediated Communication" 39 (39): 1123-1134, 1984

8 Altman,I, "Social Penetration： The Development of Interpersonal Relationships" Rinehart and Winston 1973

9 Utz, S, "Social Information Processing in MUDs：The Development of Friendships in Virtual Worlds" Web:/JOB/v1n1/ utz.html 1 (1): 2000

10 Huston,T.L, "Social Exchange in Developing Relationships： An Overview Social Exchange in Developing Relationships" Academic Press 3-28, 1979

11 DeStepen,R.S, "Small Group Consensus：Stability of Group Support of the Decision,Task Process,and Group Relations" 19 (19): 227-239, 1998

12 Robey,D, "Situated Learning in Cross-functional Virtual Teams" 47 (47): 51-66, 2000

13 Dennis,A.R, "Rethinking Media Richness：Towards a Theory of Media Synchronicity" 1-10, 1999

14 Kline,J.A, "Redundancy,Self-orientation,and Group Consensus" 40 : 72-74, 1976

15 Hollander,E.P, "Principles and methods of social psychology" Oxford University Press 1971

16 Gouran,D.S, "Patterns of Interaction in Discussion Groups at Varying Distance from Consensus" 8 : 511-524, 1997

17 Daft,R.L, "Organizational Information Requirements,Media Richness and Structural Design" 32 (32): 554-571, 1986

18 Daft,R.L, "Message Equivocality,Media Selection and Manager Performance：Implications for Information Systems" 11 (11): 355-366, 1987

19 Dennis,A.R, "Media,Tasks,and Communication Processes：A Theory of Media Synchronicity" 32 : 545-600, 2008

20 Yoo,Y., "Media and Group Cohesion：Relative Influences on Social Presence,Task Participation,and Group Consensus" 25 (25): 371-390, 2001

21 Parks,M.R, "Making Friends in Cyberspace" 46 : 80-97, 1996

22 Lea,M, "Love at First Byte ：Building Personal Relationships over Computer Networks Understudied Relationships： Off the Beaten Track" CA：Thousand Oaks 197-233, 1995

23 Daft,R.L, "Language and Organization" 4 (4): 179-191, 1979

24 Buckman,R, "How to Break Bad News： A Guide for Health Care Professionals" The Johns Hopkins University Press 1992

25 Burke,K, "How Much Bandwidth is Enough? A Longitudinal Examination of Media Characteristics and Group Outcomes" 23 (23): 557-579, 1992

26 Tidwell,L.C, "Getting to Know One Another a Bit at a Time： Computer-Mediated Communication Effects on Disclosure, Impressions, and Interpersonal Evaluations" 2000

27 Duxbury,L, "Gender Differences in Work-family Conflict" 76 : 60-74, 1991

28 Fornell,C, "Evaluating Structural Equation Models with Unobservable Variables and Measurement Error" 18 : 39-50, 1981

29 Jarvenpaa,S.L, "Communication and Trust in Global Virtual Teams" 10 (10): 791-815, 1999

30 Parks,M.R, "Communication Networks and the Development of Romantic Relationships：An Expansion of Uncertainty Reduction Theory" 10 : 55-79, 1983

31 Huang,W, "Can a Lean E-mail Medium be Used for Rich Communication? A Psychological Perspective" 7 : 269-274, 1998

32 Munzer,S, "Bridging the Gap Between Media Synchronicity and Task Performance" 36 : 76-103, 2009

33 Watson,R.T, "Attractors：Building Mountains in the Flat Landscape of the World Wide Web" 40 (40): 36-56, 1998

34 McLeod,P.L, "An Assessment of the Experimental Literature on Electronic Support of Group Work：Results of a Metaanalysis" 7 : 257-280, 1992

35 McGrath,J.E, "A. E., Groups Interacting with Technology" CA ：Thousand Oaks 1994

36 Wakefield,R.L, "A Model of Conflict,Leadership,and Performance in Virtual Teams" 19 (19): 434-455, 2008