Glenoid Bone Loss in Shoulder Instability: Superiority of Three-Dimensional Computed Tomography over Two-Dimensional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Using Established Methodology

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Background: Recent literature suggests that three-dimensional magnetic resonance imaging (3D MRI) can replace 3D computed tomography (3D CT) when evaluating glenoid bone loss in patients with shoulder instability. We aimed to examine if 2D MRI in conjunction with a validated predictive formula for assessment of glenoid height is equivalent to the gold standard 3D CT scans for patients with recurrent glenohumeral instability.
Methods: Patients with recurrent shoulder instability and available imaging were retrospectively reviewed. Glenoid height on 3D CT and 2D MRI was measured by two blinded raters. Difference and equivalence testing were performed using a paired t -test and two one-sided tests, respectively. The interclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was used to test for interrater reliability, and percent agreement between the measurements of one reviewer was used to assess intrarater reliability.
Results: Using an equivalence margin of 1 mm, 3D CT and 2D MRI were found to be different (p = 0.123). The mean glenoid height was significantly different when measured on 2D MRI (39.09 ± 2.93 mm) compared to 3D CT (38.71 ± 2.89 mm) (p = 0.032). The mean glenoid width was significantly different between 3D CT (30.13 ± 2.43 mm) and 2D MRI (27.45 ± 1.72 mm) (p < 0.001). The 3D CT measurements had better interrater agreement (ICC, 0.91) than 2D MRI measurements (ICC, 0.8). intrarater agreement was also higher on CT.
Conclusions: Measurements of glenoid height using 3D CT and 2D MRI with subsequent calculation of the glenoid width using a validated methodology were not equivalent, and 3D CT was superior. Based on the validated methods for the measurement of glenoid bone loss on advanced imaging studies, 3D CT study must be preferred over 2D MRI in order to estimate the amount of glenoid bone loss in candidates for shoulder stabilization surgery and to assist in surgical decision-making.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Parada SA, "Use of the contralateral glenoid for calculation of glenoid bone loss : a cadaveric anthropometric study" 36 (36): 1517-1522, 2020

2 Moineau G, "Threedimensional measurement method of arthritic glenoid cavity morphology: feasibility and reproducibility" 98 (98): S139-S145, 2012

3 Markenstein JE, "The quantification of glenoid bone loss in anterior shoulder instability; MR-arthro compared to 3D-CT" 43 (43): 475-483, 2014

4 Itoi E, "The effect of a glenoid defect on anteroinferior stability of the shoulder after Bankart repair : a cadaveric study" 82 (82): 35-46, 2000

5 Owens BD, "Simple method of glenoid bone loss calculation using ipsilateral magnetic resonance imaging" 41 (41): 622-624, 2013

6 Boileau P, "Risk factors for recurrence of shoulder instability after arthroscopic Bankart repair" 88 (88): 1755-1763, 2006

7 Shaha JS, "Redefining"critical"bone loss in shoulder instability : functional outcomes worsen with"subcritical"bone loss" 43 (43): 1719-1725, 2015

8 Biswas D, "Radiation exposure from musculoskeletal computerized tomographic scans" 91 (91): 1882-1889, 2009

9 Vopat BG, "Measurement of glenoid bone loss with 3-dimensional magnetic resonance imaging : a matched computed tomography analysis" 34 (34): 3141-3147, 2018

10 Stecco A, "MRI can assess glenoid bone loss after shoulder luxation : inter-and intra-individual comparison with CT" 118 (118): 1335-1343, 2013

11 Dekker TJ, "Location of the glenoid defect in shoulders with recurrent posterior glenohumeral instability" 47 (47): 3051-3056, 2019

12 Walter WR, "Imaging quantification of glenoid bone loss in patients with glenohumeral instability : a systematic review" 212 (212): 1096-1105, 2019

13 Baudi P, "Imaging of the unstable shoulder" 11 : 882-896, 2017

14 Levy DM, "History of surgical intervention of anterior shoulder instability" 25 (25): e139-e50, 2016

15 Giles JW, "Estimating glenoid width for instability-related bone loss : a CT evaluation of an MRI formula" 43 (43): 1726-1730, 2015

16 Yamamoto N, "Effect of an anterior glenoid defect on anterior shoulder stability : a cadaveric study" 37 (37): 949-954, 2009

17 Shin SJ, "Critical value of anterior glenoid bone loss that leads to recurrent glenohumeral instability after arthroscopic Bankart repair" 45 (45): 1975-1981, 2017

18 Beaulieu-Jones BR, "Characterization of posterior glenoid bone loss morphology in patients with posterior shoulder instability" 35 (35): 2777-2784, 2019

19 Lansdown DA, "Automated 3-dimensional magnetic resonance imaging allows for accurate evaluation of glenoid bone loss compared with 3-dimensional computed tomography" 35 (35): 734-740, 2019

20 Stillwater L, "3D-MR vs. 3D-CT of the shoulder in patients with glenohumeral instability" 46 (46): 325-331, 2017