Value Cleavages, Issues, and Partisanship in East Asia

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article examines how the social transformation in many East Asian democracies is altering the value priorities of their publics, and how these values are affecting party choice. Our analyses are based on the newest wave of the World Values Survey. We find that the emergence of an authoritarian-libertarian value cleavage is clearly associated with level of development, but these values emerge well before what prior research indicated. In addition, we show that party loyalty among the East Asian citizenry is shaped by a mix of social values, economic issues, Left-Right ideology, distrust in governmental institutions, and proclivities to engage in protest activities.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Flanagan, "？Value Change and Democratic Reform in Japan and Korea？ and the Authoritarian-Libertarian Value Change in Advanced Industrial Democracies？"

2 Christian Welzel, "？The Human Development Model of Democracy East Asia in Perspective.？ In Dalton and Shin Democracy and Markets around the Pacific Rim and Democracy.？ In Dalton and Shin Democracy and Markets around the Pacific Rim" ？Self-Expression 21 50-49 72,

3 Scott C. Flanagan, "？The Causes and Socio-Political Implications of Value Change in the Advanced Industrial Democracies.？ Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association" 1990.

4 Scott C. Flanagan, "？Modernization and the Emergence of the Authoritarian Libertarian Value Cleavage.？ Paper presented at the annual meeting at the Southern Political Science Association" 1991.

5 Steve Rood, "？Elections as complicated and Important Events in the Philippines ？ in Hsieh and Newman" 154-,

6 John Fuh-Sheng Hsieh, "？Continuity and Change in Taiwan？s Electoral Politics.？ In Hsieh and Newman" 32-49,

7 Scott C. Flanagan, "and the Vote.？ In Scott Flanagan" Yale University Press 84-142, 1991

8 "and McAllister in this issue." Dalton and Tanaka article

9 Scott C. Flanagan, "Value Change and Democratic Reform in Japan and Korea" 33 (33): 626-659, 2000

10 Michael S. Lewis-Beck, "University of Michigan Press" helmut eds. eco (helmut eds. eco): 1991

11 Scott C. Flanagan, "The New Politics, Culture Wars, and the Authoritarian-Libertarian Value Change in Advanced Industrial Democracies" 36 (36): 235-270, 2003

12 New Zealand, "Taiwan are included in the 1995-1997 WVS survey Singapore and South Korea are in the 1999-2001 survey but we could not include them because they lack the party preference question."

13 Mark Western, "Postmaterialist and Economic Voting in Australia" 36 (36): 439-458, 2001

14 Scott Mainwaring, "Political sequences and the stabilization of interparty competition" 13 : 155-178, PartyPolitics

15 Aie-Rie Lee, "Party Identifiers in South Korea" XXXV (XXXV): 367-376, 1995

16 Ronald Inglehart, "Modernization, Cultural Change and Democracy" New York: Cambridge University Press 2005

17 In later work, "Inglehart has adopted the broader idea of ？self-expressive values？ in his comparison of developed and developing nations and this is conceptually close to our earlier framework of A/L values. See Inglehart and Welzel"

18 Inglehart, "Inglehart Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society and Democracy. The correlations between the A-L scale and education are .23 for Japan" -12 28 02 14 29,

19 Dalton, "How Asia Votes" New York: Chatham House Publishers 2002

20 Donald E. Weatherbee, "Electoral Politics in a Newly Emerging Democracy ？ in Hsieh and Newman" 262-,

21 D. J. Jang, "East Asian Perspectives on Liberal Democracy: A Critical Evaluation" Singapore: Marshall Cavendish Academic 37-56, 2006

22 Ronald Inglehart, "Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society" Princeton Princeton University Press 1990

23 Yun-Han Chu, "Crafting Democracy in Taiwan Institute for National Policy Research Dalton and Tanaka in this issue find that national pride is the strongest correlate of Left/Right position in Taiwan." 1992

24 Russell Dalton, "Authority Orientations and Support for Democracy in East Asia" Oxford: Oxford University Press 50-72, 2006

25 Ray Duch, "A Developmental Model of Heterogeneous Economic Voting in New Democracies" 95 : 895-910, 2001