음악 표절에 관한 실무적 쟁점: 대중가요를 중심으로 = Music Plagiarism -A framework for Litigation-

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Lawsuits involving claims of music plagiarism have proliferated in recent years. Although there were many cases on plagiarism or substantial similarity in musical works recently, only several judicial decisions in South Korea were reported. In order to prove music plagiarism, a plaintiff must demonstrate: (1) the originality of his or her complaining work, (2) access of defendant to complaining work, (3) substantive similarity between two works. In Korea, there are some cases dealing with music plagiarism. And in generally, the point of view of Korean Court is resonable. But there are some point at issue. First of all, it is not clear where burden of proof in originality and access is on. As a general rule, a plaintiff must have burden of proof in originality and access, but in many cases, it is duty of defendant. Secondly, it is hard for defendant to prove independent creation. Finally, when estimating damage of plaintiff, Korean court does not considerate the importance of plagiarized part.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 최현영, "표절 개념을 통해 본 대중음악 표절시비의 문제점" 13 (13): 2001

2 정상조, "지적재산권법" 홍문사 2004

3 이성호, "저작권침해 여부의 판단 기준과 각종 저작물의 유형벌 특성에 따른 실제적 적용, In 동천 김인섭 변호사 화갑기념 논문집 『법실천의 제문제』" 1996

4 김병일, "음악저작물의 표절 및 공정이용의 기준" 6 (6): 2007

5 허희성, "음악저작물의 창작성과 실질적 유사성" (68) :

6 강태욱, "음악저작물에 있어서 실질적 유사성의 문제" (77) : 2007

7 "수원지방법원 2006. 10. 20. 선고 2006가합8583 판결"

8 "서울중앙지방법원 2012. 2. 10. 선고 2011가합70768 판결"

9 "서울중앙지방법원 2011. 4. 13. 선고 2010가단86875 판결"

10 "서울중앙지방법원 2010. 6. 24. 선고 2009가합124549 판결"

11 "서울서부지방법원 2006. 3. 17. 선고 2004가합4676 판결"

12 한국문화콘텐츠진흥원, "문화콘텐츠 계약 매뉴얼" 한국문화콘텐츠진흥원 2010

13 이장직, "대중음악의 분석" 5 (5): 1992

14 "대법원 2011. 2. 10. 선고 2009도291 판결"

15 "대법원 2004. 7. 8. 선고 2004다18736 판결"

16 "대법원 1999. 11. 26. 선고 98다46259 판결"

17 Autry, Jhon, "Toward A Definition of Striking Similarity in Infringement Actions for Copyrighted Musical Works" (fall) : 2002

18 Lepera, Christine, "Music Plagiarism: A framework for litigation" (Summer) : 1997