주요논리 관점에서 본 소비자생활협동조합의 전략: 아이쿱생협의 공정무역 사업 사례연구 = A Consumer Co-operative`s Strategy from the Perspective of Dominant Logic : The Case of Fair Trade Business of iCOOP

국문 초록 (Abstract)

국내 소비자생활협동조합(이하 생협)은 국내 유기농 생산과 소비를 발전시키는데 중요한 역할을 했다. 그러나 해외 농식품 수입에 대해서는 의견 차이를 보이고 있다. 이는 공정무역(Fair Trade) 사업을 실행하는 사업전략에서 드러난다. 본 연구의 목적은 생협의 사업전략을 주요논리(dominant logic) 관점을 통해 설명하는 것이다. 주요논리라는 개념은 조직 전략, 구조, 시스템을 이루고 있는 근본 요소 같은 특성을 말한다. 이를 위해 사례연구방법(case study method)을 이용하여 국내 생협 중 가장 매출 규모가 큰 아이쿱생협의 공정무역 사업전략을 연구하였다. 아이쿱생협은 소비자중심과 협동조합중심이라는 두 가지 논리가 공정무역 사업의 전략, 가치, 성과에 결합되어 강화되거나, 공정무역이 가진 의미와 가치와 갈등을 나타내고 있다. 본 논문은 경영전략론의 새로운 연구모형인 주요논리 이론을 이용하여 협동조합 조직과 사업전략을 설명한다. 본 연구의 가치와 독창성은 한국 생협의 공정무역 사업을 경영전략론의 관점에서 연구한 것이다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Various perspectives on Fair Trade have been developed and are related to the business strategies of the players who participate in the Fair Trade market. Although consumer co-operatives have been important players in the mainstreaming of Fair Trade, limited research has been conducted with regard to their business practices. This study aims to investigate the Fair Trade business strategies of consumer co-operatives. A case study method was adopted to investigate Fair Trade businesses in iCOOP KOREA, the largest consumer co-operative in Korea. Among the various perspectives on management strategy theories, dominant logic provides a vantage view to describe interactive processes in strategy formulation and implementation. The dominant logic of iCOOP Korea, derived from the nature of consumer co-operatives, fits well in accounting for Fair Trade businesses with cooperative-centrism and consumption-centrism. The case of iCOOP Korea shows that the Fair Trade strategy has reinforced the dominant logic and that there are conflicts when an organization practices Fair Trade. This research provides insights to explain the different views and practices of Fair Trade players.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 신성식, "협동조합 다시 생각하기" 알마 2014

2 iCOOP생협연대, "협동, 생활의 윤리: 협동 생활의 윤리 iCOOP생협 10년사" 푸른나무 2008

3 (사)한국생협연대, "제9차 정기총회 자료집" 2004

4 생협연대, "제8차 정기총회 자료집" 2003

5 iCOOP소비자생활협동조합사업연합회, "제17차 정기총회 자료집" 2015

6 iCOOP소비자생활협동조합사업연합회, "제16차 대의원 정기총회 자료집" 2014

7 iCOOP소비자생활협동조합사업연합회, "제15차 대의원 정기총회 자료집" 2013

8 iCOOP소비자생활협동조합사업연합회, "제14차 대의원 정기총회 자료집" 2012

9 (사)iCOOP생협연대, "제13차 대의원총회 자료집" 2011

10 (사)한국생협연대, "제13차 대의원총회 자료집" 2008

11 (사)한국생협연대, "제12차 정기총회 자료집" 2007

12 (사)iCOOP생협연대, "제12차 대의원총회 자료집" 2010

13 iCOOP생협연합회, "제11차 정기총회 자료집" 2011

14 (사)한국생협연대, "제11차 정기총회 자료집" 2006

15 (사)iCOOP생협연대, "제11차 대의원총회 자료집" 2009

16 (사)한국생협연대, "제10차 정기총회 자료집" 2005

17 iCOOP소비자활동연합회, "이사코스 14차 교육자료집" 2014

18 이상훈, "윤리적 소비" 한국학술정보 2012

19 아이쿱협동조합연구소, "아이쿱생협 통계 2014" 2014

20 신성식, "새로운 생협운동의 미래" 푸른나무 2011

21 신성식, "당신의 쇼핑이 세상을 바꾼다: 사람을 살리는 협동조합기업의 힘" 알마 2013

22 김태연, "iCOOP생협의 공정무역 현황과 향후과제, In 포럼: 아이쿱생협의 공정무역 현황과 방향" 아이쿱협동조합연구소 2013

23 iCOOP생협사업연합회, "iCOOP생협 2013년 연차보고서" 2014

24 "http://www.fairtrade.net/fileadmin/user_upload/content/2009/resources/15-10_ Sustainable_Development_Report.pdf"

25 Doherty, B., "Where now for fair trade?" 1-29, 2012

26 Porter, M. E., "What is Strategy?" 61-78, 1996

27 Smith, A. M., "What does it mean to do fair trade? Ontology, praxis, and the Fair for Life certification system" 9 (9): 53-72, 2013

28 Reed, D., "What do corporations have to do with fair trade? Positive and normative analysis from a value chain perspective" 86 (86): 3-26, 2009

29 Hambrick, D. C., "Upper echelons: The organization as a reflection of its top managers" 9 (9): 193-206, 1984

30 Lippman, S. A., "Uncertain imitability: an analysis of interfirm differences in efficiency under competition" 13 (13): 418-438, 1982

31 Ocasio, W., "Towards an Attention-Based View of the Firm" 18 (18): 187-206, 1997

32 Bettis, R. A., "The new competitive landscape" 16 (16): 7-19, 1995

33 Prahalad, C. K., "The blinders of dominant logic" 37 (37): 171-179, 2004

34 Huybrechts, B., "The Governance of Fair Trade Social Enterprises in Belgium" 6 (6): 110-124, 2010

35 Moore, G., "The Fair Trade Movement: parameters, issues and future research" 53 (53): 73-86, 2004

36 Blettner, D. P., "The Evolution of Dominant Logic in Relation to Strategic Inertia in Software Ventures" St. Gallen University 2008

37 Becchetti, L., "The Dynamics of Fair Trade as a Mixed-Form Market" 81 (81): 733-750, 2008

38 Prahalad, C. K., "The Dominant Logic: a New Linkage Between Diversity and Performance" 7 : 485-501, 1986

39 Bettis, R. A., "The Dominant Logic : Retrospective and Extension" 16 (16): 5-14, 1995

40 Bettis, R. A., "The Blackwell handbook of organizational learning and knowledge management" 343-355, 2003

41 Fairtrade International, "Sustainable Development Goals and Fairtrade : the case for partnership" 2015

42 Prahalad, C. K., "Strategy as a Field of Study: Why Search for a New Paradigm?" 15 (15): 5-16, 1994

43 Mintzberg, H., "Strategy Safari: The Complete Guide Through the Wilds of Strategic Management" Pearson Education Limited 2009

44 Nicholls, A., "Strategic options in fair trade retailing" 30 (30): 6-17, 2002

45 Barney, J. B., "Strategic factor markets : Expectations, luck, and business strategy" 32 (32): 1231-1241, 1986

46 Birkinshaw, J., "Strategic Management" Edward Elgar Pub 2005

47 Alexander, A., "Rediscovering consumer-producer involvement:A network perspective on fair trade marketing" 40 (40): 1236-1253, 2006

48 Maxwell, J. A., "Qualitative research design: An interpretative approach"

49 Low, W., "Postcards from the edge : maintaining the ‘alternative’ character of fair trade" 13 (13): 143-153, 2005

50 Child, J., "Organization structure and strategies of control: A replication of the Aston study" 163-177, 1972

51 Nicholls, A., "Market-Driven Ethical Consumption" Sage Publications 2005

52 Ghoshal, S., "Linking Organizational Context and Managerial Action : The Dimensions of Quality of Management" 15 (15): 91-112, 1994

53 Porter, M. E., "How competitive forces shape strategy" 34-51, 1979

54 Rumelt, R. P., "How Much Does Industry Matter?" 12 (12): 1991

55 Porac, J. F., "Handbook of strategy and management" 165-181, 2002

56 Pettigrew, A. M., "Handbook of Strategy and Management" Sage Publications, Inc 2002

57 Bowman, E., "Handbook of Strategy and Management" SAGE Publications, Inc. 31-51, 2002

58 Le Velly, R., "Handbook of Research on Fair Trade" Edward Elgar Publishing 2015

59 Davenport, E., "From trust to compliance: accountability in the fair trade movement" 9 (9): 88-101, 2013

60 Barney, J. B., "Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage" 17 (17): 99-120, 1991

61 Bezençon, V., "Fair trade managerial practices: Strategy, organisation and engagement" 90 (90): 95-113, 2009

62 Raynolds, L. T., "Fair Trade: The Challenges of transforming Globalization" Routledge 15-32, 2007

63 Nicholls, A., "Fair Trade, Corporate Accountability and Beyond: Experiments in Globalizing Justice" Ashgate 93-119, 2010

64 Jaffee, D., "Fair Trade Standards, Corporate Participation, and Social Movement Responses in the United States" 92 : 267-285, 2010

65 Huybrechts, B., "Fair Trade Organizations and Social Enterprise: Social Innovation through Hybrid Organization Models" Routledge 2012

66 Hutchens, A., "Changing Big Business: The Globalisation of the Fair Trade Movement" Edward Elgar Publishing Limited 2009

67 Yin, R. K., "Case Study Research: Design and Methods" Sage Publications, Inc. 2009

68 Dierickx, I., "Asset Stock Accumulation and Sustainability of Competitive Advantage" 35 (35): 1504-1511, 1989

69 Murray, A. I., "A Contingency View Of Porter’s ‘Generic Strategies’" 13 : 390-400, 1988

70 World Fair Trade Organization, "A Charter of Fair Trade Principles"

71 권구혁, "21세기 매니지먼트 이론의뉴패러다임: 조직, 전략, 인사 이론 등 경영의 모든 것" 위즈덤하우스 2008

72 iCOOP협동조합연구소, "(제26회 후속교육 자료집)ICA 총회 및 해외 협동조합 연수 보고회" 2012