Deeper Integration or Wider Integration?: the case of Gulf Cooperation Council = Deeper Integration or Wider Integration?: the case of Gulf Cooperation Council

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

We empirically evaluate whether fostering trade partnership within the region is a better economic course of action for the Gulf Cooperation Council than engaging into preferential trade arrangements with well-established trade blocs outside the region. We use the 8.1 version of Global Trade Analysis Project to analyze four scenarios representing various Gulf Cooperation Council trade integration paths, taking into consideration the issue of non-Tariff Barriers and trade facilitation measures. Results indicate that the Gulf Cooperation Council gain from lifting tariffs and non-tariff barriers on trade with the Greater Arab Free Trade Area subgroups and with the European Union is limited unless such barrier lifting is complemented with trade facilitation measures. With trade facilitation, the full completion of Greater Arab Free Trade Area scenario yields the highest welfare gain for the Gulf Cooperation Council, while the Gulf Cooperation Council-European Union Free Trade Agreement scenario yields positive but smaller gain. The small gain with Gulf Cooperation Council-European Union scenario is explained by the negative terms of trade effects following trade liberalization. These results underscore the importance of deepening Greater Arab Free Trade Area’s scope through introduction of trade facilitation measures as well as measures beyond merchandize trade liberalization.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 WTO, "World Trade Report" 2015

2 Nugent, Jeffrey B, "Why does MENA trade so little?, Background paper to the MENA Development Report" World Bank 2002

3 Hoekman, B., "Trade policy, Trade Costs and Developing Country Trade" 39 : 2069-2079, 2011

4 Shepherd, Ben, "Trade costs in the Maghreb 2000-2009" 2011

5 WTO, "Trade and Public Policies: A Closer Look at Non-Tariff Measures in the 21st Century" World Trade 2012

6 ESCWA, "Trade Facilitation and Paperless Trade: Implementation Survey"

7 Houcine Boughanmi, "The Trade Potential of the Arab Gulf Cooperation Countries (GCC): A Gravity Model Approach" 경제통합연구소 23 (23): 42-56, 2008

8 Dennis, Allen, "The Impact of Regional Trade Agreements and Trade Facilitation in the Middle East North Africa Region" World Bank 2006

9 Boughanmi, H., "The Effects of Regional Trade Arrangements on Agri-food Trade: An Application of the Gravity Modeling Approach to the Arab Gulf Cooperation Countries" 5 : 46-62, 2009

10 Kerkela, Leena, "The Effect of Armington Structure on Welfare Evaluations in Global CGE-Models" 2008

11 Chen, M. X., "Standards and Export Decisions: Firm-level Evidence from Developing Countries" 7 : 501-523, 2008

12 Antimiani, A., "Regionalism versus Multilateralism: The Case of the European Union Trade Policy" 49 : 253-276, 2015

13 Fugazza, M., "Non-Tariffs Barriers in Computable General Equilibrium Modeling" UNCTAD

14 Minetti, R., "Non Tariff Measures. An Introductory Guide" 2014

15 Baldwin, R, "Multilateralizing Regionalism : Spaghetti Bowls as Building Blocs on the Path to Global Free Trade" 29 : 1451-1518, 2006

16 Al-Atrash, H., "Intra-Arab Trade: Is it too little?" IMF 2000

17 Hertel, T. W., "How Confident Can We Be of CGE-Based Assessments of Free Trade Agreements?" 24 : 611-635, 2007

18 Hertel, Thomas Warren, "Global Trade Analysis: Modeling and Applications" Cambridge University Press 2009

19 Kee, H., "Estimating Trade Restrictiveness Indices" 119 : 172-199, 2009

20 World Bank, "Economic integration in the GCC"

21 "EUROSTAT"

22 World Bank, "Doing business 2014"

23 UNESCAP, "Designing and implementing trade facilitation measures in Asia and the Pacific"

24 Hoekman, B., "Changes in Cross-Border Trade Costs in the Pan-Arab Free Trade Area, 2001-2008" World Bank 2009

25 ESCWA, "Assessing Arab Economic Integration: Towards the Arab Customs Union"

26 ESCWA, "Arab Integration: 21 Century Development imperative"

27 Malcolm, Gerard, "Adjusting Tax Rates in the GTAP Data Base" GTAP 1998