Human Dignity and the Ethics of Human Enhancement

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Human dignity supports the equal value of all humans and their ethical treatment. While human rights conventions use the term frequently, it is rarely defined. The term dignity is used differently, and two dimensions are described in detail. Inherent dignity is an intrinsic dimension held by all humans and is the basis of equal rights for all humans. Circumstantial dignity is another dimension, but is variable and changeable. This is in mind when circumstances are said to enhance or diminish someone’s dignity. The recent critique of dignity arises in part because of conflation of these two dimensions. Others reject dignity because of its religious connections. Such criticisms will be responded to in defense of dignity.
Posthuman and transhuman enhancement also raise questions about the value of dignity because of its roots in humanism. Nick Bostrom defends posthuman dignity while critiquing Leon Kass’s bioconservative position. Bostrom’s argument will be critiqued because of his failure to distinguish between inherent and circumstantial dignity, and his misunderstanding of Kass’s claims.
In contrast to the transhumanist enhancement project, inherent dignity points to the givenness and limitations of human nature. This indicates the importance of developing gratitude for human nature and avoiding an endless pursuit of perfection. Such an approach is not antagonistic to medicine and science. Instead, it places priority on improving the circumstantial dignity of all human beings, especially those who live without their basic needs being met. Their inherent dignity places a moral obligation on those with resources to help them. Medicine and science should focus on relieving their needs, not enhancing those who already have most needs met. Justice for all humans based on their inherent dignity is proposed as a significant argument against the ethics of transhuman enhancement.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• I. Introduction
• II. Dignity’s Dimensions
• III. Recent Critique of Human Dignity
• 1) Lack of Clarity
• 2) Religious Objection
• 3) Posthuman Critique
• IV. Posthumanism and Transhumanism
• 1) Posthuman Dignity
• V. Critics of Transhuman Enhancement
• 1) Bostrom’s Response to Fear of Loss of Dignity
• 2) Bostrom’s Response to Fear of Discrimination
• V. Conclusion
• Works Cited
• Abstract

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Wolfe, Cary, "What is Posthumanism" University of Minnesota Press

2 UNESCO, "Universal Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights"

3 United Nations, "Universal Declaration of Human Rights"

4 Bostrom, Nick, "Two Hundred Years After Kant, Fifty Years After Turing" Ria University Press 339-371, 2004

5 Cheshire, William, "Toward a Common Language of Human Dignity" 18 (18): 7-10, 2002

6 Habermas, Jürgen, "Time of Transitions" Polity 2006

7 Pinker, Steven, "The Stupidity of Dignity"

8 O’Mathúna, Dónal P., "The Place of Dignity in Everyday Ethics" 28 (28): 12-18, 2011

9 Lee, Patrick, "The Nature and Basis of Human Dignity" 21 (21): 173-193, 2008

10 Hawthorne, Nathaniel, "The Birth-Mark, In President’s Council on Bioethics" President’s Council on Bioethics

11 O’Mathúna, Dónal P, "Taking a Precautionary Approach to Nanotechnology" 1 (1): 26-30, 2011

12 Annas, George J., "Science Fiction and Philosophy:From Time Travel to Superintelligence" Wiley-Blackwell 227-240, 2009

13 Horton, Richard, "Rediscovering Human Dignity" 364 : 1081-1085, 2004

14 Sulmasy, Daniel P, "Perspectives on Human Dignity: A Conversation" Springer 9-18, 2007

15 Lewis, Milton, "Perspectives on Human Dignity: A Conversation" Springer 93-105, 2007

16 Bostrom, Nick, "New Waves in Applied Ethics" Palgrave Macmillan 120-152, 2007

17 Meilaender, Gilbert, "Neither Beast nor God: The Dignity of the Human Person" Encounter Books 2009

18 O’Mathúna, Dónal P., "Nanoethics: Big Ethical Issues with Small Technology" Continuum Press 2009

19 Bostrom, Nick, "Medical Enhancement and Posthumanity" Springer 107-136, 2008

20 United Nations, "International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights"

21 United Nations, "International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and International Covenant"

22 Warwick, Kevin, "In the Mind of the Machine"

23 Bostrom, Nick, "In Defense of Human Dignity" 19 (19): 202-214, 2005

24 Seidel, Asher, "Immortal Passage: Philosophical Speculations on Posthuman Evolution" Rowman & Littlefield 2010

25 Kateb, George, "Human Dignity" Harvard University Press 2011

26 "Global Health Workforce Alliance. Adding Value to Health"

27 Pico della Mirandola, "Giovanni. Oration on the Dignity of Man"

28 Beckwith, Francis J, "Dignity Never Been Photographed: Scientific Materialism, Enlightenment Liberalism, and Steven Pinker" 26 (26): 93-110, 2010

29 Macklin, Ruth, "Dignity Is a Useless Concept" 327 : 1419-1420, 2003

30 Zylinska, Joanna, "Bioethics in the Age of New Media" MIT Press 2009

31 Kass, Leon, "Ageless Bodies, Happy Souls: Biotechnology and the Pursuit of Perfection" 1 : 9-28, 2003