A Multilevel Analysis of the Chinese Super League: Examining the Game Level and Home Team Level Determinants of Stadium Attendance

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The Chinese Super League (CSL) is the top tier football league in China and over the past 10 years has expanded rapidly in terms of popularity, brand strength, and name recognition. Despite the CSL’s rapid development, limited empirical research has been done to examine the league and what drives demand in attending the games. Thus, in order to gain a better understanding of CSL and identify unique patterns of demand for professional sports leagues in China, this study used data from the 2017–2019 CSL regular seasons to examine the relationship between various stadium determinants and game attendance. Moreover, the nested structure found in attendance data was considered, thus adopting multilevel modeling (MLM) to analyze game level and home team level variables to predict stadium attendance in the CSL. Our findings reveal that 12 variables significantly influenced attendance, with variables related to home teams showing more relevance to explaining stadium attendance than game level variables.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Haffner, A, "What China’s Football Reform Plan means for China and the global sports industry" LawInSport

2 Howell, S. M., "Weather, timing, and promotions in minor league baseball : An examination of attendance in the international league" 7 (7): 1-15, 2015

3 Tabachnick, B. G., "Using multivariate statistics" Pearson 2012

4 Sandercock, L., "Up where, cazaly?: The great Australian game" HarperCollins Publishers 1982

5 Buraimo, B., "Uncertainty of outcome or star quality? Television audience demand for English Premier League Football" 22 (22): 449-469, 2015

6 Coates, D., "Ticket prices, concessions and attendance at professional sporting events" 2 : 161-170, 2007

7 Funk, D. C., "The psychological continuum model : A conceptual framework for understanding an individual’s psychological connection to sport" 4 (4): 119-150, 2001

8 AFC, "The most popular football clubs: China PR" The-AFC

9 Wang, C., "The impact of the soccer schedule on TV viewership and stadium attendance : Evidence from the Belgian Pro League" 19 (19): 82-112, 2016

10 Watanabe, N. M., "The impact of race relations on NFL attendance:An econometric analysis" 15 (15): e0226938-, 2020

11 Wakefield, K. L., "The effects of team loyalty and selected stadium factors on spectator attendance" 9 (9): 153-172, 1995

12 Szymanski, S., "The economic design of sporting contests" 41 (41): 1137-1187, 2003

13 Valenti, M., "The determinants of stadium attendance in elite women’s football : Evidence from the UEFA Women’s Champions League" 23 (23): 509-520, 2020

14 García, J., "The determinants of football match attendance revisited : Empirical evidence from the Spanish Football League" 3 (3): 18-38, 2002

15 Hayley Jang ; Young Hoon Lee, "Testing the Uncertainty of Outcome Hypothesis in Football Leagues: An Application of Italian Football League" 글로벌지식마케팅경영학회 7 (7): 529-545, 2022

16 Tainsky, S., "Television broadcast demand for national football league contests" 11 (11): 629-640, 2010

17 Pawlowski, T., "Stadium attendance in German professional football –the(un)importance of uncertainty of outcome reconsidered" 19 (19): 1553-1556, 2012

18 Schreyer, D., "Stadium attendance demand research: A scoping review" 23 (23): 749-788, 2022

19 Reade, J. J., "Stadium attendance demand during the Covid-19 crisis : Early empirical evidence from Belarus" 28 (28): 1542-1547, 2020

20 Buraimo, B., "Stadium attendance and television audience demand in English league football" 29 (29): 513-523, 2008

21 Villar, J. G., "Sports attendance : A survey of the literature 1973–2007" 5 (5): 111-151, 2009

22 Tsiotsou, R. H., "Sport team loyalty : Integrating relationship marketing and a hierarchy of effects" 27 (27): 458-471, 2013

23 Uhrich, S., "Sport stadium atmosphere : Formative and reflective indicators for operationalizing the construct" 24 (24): 211-237, 2010

24 Kim, M. J., "Sport consumers motivation for live attendance and mediated sports consumption : A qualitative analysis" 24 (24): 515-533, 2021

25 Ermakov, S., "Saturday in the stadium : On higher attendance on Saturdays in Norwegian Eliteserien soccer league" 2022

26 Hill, B., "Repeat attendance as a function of involvement, loyalty, and the sportscape across three football contexts" 3 (3): 145-162, 2000

27 Lim, N., "Predictive analysis of the attendance determinants of the national basketball association a hierarchical linear regression modeling" 13 (13): 209-224, 2019

28 Schofield, J., "Performance and attendance at professional team sports" 6 (6): 196-206, 1983

29 Forrest, D., "Outcome uncertainty and attendance demand in sport : The case of English soccer" 51 (51): 229-241, 2002

30 Swanson, S. R., "Motivations of college student game attendance and word-of-mouth behavior : The impact of gender differences" 12 (12): 151-162, 2003

31 Clapp, C. M., "How long a honeymoon? The effect of new stadiums on attendance in Major League Baseball" 6 (6): 237-263, 2005

32 Statista, "Highest paid football players in Chinese Super League (soccer)2020"

33 Todd, S. Y., "Hierarchical linear modeling of multilevel data" 19 (19): 387-403, 2005

34 Shuyang Liu ; James Skinner ; Anna Grosman, "From Rags to Riches: Business Model Innovation Shifts in the Ecosystem of the Chinese Super League" 글로벌지식마케팅경영학회 7 (7): 406-426, 2022

35 Hansen, H., "Factors affecting attendance at professional sport events" 3 (3): 15-32, 1989

36 Beckman, E. M., "Explaining game-to-game ticket sales for major league baseball games over time" 13 (13): 536-553, 2012

37 Serrano, R., "Expected quality in European football attendance : Market value and uncertainty reconsidered" 22 (22): 1051-1054, 2015

38 Namhun Lim ; Paul M. Pedersen, "Examining Determinants of Sport Event Attendance: A Multilevel Analysis of a Major League Baseball Season" 글로벌지식마케팅경영학회 7 (7): 181-198, 2022

39 Sung, H., "Estimation of game-level attendance in major league soccer : Outcome uncertainty and absolute quality considerations" 21 (21): 519-532, 2018

40 Lemke, R. J., "Estimating attendance at major league baseball games for the 2007 season" 11 (11): 316-348, 2010

41 Yang Ma ; Markus Kurscheidt, "Doing It the Chinese Way: The Politically-led Commercialization of Professional Football in China" 글로벌지식마케팅경영학회 7 (7): 355-371, 2022

42 Li, B., "Does star power boost soccer match attendance? Empirical evidence from the Chinese soccer league" 14 : 97-109, 2019

43 Kringstad, M., "Does live broadcasting reduce stadium attendance? The case of Norwegian football" 8 (8): 67-81, 2018

44 Gitter, S. R., "Determinants of minor league baseball attendance" 11 (11): 614-628, 2010

45 Ryu, Y., "Determinants of audience demand for the televised professional baseball matches in Korea" 20 (20): 184-202, 2019

46 Borland, J., "Demand for sport" 19 (19): 478-502, 2003

47 Pawlowski, T., "Competition format, championship uncertainty and stadium attendance in European football – a small league perspective" 47 (47): 4128-4139, 2015

48 Watanabe, N., "Chinese super league: Attendance, pricing, and team performance" 7 (7): 157-174, 2017

49 Seungbum Lee ; Suyeon No, "China’s Overseas Financial Direct Investment (ODI) in European Football Clubs: Revisiting ODI in the Context of Sport Industry" 글로벌지식마케팅경영학회 7 (7): 391-405, 2022

50 CEIC, "China average working hours per week"

51 Kong, H. C. C, "China Wants to Become a “Soccer Superpower” by 2050" Time

52 Paul, R., "Attendance in the Canadian hockey league : The impact of winning, fighting, uncertainty of outcome, and weather on junior hockey attendance" 7 (7): 12-, 2019

53 Buraimo, B., "Attendance demand in a developing football market : The case of the Peruvian first division" 18 (18): 671-686, 2018

54 Noll, R. G., "Attendance and price setting, Vol. 2" Edward Elgar Publishing Limited 166-207, 2002

55 Ge, Q., "Are fair weather fans affected by weather? Rainfall, habit formation, and live game attendance" 21 (21): 304-322, 2020

56 Yoshida, M., "An integrated model for stadium atmosphere and stadium attachment : An empirical test in two baseball stadium contexts" 30 (30): 95-110, 2021

57 Howard, D. R., "An empirical review of the stadium novelty effect" 12 (12): 111-116, 2003

58 Lewis, M., "An empirical examination of the development and impact of star power in major league baseball" 19 (19): 155-187, 2018

59 Watanabe, N. M., "Air pollution and attendance in the Chinese super league : Environmental economics and the demand for sport" 33 (33): 289-302, 2019

60 Schreyer, D., "Against all odds? Exploring the role of game outcome uncertainty in season ticket holders’ stadium attendance demand" 56 : 192-217, 2016

61 Buraimo, B., "A tale of two audiences : Spectators, television viewers and outcome uncertainty in Spanish football" 61 (61): 326-338, 2009

62 Peugh, J. L., "A practical guide to multilevel modeling" 48 (48): 85-112, 2010

63 Lee, S., "A new approach to stadium experience : The dynamics of the sensoryscape, social interaction, and sense of home" 26 (26): 490-505, 2012

64 Ferreira, M., "A multilevel model analysis of professional soccer attendance in Chile 1990–2002" 8 (8): 49-66, 2007