Participatory Assessment of urban land uses: a map-based voting approach

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Urban land uses determined solely based on experts’ opinions, perspectives, expertise and desires may not meet local people’s needs and may be subject to conflict and opposition. Some of the stakeholders may fully agree with the current expert-based land uses and some may completely disagree. This study presents a systematic map-based voting approach to select the best uses for the lands based on the stakeholders’ preferences and compare them with current expert-oriented land uses. The proposed method was utilized for assessing the uses of urban land parcels in District # 15 of Tehran, Iran. The results show that the participatory and expert-driven land uses are different for six parcels out of ten, which implies that the land use preferences of the local stakeholders/citizens are not compatible with that of the experts for all of the land parcels.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Municipality of Tehran, "Which areas of the capital have the lowest per capita green space"

2 Simao, A, "Web-based GIS for collaborative planning and public participation : An application to the strategic planning of wind farm sites" 90 (90): 2027-2040, 2009

3 Mahmoody Vanolya, N, "Validation of spatial multicriteria decision analysis results using public participation GIS" 112 : 102061-, 2019

4 Ives, C. D, "Using social data in strategic environmental assessment to conserve biodiversity" 47 : 332-341, 2015

5 Brown, G, "Using public participatory mapping to inform general land use planning and zoning" 177 : 64-74, 2018

6 Adams, V. M, "Using optimal land-use scenarios to assess trade-offs between conservation, development, and social values" 11 (11): e0158350-, 2016

7 Arciniegas Lopez, G, "Using a touch table to support participatory land use planning" 13-17, 2009

8 Hassan, A. M, "Toward the sustainable development of urban areas : An overview of global trends in trials and policies" 48 : 199-212, 2015

9 Bourgoin, J, "Toward a land zoning negotiation support platform : ‘‘Tips and tricks’’ for participatory land use planning in Laos" 104 (104): 270-278, 2012

10 Brown, G, "The relationship between place attachment and landscape values: Toward mapping place attachment" 27 (27): 89-111, 2007

11 Reed, M. S, "Stakeholder participation for environmental management: A literature review" 141 (141): 2417-2431, 2008

12 Tudor, C. A, "Similarities and differences in the assessment of land-use associations by local people and experts" 49 : 341-351, 2015

13 Kaminska, O, "Satisficing among reluctant respondents in a cross-national context" 74 (74): 956-984, 2010

14 Nha, D, "Redefining diversity & dynamics of natural resources management in Asia Vol. 2" Elsevier 87-111, 2017

15 Brown, G, "Public participation GIS: A method for identifying ecosystem services" 25 (25): 633-651, 2012

16 Government of Canada, "Public Participation Guide"

17 Pocewicz, A, "Preferences of Wyoming residents for siting of energy and residential development" 43 : 45-55, 2013

18 Karimi, A, "Planning for the future : Combining spatially-explicit public preferences with tenure policies to support land-use planning" 82 : 497-508, 2019

19 Perminova, T, "Methods for land use impact assessment : A review" 60 : 64-74, 2016

20 Brown, G, "Methods for identifying land use conflict potential using participatory mapping" 122 : 196-208, 2014

21 Boroushaki, S, "Measuring consensus for collaborative decision-making: A GIS-based approach" 34 (34): 322-332, 2010

22 Jelokhani-Niaraki, M, "Knowledge sharing in Web-based collaborative multicriteria spatial decision analysis: An ontologybased multi-agent approach" 72 : 104-123, 2018

23 Municipality of Tehran, "Installation of 17 mechanized public parking facilities in District # 15"

24 Khaleghi, S.M, "Identifying the most important land use in sustainable urban neighborhoods of area 1in District 15 of Tehran" 2014

25 Moore, S. A, "Identifying conflict potential in a coastal and marine environment using participatory mapping" 197 : 706-718, 2017

26 De Smith, M. J, "Geospatial analysis: a comprehensive guide to principles, techniques and software tools" Troubador Publishing Ltd 2018

27 Mirkhani, "Geography and Urban Planning" 2007

28 Jankowski, P, "Geographic information science" Taylor & Francis 2001

29 Terh, S. H, "GIS-MCDA based cycling paths planning : A case study in Singapore" 94 : 107-118, 2018

30 Khamene, B.M, "Evaluation of public satisfaction with public welfare services in urban land use system (Case Study: Districts 14, 15 and 16 of Tehran Municipality)" 2015

31 Brown, G. G, "Escaping the national forest planning quagmire : Using public participation GIS to assess acceptable national forest use" 111 (111): 115-125, 2013

32 Brown, G, "Empirical PPGIS/PGIS mapping of ecosystem services : A review and evaluation" 13 : 119-133, 2015

33 Jelokhani-Niaraki, M, "Decision complexity and consensus in Web-based spatial decision making: A case study of site selection problem using GIS and multicriteria analysis" 45 : 60-70, 2015

34 Feick, R. D, "Consensus building in a multiparticipant spatial decision support system" 11 (11): 17-23, 1999

35 Brody, S. D, "Conflict on the coast : Using geographic information systems to map potential environmental disputes in Matagorda Bay Texas" 34 (34): 11-25, 2004

36 Karimi, A, "Assessing multiple approaches for modelling land-use conflict potential from participatory mapping data" 67 : 253-267, 2017

37 Engen, S, "Assessing local acceptance of protected area management using public participation GIS(PPGIS)" 43 : 27-34, 2018

38 Zeng, C, "Administrative restructuring and land-use intensity—A spatial explicit perspective" 2017 (2017): 190-199, 2017

39 Jelokhani-Niaraki, M, "A web-based public participation GIS for assessing the age-friendliness of cities: A case study in Tehran" 95 : 102471-, 2019

40 Wu, H, "A virtual globe-based 3D visualization and interactive framework for public participation in urban planning processes" 34 (34): 291-298, 2010

41 Kondo, M. C, "A random spatial sampling method in a rural developing nation" 14 (14): 338-, 2014

42 Gorsevski, P. V, "A group-based spatial decision support system for wind farm site selection in Northwest Ohio" 55 : 374-385, 2013

43 Jelokhani-Niaraki, M, "A group multicriteria spatial decision support system for parking site selection problem : A case study" 42 : 492-508, 2015

44 Herrera-Viedma, E, "A consensus model for multiperson decision making with different preference structures" 32 (32): 394-402, 2002

45 Omidipoor, M, "A GIS-based decision support system for facilitating participatory urban renewal process" 88 : 104150-, 2019