Evaluation of accuracy of different elastomeric materials in open tray implant level technique for single tooth impressions

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: This study compared the accuracy of different elastomeric impression materials with open tray implant level impression technique in a single-tooth replacement.
Materials and Methods: A reference model representing a single implant with an adjacent simulated natural tooth was fabricated. Open tray implant level impressions were made with vinylpolysiloxane (light body ExpressXT, PentaputtyPentamix2, 3MESPE, Seinfield, Germany) (Group I, n=10) and polyether (medium body Impregnum Penta, Pentamix 2, 3MESPE, Seinfield, Germany), (Group II, n=10) and implant crowns were fabricated on each master cast from their respective impressions by CNC milling and connected to the reference model with 35 Ncm torque. The accuracy of the fit was evaluated by measuring the interface gap between the implant crown and the implant replica at the mesial and distal points and by measuring the proximal gap between the implant crown and the simulated natural tooth at the buccal and the palatal points by scanning electron microscopy for each test sample. The mean values were obtained and statistically analyzed using a Mann-Whitney test.
Results: The interface gap observed at the mesial point was significantly higher than the distal point. The proximal gap observed at the palatal point was significantly higher than the buccal point for both Group I and Group II. A comparison of the groups showed that the interface gap at the mesial point and the proximal gap at the buccal and palatal points obtained from polyether impression material were lower than those observed with vinylpolysiloxane group, but the difference was not significant. However, the interface gap observed at the distal point was higher with the polyether group than with the vinylpolysiloxane group, but the difference was not significant.
Conclusions: Polyether and vinylpolysiloxane can be used to produce open tray implant impressions for a single missing tooth.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Takahashi T, "fit of implant frameworks : an in vitro comparison between two fabrication techniques" 89 : 256-260, 2003

2 Ortorp A, "comparisons of precision of fit between cast and CNC milled titanium implant frameworks for the edentulous mandible" 16 : 194-200, 2003

3 Sahin S, "The significance of passive framework fit in implant prosthodontics : Current status" 10 : 85-92, 2001

4 Binon PP, "The effect of implant/abutment hexagonal misfit on screw joint stability" 9 : 149-160, 1996

5 De Torres EM, "The effect of commercially pure titanium and alternative dental alloys on the marginal fit of one-piece cast implant framework" 35 : 800-805, 2007

6 De Torres EM, "The effect of commercially pure titanium and alternative dental alloys on the marginal fit of one-piece cast implant framework" 35 : 800-805, 2007

7 Barret MG, "The accuracy of six impression techniques for osseointegrated implants" 2 : 75-82, 1993

8 Humphries RM, "The accuracy of implant master casts constructed from transfer impressions" 5 : 331-336, 1990

9 Lee H, "The accuracy of implant impressions : A systematic review" 100 : 285-291, 2008

10 Craig RG, "Restorative dental materials" CV Mosby 293-246, 1989

11 Barbosa S, "Relation between implant/abutment vertical misfit and torque loss of abutment screws" 19 : 358-363, 2008

12 Anusavice KJ, "Phillip's Science of Dental Materials" Saunders 2003

13 Hussaini S, "One clinical visit for multiple implant restoration mast cast fabrication" 78 : 550-553, 1997

14 Jemt T, "Measuring fit at the Implant prosthodontic interface" 75 : 314-325, 1996

15 Kanawati A, "Measurement of clinicians'ability to hand torque dental implant components" 35 : 185-188, 2009

16 Vigolo P, "Master cast accuracy in singletooth implant replacement cases: An in vitro comparison. A technical note" 20 : 455-460, 2005

17 Tsuge T, "Marginal fit and microgaps of implant-abutment interface with internal anti-rotation configuration" 27 : 29-34, 2008

18 Vigolo P, "In vitro comparison of master cast accuracy of single tooth implant replacement" 83 : 562-566, 2000

19 Chee W, "Impression techniques for implant dentistry" 201 : 429-432, 2006

20 Nissan J, "Impression technique for partially edentulous patients" 88 : 103-104, 2002

21 Walker P, "Implant cast accuracy as a function of impression techniques and impression material viscosity" 23 : 669-674, 2008

22 Jemt T, "Failures and complications in 391 consecutively inserted fixed prostheses supported by Branemark implant in the edentulous jaw a study of treatment from the time of prostheses placement to the first annual check up" 6 : 270-276, 1991

23 Inturregui JA, "Evaluation of three impression techniques for osseointegrates oral implants" 69 : 503-509, 1993

24 Ozkan Y, "Evaluation of the methods used for impression making for different implant systems in prosthetic dentistry" 9 : 21-33, 2006

25 Choi JH, "Evaluation of the accuracy of implant-level impression techniques for internal-connection implant prostheses in parallel and divergent models" 22 : 761-768, 2007

26 Faria de, "Evaluation of the accuracy of different transfer impression techniques for multiple implants" 25 : 163-167, 2011

27 Faria de, "Evaluation of the accuracy of different transfer impression techniques for multiple implants" 25 : 163-167, 2011

28 Amer A, "Evaluation of some factors that may affect the accuracy of implant transfer impression" 2 : 219-226, 2009

29 Hariharan R, "Evaluation of accuracy of multiple dental implant impressions using various splinting materials" 25 : 38-44, 2010

30 조시훈 ; 김경일 ; 서재민 ; 송광엽 ; 박주미 ; 안승근, "Effect of impression coping and implant angulation on the accuracy of implant impressions: an in vitro study" 대한치과보철학회 2 (2): 128-133, 2010

31 Sorrentino R, "Effect of implant angulation, connection length, and impression material on the dimensional accuracy of implant impressions : An in vitro comparative study" 12 : 63-76, 2010

32 Kim S, "Displacement of implant components from impressions to definitive casts" 21 : 747-755, 2006

33 Kleinberg IJ, "Design of superstructures for osseointegrated fixtures" 28 : 63-68, 1985

34 Moseley P, "Custom impression trays : Part III Mechanical properties" 71 : 31-34, 1994

35 Kim JH, "Critical appraisal of implant impression accuracies : A systematic review" 114 : 185-192, 2015

36 Lorenzoni M, "Comparison of the transfer precision of three different impression materials in combination with transfer caps for the Frialit-2 system" 27 : 629-638, 2000

37 Carr AB, "Comparison of impression techniques for a two-implant 15 degree divergent model" 7 : 468-475, 1992

38 Carr AB, "Comparison of impression techniques for a five implant mandibular model" 6 : 448-455, 1991

39 Wee AG, "Comparison of impression materials for direct multi-implant impressions" 83 : 323-331, 2000

40 Cabral M, "Comparison analysis of 4 impression techniques for implants" 16 : 1-9, 2007

41 Kan K, "Clinical method for evaluating implant framework fit" 81 : 7-13, 1999

42 Ren S, "Changes in proximal contact tightness between fixed implant prostheses and adjacent teeth : A 1-year prospective study" 115 : 437-440, 2016

43 Daoudi MF, "An evaluation of three implant level impression techniques for single tooth implant" 12 : 9-14, 2004

44 Spector MR, "An evaluation of impression techniques for osseointegrated implants" 63 : 444-447, 1990

45 Vigolo P, "An evaluation of impression techniques for multiple internal connection implant prostheses" 92 : 470-476, 2004

46 Conrad J, "Accuracy of two impression techniques with angulated implants" 97 : 349-356, 2007

47 Prithiviraj R, "Accuracy of the implant impression obtained from different impression materials and technique : Review" 3 : 106-111, 2011

48 Hung H, "Accuracy of one-step versus twostep putty wash addition silicone impression technique" 67 : 583-589, 1992

49 Jang HK, "Accuracy of impressions for internalconnection implant prostheses with various divergent angles" 26 : 1011-1015, 2011

50 Wenz HJ, "Accuracy of impressions and casts using different implant impression techniques in a multi – implant system with an internal hex connection" 23 : 39-47, 2008

51 Assuncao WG, "Accuracy of impression techniques for implants. Part 1- Influence of transfer copings surface abrasion" 17 : 641-647, 2008

52 Del'Acqua MA, "Accuracy of impression and pouring techniques for an implant supported prosthesis" 23 : 226-236, 2008

53 Rashidan N, "Accuracy of implant impressions with different impression coping types and shapes" 14 : 218-225, 2012

54 Assif D, "Accuracy of implant impression techniques" 11 : 216-222, 1996

55 이상직 ; 조성범, "Accuracy of five implant impression technique: effect of splinting materials and methods" 대한치과보철학회 3 (3): 177-185, 2011

56 Lee J, "Accuracy of different impression techniques for internal-connection implants" 24 : 823-830, 2009

57 Daoudi MF, "A laboratory Investigation of the accuracy of two impression techniques for single – tooth implants" 14 : 152-158, 2001

58 Hsu CC, "A comparative analysis of the accuracy of implant transfer techniques" 69 : 588-593, 1993