미국법상 복수 주체에 의한 특허권 침해책임의 귀속법리에 관한 소고 : Akamai v. Limelight 사건 판결을 소재로

전수정,전성태 梨花女子大學校 法學硏究所 2016 法學論集 Vol.21 No.2

특허제도는 당해 특허발명의 모든 구성요소(클레임)를 실시하여야 특허침해가 성립한다는 ‘구성요소완비의 원칙(all elements rule)’을 채용하고 있다. 그런데 방법발명의 경우 복수주체가 특허발명의 구성요소를 일부씩 분담하여 실시하지만, 이들 각각의 실시를 합하면 당해 발명의 모든 구성요소를 실시하게 되는 경우 누구에게 어떠한 책임을 물어야 할 것인지가 문제되었다. 특히 미국에서는‘구성요소완비의 원칙’에서 파생된 특허의 클레임된 모든 요소가 단일주체에 의해 실시되어야 한다는 단일개체이론에 따라, 각 복수 주체간의 관계성에 주목하여 직접침해의 하나의 형태로서 공동침해의 성립요건이 논의되어 왔다. 특히 최근 미국은 복수 주체에 의한 공동침해에 관한 다양한 판례와 학설이 전개되고 있었으나, 일련의 Akamai Technologies, Inc. v. Limelight Networks, Inc. 사건을 통해서 어느 정도 정리되었다. 이글은 미국 특허권 침해의 적용법리인 보통법상의 불법행위책임과 특허법상의 침해책임 법리를 개관해 보고, Akamai Technologies, Inc.v. Limelight Networks, Inc. 사건을 분석하였다. 이를 통해 미국의 특허법상 공동침해법리의 전개방향을 살펴, 현행 미국에서의 특허권 공동침해에 대한 적용법리 및 해석 기준을 고찰하였다. 결론적으로 미국에서 복수 주체에 의한 특허권 침해책임에 대한 규율 법리는 유형적으로 첫째 복수 주체 중 특정 주체가 ‘지시 또는 통제’라는 지배력을 가지고 있는 경우, 둘째 ‘공동사업’ 관계와 같이 복수 주체 상호간에 서로 대등한 관계에 있는 경우로 나누어 판단되고 있음을 알 수 있다. 결국 미국의 특허침해책임의 법원인 불법행위법상 대위책임과 공동사업책임 법리가 미국 특허법 제271조(a)의 특허권 직접침해책임의 적용에 있어서 하나의 해석기준이 되고 있다고 할 것이다. 여기서 미국의 논의는 우리에게 다음과 같은 시사를 준다고 할 수 있다. 첫째, 특허법의 제원칙인 구성요소완비의 원칙은 단일한 자에 의해 클레임의 모든 구성요소가 실시되어야 하는 것은 아니라 클레임의 모든 구성요소가 실시되는 것으로 충분하다는 점, 둘째, 미국과 마찬가지로 우리나라에서도 특허법상의 침해책임법리만으로는 해결하기 어려운 복수 주체에 의한 공동침해책임에 있어 전통적인 불법행위법을 책임의 근거로 삼을 수 있다는 점이다. The term "patent” refers to a legal right generated to protect a person who creates a new technical idea to contribute to industrial innovation. The patent rights are only assigned to an invention evaluated as a new, useful, and industrial applicability through a series of procedures such as application, examination, and registration. The acquisition of patent rights means that a patentee has an exclusive right to practice his/her patented invention and that the said patentee has the legal authority to prohibit others from practicing his/her invented invention. In other words, a patentee acquires a monopolistic and exclusive right in his/her invention. In addition, the Patent Act recognizes injunction (Article 126 of the Patent Act) and compensation for damages (Article 750 of the Civil Act, Article 128 of the Patent Act) in order to guarantee the patentee's rights. Meanwhile, the single entity rule has been understood as a rule that was derived from the all elements rule and the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit established in the BMC case (Resources, Inc. v. Paymentech, L.P. 498 F. 3d 1373 (Fed. Cir. 2007)). In addition, this rule has been understood as the single biggest obstacle to the recognition of joint patent infringement by joint entity or multiple actors. However, the fact that the ground of the single entity rule is indefinite was also confirmed through the US precedents or the literal interpretation of Article 271(a) of the US patent law. Also, this rule was denied during a rehearing of the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in the Akamai case. The all elements rule is applied to determine if direct infringement occurred by comparing the elements of claim in a patented invention and in an accused invention. Thus, it was verified that there is no ground to assume in applying this rule and that only a single entity shall practice all elements in a claim.

폐경기여성에서 시청각 교육이 호르몬대체요법의 시행과 골다공증관련 생활습관의 변화에 미치는 효과

정태흠,전태희,김문찬,김영일,전대준,양승오,함수연,고병균,김성률 大韓家庭醫學會 2000 Korean Journal of Family Medicine Vol.21 No.11

A Case of Pneumatosis Cystoides Intestinalis in an Allogenic Stem Cell Transplant Recipient Who had Bronchiolitis Obliterans and Pulmonary Infection by Mtcobacterium abscessus

김윤정,전은경,조병식,최수미,이석,민창기,신완식 대한감염학회 2008 감염과 화학요법 Vol.40 No.5

Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) can cause various complications involving lung, liver intestine and other organs, Chemotherapy, radiation therapy, and graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) may injure the cells in the intestinal mucosa of HSCT recipients. Pneumatosis cystoides intestinalis (PI) is a condition that presence of air in the bowel wall is demonstrated by radiologic or pathologic tests, It is one of the infrequent complications after HSCT and is associated with several medical and surgical conditions. However its pathogenesis and definite etiologic factors are still unknown. Here, we present a case of PI in a HSCT recipient, who was diagnosed of bronchiolitis obliterance accompanied with chronic GVHD and pulmonary disease caused by Mycobacterium abscessus.

남성화를 보이는 여성에서 발견된 난소의 Steroid Cell Tumor 1예

조인호,정대훈,박영미,서영진,손영실,정철회,강영미,정수전,김영남,이경복,성문수,김기태 인제대학교 2006 仁濟醫學 Vol.27 No.-

Steroid cell tumor is a rare ovarian sex cord-stromal tumor which accounts for 0.1% of all ovarian tumors. Until now, only 4 cases have been reported in domestic literatures. Steroid cell tumor often secrets testosterone and presents virilization in adult women or precocious puberty in children. Treatment is often performed by surgical removal, adjuvant chemotherapy and radiation, but completely accepted treatment was not existed. We experienced a case of steroid cell tumor, which was manifested by typical virilization in a 43-year old patient, who was previously performed hysterectomy and unilateral oophorectomy. So, we present with a brief review of the literatures.

수도권 지역 대학병원과 재활병원의 인턴물리치료사간 인턴 만족도 비교

강순희,전수진,정민현,정은송,이범승,최용진 韓國交通大學校 2013 한국교통대학교 논문집 Vol.48 No.-

The purpose of this study was to compare internship satisfaction of intern physical therapists working in the university hospitals with that of them working in the rehabilitation hospitals in Seoul metropolitan area. The questionnaire for internship satisfaction survey that amended from vocational interest test [Strong Interest Inventory(SII)] was used to examine satisfaction of intern physical therapists and the questionnaire was used to ask general characteristics, educational and work environment. Thirty nine intern physical therapists working in university hospital and fifty nine intern physical therapists rehabilitation hospital in Seoul metropolitan area responded. Frequency analysis, χ² test and independent t-test were conducted to evaluate differences between groups about variables of internship satisfaction survey, general characteristics, work and educational environments with using the PASW 18.0 statistical program. The results of the study were as follows. There were significant differences of intern physical therapists between university hospitals and rehabilitation hospitals in overall scores of internship satisfaction and scores of all sub-items such as duty, supervision, working condition, work mates and wages. Intern physical therapists working in the university hospitals showed higher satisfaction than that of Intern physical therapists working in the rehabilitation hospitals.

大岩山의 植物相

閔雄基,張珍成,全正壹,金輝,崔道烈,鄭承洙 서울대학교 수목원 2000 서울大學校 樹木園 硏究報告 Vol.- No.20

This study was carried out to investigate the flora of Mts. Dae-am, Dae-woo, Baek-suk, and Sa-myung located on the east side of DMZ in province Yang-gu-gun, from July 1999 to August 2000. Although two hundred and fifty eight vascular plant taxa (70 families 167 genera) were recorded, this was only a part of representatives in this community because of the restrictin of collections within the military zone. The overall forest stand age of this area was 40 to 50 years, but occasionally ca 70 years old trees were found. We reported 11 taxa of the rare and endangered species proposed by the Ministry of Environment in this area. The Yong-neup, the only high altitude (alt. 1,200m) moore in south Korea, are located in the peak of Mt. Dae-am-san. Some species of this moore (Carex chordorrhiza Ehrh., Carex limosa L., and Gentiana jamesii Hemsl.) - were only found in south Korea. This moor would suffer vegetation change by natural moorland succession and human disturbances. The long-term monitoring of variation of annual vegetation, species distribution, numbers and distribution pattern of individuals of rare species are recommended for the wetland conservation.

철근 이음형 PC 보-기둥 내부 접합부의 구조적 거동에 관한 실험적 연구

김승훈,하상수,문정호,이리형,이강철,전병갑 대한건축학회 2004 대한건축학회 학술발표대회 논문집 - 계획계/구조계 Vol.24 No.1(구조계)

In this study, new moment-resisting precast concrete beam-column joint is proposed for moderate seismic regions. It has the connection reinforcing bars, penetrated the joint and lap-spliced with the bottom bars of precast U-beam. An experimental study was carried out to investigate the joint behavior subjected to reverse cyclic loading and constant axial compressive load. Three precast beam-column interior were tested. The variables examined were the type of connection reinforcing bars and presence of transverse reinforcement in joint. Joint performance is evaluated on the basis of connection .strength, stiffness, energy dissipation, and drift capacity. Based on the test results, the precast connection is capable of matching or exceeding the performance of the monolithic connection and thereby provides the sufficient moment-resisting behavior to be applicable for moderate seismic regions.

AGV 용 서스펜션의 진동 모드에 관한연구 : 중력 가속도가 5G인 경우 A Case of Gravity Acceleration is 5G

주만식,김민주,이승수,최영철,추정근,김중완,전언찬 한국공작기계학회 2000 한국공작기계학회 추계학술대회논문집 Vol.2000 No.-

This study is to choose the most proper model for AGV throughout simulation of behavior of suspension to reduce trial and error because there is no AGV treating heavy weight at harbor loading and unloading at home. Therefore, we estimate the vibration modes of the various suspension applied to AGV, which is over 75 ton included the weight of two containers on 5G using the Matlab, one of the simulation programs

중력가속도의 변화에 따른 자동운반차량용 서스펜션의 진동모드에 관한 연구

주만식,김민주,이승수,최영철,추정근,김중완,전언찬 동아대학교 해양자원연구소 2000 硏究論文集 Vol.13 No.1

This study is to choose the most proper model for AGV Throughout simulation of behavior of suspension to reduce trial and error because there is no AGV treating heavy weight at harbor loading and unloading at home. Therefore, we estimate the vibration modes of the various suspensions applied to AGV, which is over 75 ton included the weight of two containers using the Matlab in the case of G and 5G, one of the simulation programs.

구개결 언어에 대한 Screening test와 설문조사의 비교분석

임재석,권종진,장현석,박영준,최철민,전상호,장수정 大韓顎顔面成形再建外科學會 2001 Maxillofacial Plastic Reconstructive Surgery Vol.23 No.6

Purpose : This study was carried out to evaluate the abnormalites of the speeches of the cleft patients and compare the results of the speech evaluations of a speech pathologist with those of parents. Materials and Methods: Eleven cleft patients' parents were questioned about their children's speech and then the speeches of the cleft patients were evaluated by a speech pathologist and their results were compared with those of parents. Results : Nasal emission was noted in twenty percent of patients, with thirty percent demonstrating hypernasality and all demonstrating no hyponasality and aspirate. And twenty percent of patients show hoarseness. There was no statistically significant difference in the sensitivities to nasal emission between the speech pathologist and parents (p>0.05). However the speech pathologist is more sensitive to hypernasality than parents(p<0.05).