영화 ‘김광석’에 비추어본 김광석법과 공소시효배제: 공동체적 관점과 피해자적 관점을 중심으로

김혜경(Kim, Hye-Kyung) 한국피해자학회 2019 被害者學硏究 Vol.27 No.2

영화 ‘김광석’과 관련하여 형사법적으로는 몇가지 영화의 내적·외적 쟁점이 부각되어 왔다. 소위 ‘모델영화’라고 동 영화는 김광석의 사망(영화에서는 이를 변사자라고 표현한다)과 관련하여 이미 공소시효가 만료된 사건의 공소시효에 대한 진정소급효가 가능한가의 문제이다. 동 영화는 그의 죽음이 자살인지 타살인지 다시 재조사 할 것을 주장한다. 다만, 그와 같은 재조사가 수사의 단서로서 국가형사사법기관에 의한 적법한 절차로 이행하기 위해서는 공소시효가 만료되지 않아야 한다. 그러나 동 사건은 2007년 개정된 현행 형사소송법 제249조 및 2015년 신설된 소위 태완이법이라 칭해지는 형사소송법 제253조의2 살인죄 공소시효배제규정에 의하더라도 공소권이 부존재하다는 결론에 이른다. 따라서 법의 제정 또는 관련법의 개정을 통해 공소시효에 관한 규정을 새로이 정립한다고 한들, 그와 같은 관련법의 진정소급효를 인정하지 않는 한 김광석의 사망은 여전히 수사 또는 공소제기가 불가능하다. 그 결과 소위 ‘김광석법’을 제정한다고 한들, 그 자체가 진정소급효의 법적 승인이 핵심내용이 되어야 하는 것이다. 여기에서는 의문사 사건의 공소시효의 진정소급효를 예외적으로 인정할 것인가 여부에 대하여 우선 공소시효의 법적 성질 및 그 함의를 살펴보고, 소위 김광석법의 본질이 진정소급효이어야 하는지를 법리적으로 검토한 후에, 그 판단을 국가형벌권 및 공동체가치의 측면, 그리고 피해자적 관점에서 논의하고자 한다. 물론 법리적 결론과 현실적 필요성 사이에 괴리가 발생할 수 있고, 그것이 우리의 법생활에서 지극히 예외적인 일은 아니다. 이를 법적 공백이라고 하며 입법론적 문제로 다루고 있다. 결론적으로 공소시효제도는 헌법원리를 직접 반영하는 제도가 아니므로, 사법제도가 어떠한 형사정책적 목적을 추구하는가에 따라, 그리고 사회구성원들의 법감정의 변화에 따라 그 존치, 중단 또는 배제가 좌우된다. 그리고 우리 형사사법은 공소시효제도를 원칙적으로 인정하면서 헌정질서파괴범죄와 같은 반인륜적 범죄들에 대하여 특별법의 제정을 통해 그 중단이나 배제의 진정소급효를 허용하는 방식을 취하고 있다. 여기에서는 살인죄의 공소시효에 대하여도 진정소급효를 인정할 수 있겠는가의 문제를 몇 가지 논거를 통해 긍정하고자 하였다. 물론 이 역시도 형사정책적 영역이므로 살인죄 공소시효의 진정소급효에 대한 찬성이나 반대 중 어느 한 쪽이 완전한 정의일수도 없고 완벽하게 옳을 수도 없다. 다만, 법리적 측면뿐만 아니라 공동체 전체의 시대감정과 연대성의 차원에서 접근한다면 보다 정치한 논거를 찾아낼 수 있지 않을까 한다. The movie titled “Kim Gwang Seok” showed in 2017 was focused on his lifetime, especially his death. He led popular movement in 1980’s as well-known song and his song has been loved even now. He passed away in 6. Jan. 1996 and investigative authority reached conclusions of his death as suicide after drinking but director of this movie as well as journalist has entertained a suspicion about announcement of investigative authority and had ridden down his death and expressed that in accidental death. But his death or accidental death passed over statute of limitations on murder at this point in time. As that result, although the true criminal would be found, he/she couldn’t be under indictment in this case. Statute of limitations means a legislative enactment prescribing the period of time within which proceedings must be instituted to enforce a right or bring an action at law. That system is accepted for offender, because this is justified for considering of legal stability as time passed. In addition, the reason that it is impossible for investigative authority to attain proof after long time because physical evidence may be scattered and lost, which makes it extremely difficult to have a fair trial, can make to reduce the criminal justice costs. But Legislative proposal of a so-called ‘Kim Gwang Seok Bill’ suggests the retroactive effect of statute of limitations on murder. This proposal presents a question, that what is substantial justice in our society. Similarly to respond to this question, the revised Criminal Procedure Law so-called, ‘Taewan-Law’ acted in 2015 abolishes the statutes of limitations on the murder crimes. But this revision couldn’t be retroactively appled in the Kim’s case because statute of limitations on his case had been statute-barred in 2011 already before ‘Taewan-Law’ was in effect for murder crime. So new bill is to be enacted for crime of expiration of the statute of limitations like Kim’s case inevitably and legalistically.

개구장애를 동반한 피부근염 환자 증례

김혜경,김기석,김미은,Kim, Hye-Kyung,Kim, Ki-Suk,Kim, Mee-Eun 대한안면통증구강내과학회 2010 Journal of Oral Medicine and Pain Vol.35 No.2

Dermatomyositis (DM) is an idiopathic inflammatory connective tissue disorder and a systemic autonomic immune disease which shows a progressive muscle weakness and characteristic rash. It is identified by a characteristic rash accompanying, or more often preceding muscle weakness. Pathognomonic skin lesions are a blue-purple discoloration on the upper eyelids with edema (heliotropic rash), a flat red rash on the face and upper trunk, and erythema of the knuckles with a raised violaceous scaly eruption (Gottron's papule). The myopathy represents inflammatory and degenerative changes primarily affecting proximal muscles. DM often involves GI tract and respiratory system with as risk of 15-25% internal malignancy. It's managed with sun protection since muscle weakness as well as a rash could be aggravated by sun exposure. Systemic corticosteroid is an initial therapy and other immunosuppressive agent has been used as alternatives. Facial muscles are unaffected and masticatory muscles are rarely affected in DM. We present trismus close to muscle contracture in a patient with DM. Therefore, it needs continuous mouth-opening exercise to prevent progressive muscle contracture and to ensure normal mouth opening.

토르소 원형설계를 위한 피복인간공학적 분석방법

김혜경,서추연,석은영,강죽형,김지선,김혜수,허지혜,Kim, Hye-Gyeong,Seo, Chu-Yeon,Seok, Eun-Yeong,Gang, Juk-Hyeong,Kim, Ji-Seon,Kim, Hye-Su,Heo, Ji-Hye 대한인간공학회 2000 大韓人間工學會誌 Vol.19 No.1

The purpose of this study was to provide basic data for a more functional torso's pattern by analyzing multidimensional anthropometric measurements and the wearing condition. For the functional torso's pattern drafting, the fitness state of basic torso's patterns(4 types) was compared and evaluated from the cross-sectioned overlap maps by $moir{\acute{e}}$ topography. The results were as follows: 1. According to the measurements of four patterns by using the one-dimensional measurement, the amount of ease in girth item for pattern A was the smallest. The ease of clothes was affected by the position of dart, the amount of dart, and the drafting method. 2. As the results of wearing evaluation by $moir{\acute{e}}$ topography method, pattern B had the largest space length for hip part, pattern A, C and D had the largest space length for bust part. Also, in the all measurement items, pattern A had the smallest amount of ease. The space length for bust and waist part of pattern B was smaller than pattern D, but, for abdomen and hip part of pattern B was larger than pattern D. The space length of pattern C was revealed intermediate for all measurement part. 3. The significant difference of space length of each pattern was shown in all parts except bust part(p<.05). The amount of space was affected by the amount of dart, the characteristics of the somatotype, and the drafting method.

정중과잉치의 자가이식을 통한 상실된 상악 중절치의 수복 : 증례보고

김혜경,박호원,이주현,서현우,Kim, Hye-Kyoung,Park, Ho-Won,Lee, Ju-Hyun,Seo, Hyun-Woo 대한소아치과학회 2007 大韓小兒齒科學會誌 Vol.34 No.3

과잉치는 정상 치판의 과도한 증식의 결과로 발생하고, 주로 상악 전방부에서 많이 발견되며 이것을 정중과잉치라 칭한다. 정중과잉치의 존재 시 영구 전치의 위치 이상, 정중이개, 낭종의 형성, 구강 및 비강 내로의 맹출 등과 같은 다양한 문제가 존재하게 되므로 발거하는 것이 일반적이다. 본 증례는 외상으로 인해 편측 상악 중절치를 조기에 상실하였고, 매복된 상악 정중과잉치를 가지고 있는 9세 8개월된 남아로, 정중과잉치를 상실된 상악 중절치 부위에 자가이식한 후 보철적으로 수복하여 치조골 흡수를 막고 심미적인 수복을 도모한 증례이다. 이 증례에서 과잉치는 총 길이 14mm로 지대치로 사용하기에는 크기가 작고 치관/치근 비율도 좋지 않아 예후가 불량할 것으로 예상하였으나, 시술 후 8개월의 관찰 기간 동안 양호한 결과를 나타내어 이에 보고하는 바이다. Supernumerary tooth is developed from overgrowth of dental laminar and is mainly observed in the maxillary anterior area, named 'mesiodens. Mesiodens cause many problems such as malposition of permanent anterior tooth, diastema, formation of cyst, and eruption to oral or nasal cavity. Extraction, therefore, is generally recommended choice of treatment. This case report describes that the patient is a 9 years and 8 months old boy, whose unilateral maxillary incisor was missing due to trauma, and he had a mesiodens. We practiced autotransplantation of the mesiodens to the missing maxillary central incisor area and then restored with prosthetics, substantially kept out alveolar bony resorption and provided esthetic appearance. Mesiodens was too small to be used as an abutment because its length is totally 14mm, so that poor prognosis was anticipated due to bad crown/root ratio. However, we observed clinically acceptable result during the observation period of 8 months after operation.

결혼이주여성과 한국여성의 양육 스트레스 비교

김혜경 ( Hae Kyeong Kim ),이은희 ( Eun Hee Lee ) 서울대학교 간호과학연구소 2014 간호학의 지평 Vol.11 No.2

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to compare parenting stress between married migrant women and Korean women. Methods: Subjects were 68 married migrant women and 70 Korean women raising children aged seven years or younger, living in three different cities in Gangwon Do. To measure parenting stress, we used Kim`s (1997) questionnaire that had been modified from Richard & Abidin`s (1990) Parenting Stress Index (PSI). Results: There were significant differences between the two groups in age, academic credentials, job, monthly income, and achievement of maternal role. No statistically significant differences were found for parenting stress scores (p<.355), but there was a significant difference in the child characteristics of parenting stress (p<.007) between the two groups. There were no differences in the demographic variables influencing parenting stress between the two groups. Conclusion: The development of multi-cultural parenting and family support programs should consider the nationality and marital satisfaction of the family.

목운동에 따른 목과 어깨부위의 체표변화에 관한 연구

김혜경,박순지,서추연,석은영,Kim, Hae-Kyung,Park, Soon-Jee,Suh, Chu-Yeon,Suk, Eun-Young 대한인간공학회 2002 大韓人間工學會誌 Vol.21 No.1

With the wide range of movement, the movement of neck accompanies the body surface change of neck and shoulders. And neck corresponds to the collar of garment, meaning that the body surface change of this part affects the construction of patterns for collars. So the purpose of this study was to manifest the changes of body surface in the neck and shoulder accompanied with the movement of the neck and to draw up the facts worth consideration when constructing the collar pattern. In this study, the draft of body surface of neck and shoulder was drawn up by gypsum method according to the 5 movements (standing at attention, neck bending - front, back, right, left). The length of body surface was measured and analyzed by ANOVA, post hoc test, correlation and regression analysis using SPSS 10.0 for Windows. The variation of the surface of neck was remarkable in the vertical lines than the horizontal ones. So the height of collar should be established considering the range of movement of the neck. It was the raising amount of c.f(center front) of neck and girth of neckbase (back) that were proved to have significantly varied after movement. With correlation analysis done, in every movement, the raising amount of side and the girth of neckbase had remarkably positive relation. The movement of the neck accompanied the variation of body surface in the shoulder as well. It was the part of scapula and side of neckbase that the variation was notable, suggesting that the surplus is needed in these parts.

논문편 : 인대 제작을 위한 인체계측 및 체형 분류 (1) - 국민학교 1 , 2학년 아동을 대상으로 -

김혜경,전은경 ( Hae Kyung Kim,Eun Kyung Jeon ) 대한가정학회 1992 Family and Environment Research Vol.30 No.3

범이론적 모형에 근거한 성인의 운동실천행위 분석

김혜경,Kim, Hye-Gyeong 한국건강관리협회 2005 한국건강관리협회지 Vol.3 No.2

This study examined the applicability of the transtheoretical model(TTM) to understanding exercise behavior of early adulthood. A cross-sectional study was conducted and data wee collected from 1618 adults aged from 20 to 39 through internet survey. Major conclusions wee as follows: 1. Stage distribution for exercise behavior was 15.6%, 26%, 25%, 19%, 14.4% for precentemplation, contemplation, preparation, action, maintenance stages, respectively. 2. Behavioral processes were more frequently utilized than cognitive processes for action and maintenance stage. 3. Self-reevaluation, social liberation and reinforcement were frequently used in precontemplation, contemplation and preparation stages. Self-reevaluation, reinforcement, self-liberation were frequently used in action and maintenance stages. 4. Pros of exercise behavior began to be higher than cons of exercise behavior from the actions stage and continued to increase to maintenance stage. 5. Self-efficacy was higher in action stage than precontemplation, contemplation and preparation stages and the highest in maintenance stage.

일반화된 분수 지배게임에 대한 균형성

김혜경,박준표,Kim, Hye-Kyung,Park, Jun-Pyo 한국데이터정보과학회 2009 한국데이터정보과학회지 Vol.20 No.1

A cooperative game often arises from domination problem on graphs and the core in a cooperative game could be the optimal solution of a linear programming of a given game. In this paper, we define a {k}-fractional domination game which is a specific type of fractional domination games and find the core of a {k}-fractional domination game. Moreover, we may investigate the balancedness of a {k}-fractional domination game using a concept of a linear programming and duality. We also conjecture the concavity for {k}-fractional dominations game which is important problem to find the elements of the core. 게임이론 중 특히 협력게임은 종종 그래프에서의 지배문제로에 기인하며, 협력게임에서의 코어는 바로 이에 대한 선형프로그램의 최적해가 될 수 있다. 이 논문에서는, 분수 지배게임의 특수한 형태인 분수 지배게임을 새롭게 정의하며, 분수 지배게임의 코어를 찾는다. 더욱이 선형 프로그래밍과 그 쌍대성 개념을 이용하여 {k}-분수 지배게임의 균형성을 조사한다. 또한 코어의 원소를 찾기 위한 중요한 문제가 되는 오목성에 있어서 분수 지배게임도 오목성을 가질 것이라고 추축해본다.

비타민,제대로 알고 먹자-오메가3지방산, 오메가6지방산, 비타민E

김혜경,Kim, Hye-Gyeong 한국건강관리협회 2008 건강소식 Vol.32 No.7

미량으로도 성장을 저지시키거나 결핍증을 초래하고, 일부를 제외하고는 체외에서 합성되지 않거나 합성된다 하더라도 필요량을 충족할 수 없어 외부로부터 공급받아야 하는 비타민. 땀을 많이 흘리는 여름은 다른 계절에 비해 체력이 떨어지게 마련인데, 이때 비타민 섭취는 필수. 오메가3지방산과 오메가6지방산, 비타민E에 대해 좀 더 자세히 알아보고, 술과 담배를 좋아하는 남편, 한창 성장하는 아이들, 관절이 좋지 않는 어르신들을 위한 맞춤형 비타민을 준비해보자.