1980/90년대 영국 보수당 정부 사회서비스 개혁에 대한 재조명: 정치사상과의 관계를 중심으로 = The role of political ideology: Reviewing Social Services Reform of the Conservative Government in 1980s and 90s Britain

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In order to discuss the current expansion of social services in Korea through market-based system, we need to examine whether this could be considered as natural development of social policy after internationally experienced 'state failure', or another political choice, which should be challenged by other alternatives. Therefore, in this study, policy approach of social services reform by the Conservative Government in the 1980s and 90s Britain is defined with the contemporary academic discussion through content analysis of key policy documents and compared to the political ideology of the Government. The result shows contextual consistency between the policy approach and the ideology of the Government. Also its approach has sharp contrast not only with previous Old Labour Governments' but also with next New Labour's. This implies causal role of political ideology in policy development.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이영범, "효과적인 사회서비스 시장화를 위한 지역적 특성에 관한 연구: 지역선택형 지역사회서비스 투자사업을 중심으로" 서울행정학회 20 (20): 163-191, 2010

2 강혜규, "확대정책과 지역사회 사회복지서비스 공급체계" 25 : 67-98, 2008

3 남찬섭, "최근 사회복지서비스 변화의 함의와 전망 - 지방이양, 바우처, 노인장기요양보험으로 인한 변화를 중심으로 한 탐색적 고찰" 28 : 7-49, 2009

4 오혜경, "영국 지역사회보호 서비스의 생성, 변천 및 평가(정신보건 서비스 중심)" 3 : 99-121, 1996

5 김보영, "영국 신노동당 정부의 사회서비스 개혁 방향과 전략 연구" 한국사회복지정책학회 36 (36): 127-152, 2009

6 김보영, "영국 블레어 정부의 정치사상에 대한 분석 및 한국에의 함의" 한국사회복지정책학회 36 (36): 83-112, 2009

7 황덕순, "시장원리 확대와 개인사회서비스의 변화-영국의 사례" 한국노동연구원 8 (8): 63-91, 2008

8 김종해, "사회서비스의 시장화, 무엇을 위한 것인가" 2008

9 감정기, "사회서비스, 어떻게 볼 것인가" 2007

10 김용득, "사회서비스 정책의 동향과 대안 - 시장 기제와 반-시장 기제의 통합" 한국사회복지연구회 (36) : 5-28, 2008

11 Royal Commission, "With respect to old age: long term care - rights and responsibilities:a report by the Royal Commission on Long Term Care" The StationeryOffice 1999

12 Lelliott, P., "Who pays for community care? The same oldquestion" 307 (307): 991-994, 1993

13 Knapp, M., "Volunteer participation incommunity care" 24 (24): 171-192, 1996

14 Wistow, G., "User involvement in community care: origins, purposes andapplications" 71 (71): 279-299, 1993

15 Scrivens, E, "Towards a theory of rationing" 13 (13): 53-64, 1979

16 Hunter, D. J, "To market! To market! A new dawn for community care" 1 (1): 3-10, 1993

17 Hatch, S, "The voluntary sector: a larger role? in Anew look at the personal social services" Policy Studies Institute 1981

18 Giddens, A, "The third way : the renewal of social democracy" Policy press 1999

19 CSCI, "The state of social care in England 2007-08" Commission for Social CareInspection 2009

20 CSCI, "The state of social care in England 2005-06" Commission for Social CareInspection 2006

21 Care Quality Commission, "The state of health care and adult social care in England: Keythemes and quality of services in 2009" The Stationery Office 2009

22 Kim, B.-Y, "The role of political ideology in the policy development of personal socialservices from the 1960s to 2000s Britain" University of York 2008

23 Lewis, J., "The purchaser/provider split in socialcare: is it working" 30 (30): 1-19, 1996

24 Jefferys, M, "The over-eighties in Britain: the social construction of panic" 4 (4): 367-372, 1983

25 Cooper, J, "The mosaic of personal social services: public, voluntary and private" 18 : 237-250, 1988

26 Osborne, S. P, "The management of need--the role of case management and theallocation of community care resources" 17 : 5-12, 1991

27 Ramon, S, "The logic of pragmatism in mental health policy: the implications of thegovernment position on mental health in the 1959 debate for the 80s" 2 (2): 38-54, 1982

28 Levick, P, "The janus face of community care legislation: an opportunity for radicalpossibilities" 12 (12): 75-92, 1992

29 West, P, "The family, the welfare state and community care: political rhetoric and publicattitudes" 13 (13): 417-446, 1984

30 Goldberg,E.M, "The effectiveness of social care: a selective exploration" 17 : 595-614, 1987

31 Deakin, N, "The devils in the detail: some reflections on contracting for social care byvoluntary organizations" 30 (30): 20-38, 1996

32 Lewis, J., "The community care changes: unresolved tensionsin policy and issues in implementation" 24 (24): 73-94, 1995

33 Ellison, N, "The changing politics of social policy IN Development in British social policy" Macmillan 1998

34 Butcher, H, "The 'Community Practice' approach to local public service provision - Ananalysis of recent developments" 21 (21): 107-115, 1986

35 McGrath, M, "Supporting 'needs-led' services: implications for planning andmanagement systems(a case study in mental handicap services" 21 (21): 71-97, 1992

36 Lipsky, M, "Street-level bureaucracy: dilemmas of the individual in public services" Russell Sage 1980

37 Davies, B, "Strategic goals and piecemeal innovations: adjusting to the new balance ofneeds and resources in A new look at thepersonal social services" Policy Studies Institute 1981

38 Giddens,A, "Sociology(5th ed.)" Polity Press 2006

39 Barclay, P. M, "Social workers: their role and tasks" Bedford Square Press 1982

40 Webb, A, "Social work, social care and social planning: the personal social services since Seebohm" Longman 1987

41 Green, S., "Social support and government policy on servicesfor the elderly" 13 (13): 210-218, 1979

42 Hadley, R, "Social services department and the community in A new look at the personal social services" Policy Studies Institute 1981

43 Hudson, B, "Social policy and the New Right-the strange case of the Community CareWhite Paper" 16 : 15-34, 1990

44 Beck, U, "Risk society: towards a new modernity" Sage 1992

45 Bewley, C, "Representing the views of disabled people in communitycare planning" 9 (9): 301-314, 1994

46 Seebohm Committee, "Report of the committee on local authority and allied personalsocial services. Cmnd" Her Majesty's Stationery Office 1968

47 Waterson, J, "Redefining community care social work: needs or risks led" 7 (7): 276-279, 1999

48 White, T, "Recent developments and the response of social service departments in A new look at the personal social services" 1981

49 Bovaird, T., "Public management and governance(2nd ed.)" Routledge 2009

50 Webb, A, "Public expenditure and policy implementation: the case ofcommunity care" 61 : 21-44, 1983

51 DHSS, "Priorities for health and personal social services in England: a consultativedocument" Her Majesty's Stationery Office 1976

52 Harris, J., "Post-Fordism, the welfare state and the personal socialservices: A comparison of Australia and Britain" 30 (30): 51-70, 2000

53 Finlayson, A, "Political science, political ideas and rhetoric" 33 (33): 528-549, 2004

54 Hay, C, "Political analysis" Palgrave 2002

55 Caldock, K, "Policy and practice: fundamental contradictions in the conceptualization ofcommunity care for elderly people" 2 : 133-141, 1994

56 Walker, J, "Policies for Life. Contributions to Family Therapy-Social Policy" 10 (10): 283-306, 1988

57 Webb, A, "Planning, need and scarcity: essays on the personal social services" Allen and Unwin 1986

58 Sullivan, M, "Personal social services in The development of the British welfare state" Prentice Hall/Harvester Wheatsheaf 1996

59 Bilton, K, "Origins, progress and future in Seebohm across threedecades: social services departments past, present and future" BASWPublications 1979

60 Owen, D, "Opening address: social formal and informal patterns of care" 16 : 5-14, 1986

61 Joffe, J, "Note of dissent In With respect to old age: long term care -rights and responsibilities: a report by the Royal Commission on Long Term Care" The Stationery Office 1999

62 Department of Health, "Modernising social service: promoting independence, improvingprotection, raising standards" The Stationery Office 1998

63 Pritchard, C, "Mental health policy" 17 (17): 32-45, 1983

64 Parker, G, "Making the ends meet: do, carers and disabled people have acommon agenda" 30 (30): 347-359, 2002

65 Chesterman, J., "Long-term care at home for the elderly: afour-year follow-up" 18 : 43-53, 1987

66 Challis, D, "Long term care for the elderly: the Community Care Scheme" 15 : 563-579, 1985

67 Smith, T, "Literature review: decentralization and community" 19 : 137-148, 1989

68 Rushton, A, "Literature review: community-based versus hospital-based care for acutelymentally ill people" 20 : 373-383, 1990

69 Shaw, I. F, "Literature review. Consumer evaluations of the personal social services" 14 : 277-284, 1984

70 Dant, T, "Keyworkers for elderly people in the community: case managerand care co-ordinators" 19 (19): 331-360, 1990

71 Bowl, R, "Involving service users in mental health services: social service departmentsand the National Health Service and Community Care Act 1990" 5 (5): 287-303, 1990

72 Richards, D., "Interpreting the world of political elites" 82 (82): 777-800, 2004

73 Olsen, M. R, "Integrating formal and informal social care - the utilization of socialsupport networks" 16 : 15-22, 1986

74 Trnobranski, P. H, "Implementation of community care policy in the United Kingdom: willit be achieved" 21 (21): 988-995, 1995

75 Dalley, G, "Ideologies of caring: rethinking community and collectivism(2nd ed.)" Macmillan 1996

76 Campbell, J. L, "Ideas, politics, and public policy. Annual review of sociology" 28 : 21-38, 2002

77 Béland, D, "Ideas and social policy: an institutionalist perspective" 39 : 1-18, 2005

78 Glennerster, H., "How much do we care" 24 (24): 93-103, 1990

79 Barker, R, "Hooks and hands, interests and enemies: political thinking as political action" 48 (48): 223-238, 2000

80 Statham, D, "Guest editorial: partnership between health and social care" 8 (8): 87-89, 2000

81 DHSS, "Growing older" HMSO 1981

82 Davies, B, "Financing long-term social care: challenges for the nineties" 22 (22): 97-114, 1988

83 Bebbington, A, "Equity and efficiency in the allocation of the personalsocial services" (3) : 309-330, 1983

84 North, N, "Empowerment in welfare markets" 1 : 129-137, 1993

85 Challis, D, "Editorial: community care, social work, and social care" 23 : 319-328, 1993

86 Lunt, N., "Economic discourse and the market: the case ofcommunity care" 74 (74): 369-391, 1996

87 Beresford, P, "Disabled people, service users, user involvement andrepresentation" 9 (9): 315-325, 1994

88 Kim, K.-H, "Development of community care for elderly people in theUK: focused on policy development from 1950s to 1990s" 21 (21): 169-182, 2002

89 Higgins, J, "Defining community care: realities and myths" 23 (23): 3-16, 1989

90 Knapp, M, "Cost information and residential care of the elderly" 1 (1): 199-228, 1981

91 Biggs, S, "Consumers, case management and inspection: obscuring social deprivation andneed" 10 : 23-38, 1991

92 Wilson, G, "Conflicts in case management: the use of staff time in community care" 27 (27): 109-123, 1993

93 Dean, H, "Complaints procedures and individual redress: a note on research in progress" 1 (1): 119-123, 1993

94 Forder, J., "Competition in the mixed economy of care" 25 (25): 201-221, 1996

95 Finch, J, "Community care: developing non-sexist alternatives" 3 (3): 6-18, 1984

96 Griffiths, R, "Community care: agenda for action" HMSO 1988

97 Morris, J, "Community care or independent living" 14 : 24-45, 1994

98 Langan, M, "Community care in the 1990s: the community care White Paper: 'Caring forPeople'" 10 : 58-70, 1990

99 Challis, D., "Community care forthe frail elderly: an urban experiment" 18 : 13-42, 1987

100 Madden, P, "Community care for young adults with disability: issues for social servicesdepartments" 4 (4): 104-108, 1990

101 Marsland, D, "Community care as an alternative to state welfare" 30 (30): 183-188, 1996

102 Phillipson, C, "Community care and the social construction of citizenship" 8 (8): 103-112, 1994

103 Finch, J., "Community care and the family: a case for equal opportunities" 9 (9): 487-511, 1980

104 Walker, A, "Community care and the elderly in Great Britain: theory and practice" 11 (11): 541-557, 1981

105 DH, "Community Care Statistics 1999: Home help/home care services" Department of Health Publications 1999

106 Bessell, R, "Comment on Tom White's paper by Robert Bessell in A new look at the personal social services" Policy Studies Institute 1981

107 Home Office, "Children in trouble" Her Majesty's Stationery Office 1968

108 Means, R, "Charging and quasi-markets in community care: implicationsfor elderly people with dementia" 30 (30): 244-262, 1996

109 Biehal, N, "Changing practive: participation, rights and community care" 23 : 443-458, 1993

110 Cambridge, P, "Case managment in community services: organizational responses" 22 : 495-517, 1992

111 Huxley, P, "Case management and care management in community care" 23 : 365-381, 1993

112 DHSS, "Caring for people: community care in the next decade and beyond" HMSO 1989

113 DHSS, "Care in the community: a consultative document on moving resources for carein" Department of Health and Social Security 1981

114 HM Government, "Building the National Care Service" The Stationery Office 2010

115 Hudson, J., "Between ideas, institutions and interests:Analysing third way welfare reform programmes in Germany and the UnitedKingdom" 37 (37): 207-230, 2008

116 DHSS, "Better services for the mentally ill" Her Majoesty's Stationery Office 1975

117 DHSS, "Better services for the mentally handicapped" Her Majesty's Stationery Office 1971

118 Jordan, B, "Association and exclusion in the organisation of social care" 6 (6): 5-18, 1995

119 Challis, D, "Assessment and casemanagement: some cost implications" 1 (1): 147-162, 1989

120 Cornwell, N, "Assessment and accountability in community care" 12 : 40-52, 1996

121 Hudson, B, "Adult care in Local authority social services: an introduction" Blackwell Publishers 2000

122 Barnes, M, "Achieving a strategy for user involvement in communitycare" 2 : 347-356, 1994